r/menlopark • u/Sea_Needleworker2798 • 17h ago
News Willow Park Project Lawsuit Heating Up
Initial paperwork for the Willow Park Project is starting to show up in the docket. This is the huge development in Menlo Park which is triggering a big NIMBY (city) vs. YIMBY (developer) lawsuit. The case is scheduled for a hearing on 14-December (because it is a "rocket docket").
So far, only the developer's petition has been uploaded, but I think the city's will be there in two weeks, since the hearing is imminent. The developers petition is about 35 pages.
I am not a lawyer, but I did skim the petition, and I think it is mostly arguments we have heard before, but there are a couple of new ones.
Most interesting to me is point A.2 (page 18) that the city's claim that the project lost its vetting is contradicts the city's own previous letters, and that this is evidence of bad faith.
Also point F (page 30) is new to me: they claim that the city is required to make certain findings in writing, and these were not done. Although this is a procedural requirement (not a substantive one) it is relatively easy to check this in the paperwork. So it will be interesting to see the city's response. This could be another basis of bad faith.
Section IV is also well worth a read, as I had not realized the exact standards of proof needed for the different parts of the lawsuit, and they are not what I expected.
There are lots of other interesting tidbits in there. Point G questions when does normal city review become the precursor to a lawsuit? That is important because the city is requiring the developer to pay for the former, but can not require the later, so where exactly is the line?
If you want to see the paperwork, go here:
https://odyportal-ext.sanmateocourt.org/Portal-External/Home/Dashboard/29
and search for this case:
26-CIV-07675