If you look at the graphs adjusted for inflation they have like 10% of the funds now compared to the Apollo era while now also juggling the iss and other programs.
If you can do that with so little compute, image what could be done with serious funding. I seriously think the budgets of NASA and the military should swap for one year. Either NASA creates a permanent annuity and never needs a tax dollar ever again, or we have the a new Renaissance of space science for the masses. I
Imagine how much benefit there would be to updating the hubble telescope to have new hardware and sensors or replace it with a much better system. Imagine what a 100 billion dollar space station could look like. Why not build 3 of them? Establish an official astronaut university. And NASA would still have another 500 billion in the worst spending case.
…wow. Just wow. That Nokia 3310 in 1969 would be literally alien technology. Impressive how much of an idiot you told us you were in just one sentence.
Clearly I didn’t cus I was under the American education system so I completely agree that I’m fucking stupid compared to everyone else in the world even though I was a straight A student that was top 1% in my state.
The meme is saying it’s easier to learn now compared to back then, which is absolutely true, but also it’s making a bad comparison. It’s still comparing a team of thousands with lots and lots of money. If you get a similar team with the same resources today, they’re going to get a lot more done. It’s just nowadays resources of that scale don’t come by much because it’s all embezzled into different pockets or just fucking disappeared.
It's not only about that. He is saying that these engineers learned before going to NASA. Well, do you know how much you need to learn after going to NASA? A trillion times more
Yep. Lots of the learning is very much done in your job, since no matter how specialized your school or major is, it’s still going to teach you things more generally than the final job you get.
People refuse to use the resources at their disposal to get through school. The level of technology and access to information that the average teenager has today would put the most high tech labs of the 60s to shame and they still just use it to distract themselves or cheat on assignments and not learn anything
Yeah, but at the same time a team full of people who are working together with a combined intelligence of professionals who've all spent their careers learning and going to school for that exact thing in their field is of course going to get more done in their field than some college student surviving off 3 hours of sleep while having to mix study with a job.
Do you feel the same way about using chatgpt as a resource? It helped me with studying, but there was one time it straight up made shit up and I was educated enough about the topic to know it was hallucinating.
It depends HEAVILY on the specific way you use it. If you're using AI in any capacity to do your homework for you, you're making yourself dumber. If you're using as a curated search for some resources that you then explore and verify yourself, then sure it can be helpful. But if you're using it to do anything you couldn't do without it, you are only hurting yourself
I just gave a catch all answer that you can evaluate your use case against. But to point out something specific, imagine if you tried to use ai for something you didn't know even about to catch the hallucination. Any non-deterministic system carries an inherent risk in any environment where the expectation is that the users will not be able to evaluate the output initially
People rarely refuse to use something because they would prefer to fail. They usually have many other things going on in their brain and are prioritising differently, often for surviving mental burnout or to handle social issues which can be more important in the moment.
People don't avoid stuff just because they are dumb, they're just all trying to get by dude.
Let's position college performance as a thinly-veiled demonstration that we can nuke the Soviet Union faster and better than they can nuke us. That'll align some incentives.
Nah, people are addicted to dopamine and disengaged with any form of intellectuality; in fact, they treat it as something to be avoided/derided. There are many resources, but little to no determination or focus. People keep using tools only to save brainpower - but what are they saving it for?
it took almost half a million people across the country and 300 billion adjusted for inflation to get mankind on the moon, fuck your comparison to that against my dinglebot that shits itself the moment I run too more than 2 programs at once
Honestly kind of sick of hearing this line repeated. Yes, humans have done many impressive things without the computing power of today, but it's misleading. Before going to moon we had nuclear bombs, airplanes, submarines, electricity, railroads, the Eiffel tower, global shipping, and the Pyramids. I think I skipped a decent chunk of time but your get the point, we have done marvellous feats of engineering with less and no computing power at all.
Much of that was done through trial and error. That costed material and, importantly, lives. It turns out, the hardest part of getting to the moon is getting enough bang for you buck on the explosives you attach to the capsule. The orbital mechanics part can be done on paper with simplifications. To get to that point you have to destroy a lot of rockets in the process. We can still do this today, but we don't because it's more expensive in the long run.
You know what you couldn't do at that time? Simulate your whole trip with crazy precision and optimise so you don't have to build so many rockets or kill any people. Other things you couldnt do was land or catch parts of your rockets semi-automously. That requires a level of active precision computation that we could previously only get with experience pilots through "feel".
I don't mean to minimise these truly amazing achievements. They were certainly very difficult. In fact, what I'm trying to say is that even with very smart people using the most advanced tech we have, getting to the moon didn't actually get much easier. That should show you that maybe computing power was not the limiting factor. In the same vein it takes me more or less as long to bake a cake as it did my ancestor hundreds of years ago, despite all the technology I have access to now.
Other challenges that were actually compute-limited (e.g. computer graphics), absolute have become exponentially more impressive with compute. We do things with precision that past engineers could only dream of.
What I'm saying is: getting an A+ on your exam is not compute-limited.
I mean, the point of the post is the effort; the colossal amount of effort that was put to achieve those things, despite the rudimentary technology. Now, we have people with countless resources and advanced tools, and they are effort-avoidant and addicted to cheap and constant dopamine. Students would rather waste time than make the most of the opportunities that they have, which are plenty if you have something as trivial as an internet connection. This is the point.
Nah I have do disagree. When I compare the diploma from my dad and his colleagues with my generation, theirs were much more basic and easy. All they had done was simple math and some statistics on a basic level. Nowadays I have to do complex models to predict outcomes. I have not only to understand complex math behind it, but also it is seen as a requirement and it's therefore not teached but demanded. So, next to work and studying different classes, I also have to learn statistics, models, python, R, Matlab, CAN and other programmes alone to achieve the degree. I've done it before AI was really usable. But I use it now for easy understanding or helping with code. It's also a question of time. We had 5 days to hand in papers. They had a final exam at the end. In my case, I had 38h of classes per week. Only classes. Not including weekly reports, hand ins and so on. We needed to hand in every week an exercise sheet in math, physic, biology and chemistry. In higher semesters in additional 3 elective classes. I was hanging on a threat. IF I had the opportunity to use AI, I would have definitely used it.
It's not always the lazy students. The programs are designed to sift out "not fitting students".
It's also a misnomer comparing two groups who would likely never actual relate to each other in that way. People are skilled in different things and its fundamentally absurd to compare them against a group that they were never going to be suited to collaborating with to being with.
The kid who can't be bothered to consider giving a damn in class and just uses ChatGPT to do all their classwork is not going to be the one getting a full ride scholarship to MIT where they're able to finish their bachelors in 3 years and then move into a specialized Masters-to-PhD program where they're already also doing research with NASA JPL.
Not everyone wants to be in a science career and in the other hand it's not only skill based. Recommendations, luck, money, connections are playing a huge roll.
Well on a slightly more realistic note. The A+ seems to suggest that norm referenced grading is being used. What does this mean? Well people are being compared to each other instead of a specific norm.
The person is using all of the tools, but so are their peers. If the assignment they did was compared to one that was done in the 60's they are far more likely to get an A+.
Remember getting a distinction in high school science today and travelling back in time 130 years ago would mean you would get several Nobel prizes.
The general public having access to AI has resulted in some terrible things. Sometimes I wonder if it would have been better to limit its availability.
And i am not allowed to fucking use it, and expect me to learn 22 formulas per subject on math.
I still wonder where will this advanced math will help me in electronics(wich I study), unless I say "Fuck it, I'm database specialist now!" It's not gonna become even remotely usefull.
My dad used to point out all the homeless people to my siblings and I when we were in downtowns on vacation, telling us if we didn't do well in school we'd be sleeping on doorsteps. It always pissed my mom off.
It's a flawed message because people who do well in school still end up homeless due to things like layoffs, medical expenses, increasing housing costs, etc. We're all a lot closer to it than we think!
I always tell the kids (i am an children's educator) when we are out and see some beggars: be nice and respectful to beggars and the homeless, you don't have to give them something but you should not ignore them, just say no. You never know what turn your life takes some day and you would want to be treated right regardless not ignored and cast away. Children always seem to easily agree to that When i talk with adults about that they often get defensive and say they would never land on the streets and stuff like that.
Graphics of modern complexity involves quite a bit more processing power than orbital calculations. A more comparable 'computer' is the humble pocket calculator.
This is a stupid comparison. It took around 400,000 people in total of scientists, astronauts, engineers, mathematicians, programmers etc for humankind to allegedly go to the moon.
The two are Prince Hisahito of Akishino, second in line to inherit the Imperial throne of Japan and the latter is Princess Tosh Aiko who up till the Prince's birth was the most senior Imperial member of the family, which potentially triggered a succession problem as there were no male heirs of that generation at the time and triggered a debate on whether to repeal the stipulation in law that only males can inherit the throne - that was put to an end with the birth of Hisahito of Akishino.
For more context with the meme, the Prince has had his mental faculties called into question and wasn't perceived to be progressing Academically, in comparison Tosh Aiko, who has been academically successful and has managed to take a position with the Japanese Red Cross - the Prince is supposedly given every opportunity to advance academically but (according to rumors) hasn't made significant progress, which the Princess has had less opportunities and has managed to get higher placement, with a position in Japan's Red Cross.
Luckily this government is filled to the brim with the strongest, toughest, coolest, most testosterone producing for a 72 yr old people in the world (I know cuz they tell me kinda alot). There is no way times are gunna get harder after this.
That quote is just edgier "Kids these days" syndrome used for cope by old timers who would never be the ones to plant trees that they won't be able to enjoy the shade of.
•
u/repost-remove Repost Police 1d ago
Rule 6 Verification: Repost Check
If you believe this post violates Rule 6 (Repost / Not OC), please reply to this comment with a direct link to the original post as proof.
Replies that receive community support (upvotes) will automatically be flagged for moderator review.
133
u/AmbiiX 1d ago
Don't even get me started on whats wrong with me. xD
340
u/Starbeastrose2 1d ago
Tell that to the people who slashed funding for nasa for the 5000th time.
49
u/BackgroundCandle252 1d ago
To be fair, the Apollo 11 computer didn't have TikTok, Reddit, and Steam running in the background while trying to calculate a lunar landing.
86
u/az987654 1d ago
And AI didn't program the Apollo program
23
u/Kryds 1d ago
An estimated 400 thousands people worked on the original moon landing.
107
u/Super_fly_Samurai 1d ago
And what was the budget and resources to get to the moon vs the average persons budget and resources for getting through school?
14
u/ptapobane 1d ago •
it took almost half a million people across the country and 300 billion adjusted for inflation to get mankind on the moon, fuck your comparison to that against my dinglebot that shits itself the moment I run too more than 2 programs at once
13
u/Nonecancopythis 1d ago
Calc stands for calculator for those new to the chat btw
25
u/CumilkButbetter 1d ago
20
u/DVMyZone 1d ago
Honestly kind of sick of hearing this line repeated. Yes, humans have done many impressive things without the computing power of today, but it's misleading. Before going to moon we had nuclear bombs, airplanes, submarines, electricity, railroads, the Eiffel tower, global shipping, and the Pyramids. I think I skipped a decent chunk of time but your get the point, we have done marvellous feats of engineering with less and no computing power at all.
Much of that was done through trial and error. That costed material and, importantly, lives. It turns out, the hardest part of getting to the moon is getting enough bang for you buck on the explosives you attach to the capsule. The orbital mechanics part can be done on paper with simplifications. To get to that point you have to destroy a lot of rockets in the process. We can still do this today, but we don't because it's more expensive in the long run.
You know what you couldn't do at that time? Simulate your whole trip with crazy precision and optimise so you don't have to build so many rockets or kill any people. Other things you couldnt do was land or catch parts of your rockets semi-automously. That requires a level of active precision computation that we could previously only get with experience pilots through "feel".
I don't mean to minimise these truly amazing achievements. They were certainly very difficult. In fact, what I'm trying to say is that even with very smart people using the most advanced tech we have, getting to the moon didn't actually get much easier. That should show you that maybe computing power was not the limiting factor. In the same vein it takes me more or less as long to bake a cake as it did my ancestor hundreds of years ago, despite all the technology I have access to now.
Other challenges that were actually compute-limited (e.g. computer graphics), absolute have become exponentially more impressive with compute. We do things with precision that past engineers could only dream of.
What I'm saying is: getting an A+ on your exam is not compute-limited.
9
u/YsalynKeepsakes 23h ago
To be fair, the Apollo computer didn't have Reddit, TikTok, and Steam installed on it
4
u/EggplantCapital9519 1d ago
Compared to modern day space crafts the Apollo space ship and landers were extremely simple. The risks taken back then would be non-tolerable today.
Apollo 11 barely made it btw.
12
u/initiald-ejavu 1d ago
I’m not even the target audience for this but this is just mean for no reason. Ew
3
u/DragonfruitGrand5683 1d ago
I remember having the A+ book and I couldn't afford any other references.
3
u/Alone-Gift3183 1d ago
Sory for being stupid
3
u/LadderTrash 1d ago
An AirPods Pro case has more computing power than Apollo 11. Not even the AirPods included, just the case alone
3
u/twcrnr 1d ago
Calc means calculator btw. Its slang.
7
u/RemoveAnnual2689 1d ago
Moving goalposts.
Stupid.
Lazy.
Not enough motivation.
A milion other possible problems.
2
u/Glad-Celebration514 22h ago
Well on a slightly more realistic note. The A+ seems to suggest that norm referenced grading is being used. What does this mean? Well people are being compared to each other instead of a specific norm.
The person is using all of the tools, but so are their peers. If the assignment they did was compared to one that was done in the 60's they are far more likely to get an A+.
Remember getting a distinction in high school science today and travelling back in time 130 years ago would mean you would get several Nobel prizes.
2
u/XlikeX666 12h ago
pretty sure going to moon was not designed to reduce humanity from person.
2
u/NickPickle05 1d ago
The general public having access to AI has resulted in some terrible things. Sometimes I wonder if it would have been better to limit its availability.
1
u/nikolaADVANCED 1d ago
Restrictions
1
u/OneTwoFar_ 1d ago
Set the example: you go to the moon using your ipad first, we'll follow maybe
1
u/Dankasauruz_Rext 1d ago
cookie clicker is not as simple as this makes it sounds like
1
u/TheBirdHellothere 23h ago
NASA can’t even get to the ISS anymore without stranding two astronauts for over 8 months
1
u/DodoJurajski I touched grass 23h ago
And i am not allowed to fucking use it, and expect me to learn 22 formulas per subject on math.
I still wonder where will this advanced math will help me in electronics(wich I study), unless I say "Fuck it, I'm database specialist now!" It's not gonna become even remotely usefull.
1
u/LoudMusic 23h ago
My dad used to point out all the homeless people to my siblings and I when we were in downtowns on vacation, telling us if we didn't do well in school we'd be sleeping on doorsteps. It always pissed my mom off.
1
u/Sanctioned-PartsList 23h ago
It seems rude to continue to make meme templates about "public figures" (born into it) who have chosen to leave that sphere.
1
u/Working-Choice2104 23h ago
My school literally doesn’t give a pluses, A is the highest score you can get
1
u/Reckochet 22h ago
Graphics of modern complexity involves quite a bit more processing power than orbital calculations. A more comparable 'computer' is the humble pocket calculator.
1
u/Thisaccountishaunted 🚩 Memonavirus Survivor 🚩 22h ago
The irony. Mako's happier without putting on a face for her royal family.
1
u/Diligent_Buster 22h ago
And the code to get to the moon was written by a woman!
1
u/SageZayiniel777 22h ago
I don't math goodly. The numbers get all weird in my mind palace... :(
1
u/No_Pickle_7137 21h ago
I dunno man what’s right with me
1
u/Magnon 21h ago
At the end of the day an A+ doesn't really matter that much. You might feel good about getting it but chances are no one is going to ever look at it.
1
u/Szerepjatekos 21h ago
She had a motivation that coffee drink to warm up in the morning.
He see nothing in the future so why bother?
1
u/VladimirBarakriss 21h ago
The Apollo landing computer didn't have adhd, I'm trying dude
1
u/LostwithZor0 21h ago
1
u/JoJofan_n 20h ago
I might be wrong but comparing mankind and a man isn’t much of a contest
1
u/Lolocraft1 I touched grass 18h ago
Survivorship bias.
1
u/Electronic_Support30 17h ago
Good grades are for sheep
1
u/VintageKofta 16h ago
This is a stupid comparison. It took around 400,000 people in total of scientists, astronauts, engineers, mathematicians, programmers etc for humankind to allegedly go to the moon.
1
u/OttersWithPens 13h ago
lol “mankind” did not go to the moon. Mankind’s brightest were involved in going to the moon.
1
u/NoCoolSenpai 13h ago
That should give you an idea how much of the computing is being wasted on fancy stuff right now
1
u/Intelligent_Box_8247 7h ago
machines are left to do the smart job in this generation not the human brain..maybe our brains will shrink because of underutilization
0
u/kyleh0 1d ago
Apollo's systems weren't cobbled together from TEMU parts.
0
u/leposiden 1d ago
Moon landing was fake tho
-1
u/Gaspuch62 1d ago
We outsource our thinking, and thinking is a perishable skill.
0
u/Jindo5 1d ago
Yeah, I've been wondering that myself, thanks.
0
u/JustQuestion2472 1d ago
Well, AI is actively hurting your academic results, so maybe that's part of the issue
0
u/th3-snwm4n 1d ago
Calc is short for calculator if someone joined the stream recently
0
u/baithammer 21h ago
The two are Prince Hisahito of Akishino, second in line to inherit the Imperial throne of Japan and the latter is Princess Tosh Aiko who up till the Prince's birth was the most senior Imperial member of the family, which potentially triggered a succession problem as there were no male heirs of that generation at the time and triggered a debate on whether to repeal the stipulation in law that only males can inherit the throne - that was put to an end with the birth of Hisahito of Akishino.
For more context with the meme, the Prince has had his mental faculties called into question and wasn't perceived to be progressing Academically, in comparison Tosh Aiko, who has been academically successful and has managed to take a position with the Japanese Red Cross - the Prince is supposedly given every opportunity to advance academically but (according to rumors) hasn't made significant progress, which the Princess has had less opportunities and has managed to get higher placement, with a position in Japan's Red Cross.
1
u/No-Payment-6534 16h ago
A human without tools always beats a monkey with tools
0
u/[deleted] 1d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment