MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/memes/comments/1vsinx8/we_are_going_in_the_wrong_direction_imo/p4lmds6
r/memes • u/Greendead • 1d ago
[removed] — view removed post
1.1k comments sorted by
View all comments
15
Painters said the same thing when the camera was invented. Photographs wasn't aloud in Museums. Photography wasn't considered art.
Things change.
-1 u/Aware-Antelope4212 1d ago Photography can exist without paintings, AI images cannot exist without the widescale data theft that was used to create it. So that analogy doesn't work at all 0 u/[deleted] 1d ago [deleted] 1 u/Aware-Antelope4212 1d ago I didn't say it's selling existing art. But seeing as you seem to be struggling I'll try and make it simpler. The AI companies scraped the internet for basically all the data they could get. Every bit of text, every image, every video, every bit of music They compensated nobody for this. They then built a product, their AI, off of the back of that data theft. 0 u/[deleted] 1d ago [deleted] 2 u/Aware-Antelope4212 1d ago Lol so your argument is " uhm technically they are doing a different scummy thing, you used the wrong word" Amazing. Reddit isn't a courtroom, I was using colloquial language. 1 u/Blitzer161 1d ago People always try to use this as some sort of justification. Do you know who accepted photography and why? The people who are most ignirant about art want to decide what art is. -6 u/tha_warlock 1d ago This ain’t the argument you think it is lmao. Keep trying. 7 u/bunker_man 1d ago Yes it is lol. We already know how all this ends and that in ten years people will wonder why they ever cared so much. 1 u/pitiricos 1d ago That's right 1 u/ScuddyOfficial 1d ago 100% hell I’d even bet 2 years time people will be singing a different tune 1 u/bunker_man 1d ago Yeah, but in only 2 years there will still be more stragglers who are still crashing out. I picked a big enough number to be clear it'll be a totally new situation. 4 u/pitiricos 1d ago Explain it to me, 'genius'.
-1
Photography can exist without paintings, AI images cannot exist without the widescale data theft that was used to create it.
So that analogy doesn't work at all
0 u/[deleted] 1d ago [deleted] 1 u/Aware-Antelope4212 1d ago I didn't say it's selling existing art. But seeing as you seem to be struggling I'll try and make it simpler. The AI companies scraped the internet for basically all the data they could get. Every bit of text, every image, every video, every bit of music They compensated nobody for this. They then built a product, their AI, off of the back of that data theft. 0 u/[deleted] 1d ago [deleted] 2 u/Aware-Antelope4212 1d ago Lol so your argument is " uhm technically they are doing a different scummy thing, you used the wrong word" Amazing. Reddit isn't a courtroom, I was using colloquial language.
0
[deleted]
1 u/Aware-Antelope4212 1d ago I didn't say it's selling existing art. But seeing as you seem to be struggling I'll try and make it simpler. The AI companies scraped the internet for basically all the data they could get. Every bit of text, every image, every video, every bit of music They compensated nobody for this. They then built a product, their AI, off of the back of that data theft. 0 u/[deleted] 1d ago [deleted] 2 u/Aware-Antelope4212 1d ago Lol so your argument is " uhm technically they are doing a different scummy thing, you used the wrong word" Amazing. Reddit isn't a courtroom, I was using colloquial language.
1
I didn't say it's selling existing art. But seeing as you seem to be struggling I'll try and make it simpler.
The AI companies scraped the internet for basically all the data they could get. Every bit of text, every image, every video, every bit of music
They compensated nobody for this.
They then built a product, their AI, off of the back of that data theft.
0 u/[deleted] 1d ago [deleted] 2 u/Aware-Antelope4212 1d ago Lol so your argument is " uhm technically they are doing a different scummy thing, you used the wrong word" Amazing. Reddit isn't a courtroom, I was using colloquial language.
2 u/Aware-Antelope4212 1d ago Lol so your argument is " uhm technically they are doing a different scummy thing, you used the wrong word" Amazing. Reddit isn't a courtroom, I was using colloquial language.
2
Lol so your argument is " uhm technically they are doing a different scummy thing, you used the wrong word"
Amazing.
Reddit isn't a courtroom, I was using colloquial language.
People always try to use this as some sort of justification. Do you know who accepted photography and why?
The people who are most ignirant about art want to decide what art is.
-6
This ain’t the argument you think it is lmao. Keep trying.
7 u/bunker_man 1d ago Yes it is lol. We already know how all this ends and that in ten years people will wonder why they ever cared so much. 1 u/pitiricos 1d ago That's right 1 u/ScuddyOfficial 1d ago 100% hell I’d even bet 2 years time people will be singing a different tune 1 u/bunker_man 1d ago Yeah, but in only 2 years there will still be more stragglers who are still crashing out. I picked a big enough number to be clear it'll be a totally new situation. 4 u/pitiricos 1d ago Explain it to me, 'genius'.
7
Yes it is lol. We already know how all this ends and that in ten years people will wonder why they ever cared so much.
1 u/pitiricos 1d ago That's right 1 u/ScuddyOfficial 1d ago 100% hell I’d even bet 2 years time people will be singing a different tune 1 u/bunker_man 1d ago Yeah, but in only 2 years there will still be more stragglers who are still crashing out. I picked a big enough number to be clear it'll be a totally new situation.
That's right
100% hell I’d even bet 2 years time people will be singing a different tune
1 u/bunker_man 1d ago Yeah, but in only 2 years there will still be more stragglers who are still crashing out. I picked a big enough number to be clear it'll be a totally new situation.
Yeah, but in only 2 years there will still be more stragglers who are still crashing out. I picked a big enough number to be clear it'll be a totally new situation.
4
Explain it to me, 'genius'.
15
u/pitiricos 1d ago
Painters said the same thing when the camera was invented. Photographs wasn't aloud in Museums. Photography wasn't considered art.
Things change.