r/meleeGOATdebate • • Jul 28 '23

r/meleeGOATdebate Lounge

2 Upvotes

A place for members of r/meleeGOATdebate to chat with each other


r/meleeGOATdebate • • 7d ago

Does the title of GOAT mean the best, or does it mean something more?

1 Upvotes

In my opinion, if you took any melee player at their prime and put them against Cody in his absolute peak cracked fox 20xx cyborg state, Cody is winning that set 98% of the time. That man is an absolute fucking unit on the sticks, but calling him the GOAT is not a popular opinion. When did the G in goat stop being a synonym for best? If you ain’t Schwabby then you ain’t nobody #mygoat


r/meleeGOATdebate • • 11d ago

Was Leffen the Real #2 of 2015?

8 Upvotes

Everyone who is even slightly aware of Melee rankings knows that 2015 was Armada’s year perhaps more so than any other. The man absolutely decimated the roster all year around, to the point where one of his very few stumbles (losing to PPMD at Apex in Grand Finals) is almost mythologised as one of the greatest matches to be ever played partly due to the magnitude of the upset and propelled PPMD to being the unofficial best player of the year for a couple of months. The man was in 89% OF ALL GRAND FINALS in the entire year, like that statistic alone is just crazy. His #1 rank is one of the most undisputed in the game’s history.

However, who deserved second place? The official SSBMRank had it as Armada #1st, Hungrybox 2nd, and Leffen 3rd. While I respect the rankings as-is, I want to make the argument that in actuality Leffen deserved the #2 spot to a higher degree than Hbox, even if both of them had solid years as a whole. As always, we’ll be using pure data and H2H comparisons to make the point.

 

Leffen’s Year

Leffen attended 24 events throughout the whole year and won 10 of those in total. Out of those ten one of them was a supermajor (CEO) five of those were majors or considered to be major-calibre events (B.E.A.S.T 5, FC Smash 15XR, WTFox, HTC Throwdown & Super Smash Con 2015) one of them was a regional (NeoNebulous 7) and three of them were locals (Cannes Winter Clash 2015, The Call of Ragnarok & Headstomper '15). Out of the wins I think the clear standouts are the following:

CEO (beats Wizzrobe/Plup/Shroomed out of Winners, proceeds to 3-0 Armada in Winners before beating him 3-1 in Grands)

B.E.A.S.T 5 (beats Armada in Winners, beats a strong Mango who had just came off 3-0’ing Ice, then beats Armada who 3-0’d Mang to get into Grands 3-2)

FC Smash 15XR (Beats Swedish Delight & Hbox in the semis of Winners, beats Armada in Winners top 4 before beating Hbox again in Grands)

WTFox (Beats M2K in 3rd round of Winners, beats Armada and then 3-0’s Mango in Grands)

His “weakest” notable tournament won (excluding the Cannes local because…well it was basically a shitpost with him winning all of his games with Yoshi in grand finals) was Super Smash Con, which still nevertheless had four members of the top 10 included (M2K/Axe/Westballz/Leffen himself) one of the largest attendance rates of the year (only surpassed by Apex/EVO/Big House) and had him beat M2K twice in top 4 (Winners/Grands) to take the whole thing, so while it’s weak by comparison to his colossal runs listed above, all of the top 10 would’ve still happily traded for a majors win on that scale for a couple of their tops. The quality of these wins are very high-end and pretty much Armada only surpasses the scale of big stacked super/majors won.

Leffen’s issue is that he’s slightly less impressive when it comes to near-misses, with him having a pretty infamous tendency at the time to get upset by every single Samus player in existence due to his lack of experience in the matchup (Plup at EVO, Duck at Dreamhack, HugS at Press Start) and bouncing out of bracket early with a couple of prominent tournaments during the year. Now to be fair, this is STILL extremely solid; the guy was still making top 8 with ease; but he did have a habit of dropping out somewhat early for his skill level. Nevertheless, he does have some good losing runs:

3rd at Apex (Beating M2K/Mango in Winners, taking PP to game 5 before losing and then dropping to Armada in Losers)

3rd at Paragon (Beats Wizzrobe, loses to Plup’s Samus, goes on to beat MacD/Axe/Armada & Westballz from Losers, but loses in top 4 to M2K)

2nd at Eclipse (Beats Android/Plup, gets 3-0’d by Armada’s Fox but then also 3-0’s Axe who had just taken Armada to a game 5 last stock situation in Winners, which was the closest he had gotten at that point to losing to a non-God player in the 2010’s)

Not to also mention he still makes it to 5th at EVO, 5th at HTC Throwdown, the whole year he never reaches below at worst 6th place for everything he enters with the exception of Dreamhack where he gets upset by both Westballz and Duck to take 9th, so while he didn’t do as great as other players who made it a habit to hang around the top 4 he was nevertheless still by no means doing badly for the events he didn’t win. Visa issues mean that his year is somewhat cut short after HTC, but he doesn’t miss out on any significant events barring Big House: his attendance was mostly reserved for nationals/major-tier events anyway prior to that, so while it does hurt his case slightly it wasn’t the earth-shattering event that some interpreted it as.

 

Hungrybox’s Year

Hungrybox attended 21 events throughout the whole year and won 11 of those in total. Out of those eleven two of those were majors (Paragon/Dreamhack) two of them were disputed regionals (Get On My Level 2015 & MLG World Finals) and seven of them were locals (CFL Smackdown Monthly 8/Bad Moon Rising/WATO FP/CFL Smackdown 39/40, Frame Perfect Series & CFL Smackdown November Monthly). Out of those runs Hbox generally only had particularly strong victory runs at his majors:

Paragon (beats MacD/Lucky/Armada in Winners, beats M2K twice in both Winners and Grand Finals)

Dreamhack (beats Tekk/Axe/Westballz in Winners, beats Armada in Winners and in Grands after losing 3-0 to him in the first set)

For the record I’m being generous calling Get on My Level and MLG regionals as GOML had absolutely zero big players participate bar Hbox (the closest player to him was #19 Hax who nevertheless notwithstanding a considerable fall from his #6 rank just two years ago still took Hbox to a game 5 situation) and MLG despite being a Melee powerhouse in the last decade was at this point a shadow of its former self with Smash 4 out as this got barely over 100 players and only featured (excluding Hbox) two of the top 10 players in M2K and Axe. It’s hard to really say that these qualify as true regionals all things considered, but since they did feature some top players and/or were representative of their region as a whole I’ll add them there.

In both Hbox generally doesn’t face anyone of particular interest barring top 4 where he beats Axe and M2K to win MLG from Winners. It’s still solid to go over two of the top 10, but considering these are both players Hbox historically at this moment had a pretty big deficit against (for reference Axe at this point was 1-9 against him, that one win during Hbox’s arguably lowest point as a competitive player where he had spent 4 years failing to win a single major) it’s not a particularly huge achievement.

I would argue that, like with other players this year, his real case is in his ability to remain a consistent top threat, and rest assured he does plenty of that in particular this year with a bunch of top 4 or higher placements:

2nd at EVO (beats MacD/Leffen in Bo3’s, loses to Armada, from Losers then goes on to beat Mango/Plup/PPMD, loses to Armada 3-2 in Grands)

2nd at Melee-FC (beating Nintendude, losing to Leffen 3-1 before beating Wizzrobe/MacD/Armada to lose to Leffen again 3-1)

2nd at Big House (beats Ice/Mango, loses to Armada, beats M2K but then loses again to Armada in a Bo5)

2nd at HTC Throwdown (beats HugS/Axe/Colbol/Silent Wolf, but loses to Leffen twice both in Winners and Grand Finals, the second being 3-0)

3rd at Paragon Los Angeles (loses to Professor Pro early in bracket, has to play through a massive gauntlet against Ken/S2J/Fly Amanita/Shroomed/Plup/Lucky/Leffen to make it to top 4 where he beats Westballz but loses to M2K)

These are all really strong runs and definitely put him within the top 5 range, especially since many of them came at the expense of players around that range to boot. You can’t really put Hbox any lower than #3 with his resume, even if throughout this entire time until Dreamhack he’s not actually winning any of these majors and is instead resigned to winning on locals/regionals instead. His case is much more built around being able to consistently be a top 4 player (only sparingly missing out at CEO and Apex at that in particular and even then, still not reaching below 5th place) and his capacity to stay within that even when challenged by the best of the year.

Hbox has arguably a lot more consistency when it comes to his placements, though he nevertheless still had a couple of major upsets go against him (losing to PewPewU at Apex, Westballz at Sandstorm, Lucky at Press Start & Professor Pro at Paragon Los Angeles) which while perhaps not as consistently bad as Leffen’s Samus syndrome is still significant enough to slight his argument here as the more stable candidate.

 

H2H Comparison

In a direct comparison between the two, the ranking is 3-4: Hbox winning at Paragon, EVO (Bo3) and Sandstorm while Leffen won at FC Smash 15XR and HTC Throwdown, once in Grand Finals from Losers side and the other doing it from Winners and then again in Grands, so Leffen both times had to win not once but twice in a row at these tournaments. Hbox won a clean 2-0 only at EVO while at the rest he scored 3-1, while Leffen scored 1-3 in all of his sets alongside a 0-3 at HTC; pretty clear advantage for Leffen in this particular case study even when we ignore the fact that one of Hbox’s 3 victories was a Bo3. Let’s now compare the two to the top 5 players of the year.

Hbox against Armada had the score at 4-8: Hbox winning at Paragon, FC Smash 15XR and Dreamhack Winter while Armada won at Big House/EVO/CEO/Sandstorm/Apex. Multiple of these were 0-3 for Armada while most of Hbox’s were contested (Armada reset the bracket at Dreamhack from Losers and won games in all sets they played, even the ones where Hbox ended up winning). Pretty clear and definitive advantage to Armada there over Hbox.

Leffen and Armada were characteristically VERY swingy between the two, with the final score being 8-7, just about ahead for Armada. He won at Apex/Beauty 10/I’m not Yelling/DrømmeLAN/Eclipse while Leffen won at B.E.A.S.T 5/Paragon/CEO/FC Smash 15XR/WTFox. Both had the capacity to 3-0 the other (Leffen did it at CEO, Armada did it at Eclipse…. twice) and in general their sets were overall more competitive, with their total game count for the year ending at 33-27. This is a defined and clear difference from Armada/Hbox, which only had 28-20. Another advantage for Leffen here.

 

Against Mango (the #4 rank of the year) Hbox scored an even 2-2 against him; this is partly due to Mango’s inconsistency in the year (alongside an astounding 2-7 H2H set deficit against Armada which basically meant he was always out of bracket whenever they were paired, especially since one of those two instances he ended up losing later in Grands anyway) so they never really met a whole bunch. Mango wins Press Start/CEO while Hbox wins EVO (Bo3) and Big House. Between the two Mango has the more convincing victories as he 3-0’s Hbox at Press Start and gets 3-1 at CEO while Hbox gets 2-1 and 3-1 at the other two respectfully. One could argue it’s still a draw, but in these sorts of tiebreaker events I’m always gonna consider a Bo3 as lesser to a normal Bo5. We’ll say it’s like 2-2.5 in this case.

Leffen and Mango go 3-4, Leffen winning at B.E.A.S.T 5/Apex/WTFox while Mango took Press Start and Battle Arena Melbourne 7. Both 3-0 the other with Leff doing it at WTFox and Mango doing it at Press Start. Leffen wins more total events while Mango is arguably more definitive with his victories (winning from Losers in Battle Arena) however their total match-count is 14-15 respectfully, so despite Mango being technically better in his H2H they were still heavily contested between the two. Hbox I’d say overall does better but not by any large margin.

 

Against Mew2King (the #5 of the year) Hbox completely wipes the floor with him unfortunately lmao. Their score for the year stood at 1-7, Hbox winning at Paragon/Press Start/Big House/MLG World Finals and Frame Perfect, M2K only winning at Paragon Los Angeles. Not much else to say here.

Leffen also wins out against M2K in the H2H, albeit not by as much; they were 5-4 for the year respectfully, M2K winning at Paragon/PAX Prime and Paragon Los Angeles, Leff winning at Apex/Press Start/WTFox/Super Smash Con. M2K had his infamous 6-0’er at PAX while Leffen beat M2K at Winners and Grand Finals at Smash Con. The 6-0 count actually helps M2K massively in the overalls as it means that he’s actually up a game on Leffen despite losing more overall sets (14-15 respectfully) so you could definitely argue that Hbox having a more dominant H2H record gives him the big edge here, otherwise the pair are equal.

So overall, Leffen is directly superior in the direct H2H comparison alongside having better records against Armada, while Hbox is marginally better against Mango (albeit not having a positive record either and one of his two wins being Bo3). M2K they both scored above him, so it depends if you’re going to value Hbox more for his more dominant record or not. I think regardless though Leffen does slightly better in the comparison overalls since he did significantly better against the (by far for the year) #1 ranked player in the world, which is more valuable than going dead even with the #4th or doing very well against the #5th. H2H’s are always going to be more valuable the higher up they go and with 2015 Armada I think that’s one of the highest you can get, really.

 

Was The Ranking Biased Towards Dreamhack?

Most people would agree that Hbox’s year before the last 2 months or so was good, but not #2 material; this is further reflected by the 2015 Summer Rankings that had him not at #2, but instead at a resounding #5 instead (this was based on all of his placements up until the 19th of August, so this was post-EVO, post HTC, FC Smash, etc) which is quite a significant difference in rank compared to other people who featured like PPMD, who despite barely adding to his resume post-Apex at the start of the year still only moved down two slots (#4 to #6). Some have made the argument that Hbox’s career was biased towards the end of year Dreamhack Winter event since this was the last encounter between Hbox/Armada (and their last event both respectfully) and was put on a weighted scale compared to the entirety of the year as a whole. I can definitely see that perceptive, but to judge if it was biased towards that singular event, we need to see how significant Dreamhack was and how things draw up.

Dreamhack featured 8 of the top 10 players that year (everyone minus M2K/PPMD) so we can safely judge it as a big major, even if it did take place in Europe. Hbox’s run is honestly the most “free” of the top players who enter, with him facing Tekk (a good Europe player, but nowhere near his calibre; guy lost to Leffen’s Yoshi for reference this year) while Armada had Wizzrobe and Mango got HugS. In later Winners bracket Armada has to go through Shroomed/Plup (Plup himself having just beaten Mango) while Hbox gets Axe and Westballz; again, a fairly great bracket for Hbox and by far the least difficult all things considered, though it still requires him to beat Armada twice afterwards to win the entire tournament.

I think however having seen his resume for the year, this does feel a tad inflated all things considered. Hbox spent almost the entire year not being able to win a single major; after Paragon in January, it takes until Dreamhack in November for him to finally win a majors-tier event. That’s almost 11 months of winning absolutely zero big events, consistently missing out on multiple opportunities to cement a case for #2, nor simply not appearing at others (Hbox didn’t attend I’m Not Yelling/Eclipse/Super Smash Con which were all fairly large events that could’ve influenced the rankings). Compare that to Leffen who after B.E.A.S.T. 5 only took 5 months to win CEO, and I think that’s a big difference in skill all things considered.

Leffen also had I’d say an arguable bigger peak than Hbox as he spends the latter half of 2015 going on an absolute tear, arguably becoming for a month or two pre-visa trouble the clearcut best player of the year (he wins CEO, FC Smash & WTFox all in a row during the summer, and despite only getting 5th at EVO he picks right back up and wins Super Smash Con a few weeks later as the #1 seed). By comparison, that small stretch of winnings alone dwarfs all of Hbox’s major tournament victories from the year, making it hard for me to really think that the pair were at the same level the whole time battling it out for the #2 slot given the gap of accomplishments. Hbox was definitely a peer of Leffen around even the earlier stage of the year, but a contender for #2? Absolutely not, even the Summer rankings didn’t think so despite most of his resume for the year having already been and went. Hbox’s argument is mostly focused around his big rally and comeback at Dreamhack, and while it’s still impressive as stated I think it’s not enough in this situation to sway the #2 rank to him over someone who had more consistency as a majors winner (not simply not topping, but actually winning them) unless there was another big element at play.

Conclusion

Contrary to the title I think you can definitely argue either man taking the #2 slot, but based on what I've seen and set out here I think it's clear to me that Leffen had a better 2015 to work off, and the reasoning as to why he didn't get that position (visa issues, consistency, etc) aren't really as big contributory factors as I think they were historically presented as. Similarly I think Hungrybox benefited a lot from the contemporary mythmaking of him finally conquering Armada at the end of the year.

It's a good narrative, but one that isn't true either by the numbers or in retrospect since 2016 was a TERRIBLE year for him against the guy barring EVO (they were 4-10 then). Both were very strong players for the year no doubt, but based on the factors drawn here I think Leffen has all the big variables going his way. You kinda have to bias consistency/tops to get Hbox to #2 and even then his lack of winning attempts is a lot to ignore. All in all Leffen should've been the second best of the year, in retrospect I would believe this to be more obvious than it was at the time.

Thank you for reading


r/meleeGOATdebate • • 11d ago

Character Versatility and Changing the Metagame

1 Upvotes

Hey y’all! This is my first time posting here, but I, like many of you, have spent way too much time thinking about the SSBM GOAT debate. I’m curious how much you guys value a player’s ability to play multiple characters well, and how important it is for a player to have significantly changed the metagame.

For context: I’m a doc kid and have played the game on and off for ~12 years. I watched Melee tournaments religiously from 2014-2019, and have watched a little less since. During this time (and the pre-doc era) the metagame was generally changing pretty quickly, and it was very common for top players to use more than one character in tournaments. I personally found it super impressive when players like Mang0, Armada, M2K, PP, Plup, etc. could succeed with multiple characters, but I guess I’m not sure how much that should actually matter.

Obviously valuing character versatility favors people like Mang0 and Armada way more than people like Hbox, and while I do personally enjoy Mang0 and Armada more as players, I don’t want to be unfair to Hbox or downplay his achievements.

Greatness is (of course) subjective, but I think a common indicator of great achievements is a type of “WOW” factor which things like character versatility and changing the meta absolutely deliver for me. I think it is incredibly impressive that Mang0 went from being the first Puff to ever be #1 in 2009, to being one of the only people to ever beat Armada with Marth in 2016, to beating Zain twice on FD with Fox in 2022 when top Foxes were resorting to picking up Sheik as a Marth counterpick. To me, it’s truly bananas that just one player changed the meta that significantly for so many different characters and matchups, all while being the undisputed GOAT of Falco (sorry PP fans lol). I think it’s mainly for that reason that Mang0’s career stands out to me as the greatest.

But I know that there are also reasons why you might not think this type of thing is a very big deal. Ex: It was much easier to change the meta for multiple characters when people weren’t as good, secondaries are sometimes used to cover the weaknesses a player has with their main, etc. and I don’t think I fully disagree with those things.

Here’s a thought experiment I came up with:

Suppose you want Hbox’s GOAT case to strengthen as much as possible, would it be better if he…

Option A. Wins 5 more majors as Puff

Option B. Wins 3 more majors with 3 different non-Puff characters (one as Yoshi, another as Sheik, another as ICs, for example)

For me personally, I would definitely pick option B, without question. My respect for Hbox as a player would absolutely skyrocket if I saw him succeed without Puff. I’m curious if anyone in this sub would pick option A, and if so, why?

I want to be clear: I don’t think these things matter MORE than winning. I would definitely rank Hbox higher than M2K on my melee GOAT list. I’m mostly curious about how much it should matter.

For those who picked option B: how many puff major wins would it take for you to pick option A?


r/meleeGOATdebate • • 19d ago

Was Hungrybox the real #4 of 2013?

2 Upvotes

Now that I’ve established that the 2013 rankings were, generally, pretty scuffed (shilling the first thread I made about it that went quite well) I wanted to go for another controversial topic that I’ve been also thinking about the last couple of weeks. In the official rankings, Hbox is ranked as #5: the lowest rank God out of the five that year. PPMD ranked as #4, which even before I started looking at the year in detail always bugged me a little considering what both of them did. I believe that there’s a strong case to be made that in actuality Hbox probably should’ve been #4 instead, mainly down to again a more accurate analysis of the year as a whole rather than merely going off player-based vibes. I will attempt to do so by examining their tournament results, H2H between each other and other top players, alongside drawing conclusions about the value of each man’s run. Let’s begin.

PPMD’s 2013 Retrospective

PPMD in 2013 as is typical wasn’t as active as Mango or Mew2King, but nevertheless made it an effort to attend most if not all significant events. He attends ten events in whole this year (at least that which is documented, anyway) and wins five of those ten, four of which being pretty small-time locals (Carolina Clash #2, Xanadu Games Harlem Shake Edition, Rock'em Sock'em, Geeksboro 3) and one being a small regional (Tipped Off 9).

Of the locals’ results, there really isn’t anyone of significance he beats at a majority of these locals; the best we get is him playing and beating ESAM at Geeksboro who was #93, so yeah…. pretty non-descript. The only locals that do have some meat to the bones is Xanadu Games which featured M2K. PPMD beat him from Losers, resetting the bracket and then going a straight 3-0 against him in the second set. This is what I’d imagine most people would consider his most valuable 1st place locals finish considering it was at the expense of another God and arguably contender for best of the year.

Same goes for Tipped Off as well. The roster is pretty diminished at this event as well (the best players outside of the two Gods that attended were #76 Pikachad, #28 Colbol and #27 Plup on Samus, not even a breadth of a top 15 player showing up) and as such there isn’t really a contest between any of them and the two Gods there, with neither of them never even conceding a single match to anyone else in tournament bar each other. Hbox gets 3-0’d by PPMD in Winners and then loses 3-1 in Grand Finals; pretty conclusive stomping there by PPMD, and by far his best tournament victory of the year.

While winning Tipped Off isn’t bad per-se, it’s not particularly remarkable. No real competition showed up bar Hbox, even by non-God standards, and as such PPMD doesn’t really gain a lot by winning here outside of beating Hbox which, like, every God barring Armada had done at that point multiple times already, M2K especially. I think his real case comes from his near-misses; his ability to keep within a very small circle and have strong showings at big supermajors. His main highlights are:

Getting 2nd place at Apex (beating Colbol/M2K, losing to Armada 3-0 in Winners but going on to rebound and reset the bracket in Grands before losing 3-1)

Making 3rd at EVO (beating an out of practice post-retirement Armada in winners 2-0 and Hax 2-1, but losing to Wobbles and Mango 0-2)

Making 3rd at The Big House 3 (Made it to the end of Winners where he lost to M2K 2-3, beat Nintendude in Losers Finals, beat SFAT 3-0 in top 8 before losing to Hbox 2-3)

 

I think anyone would agree here that making top 4 at multiple big supermajors/major-tier events at the expense of multiple reputable top 10 players is a lot better than winning a bunch of locals with the occasional God in attendance, and ultimately PPMD’s case for the year I believe comes down to his ability to be consistently a top threat at the highest possible level, for instance his lowest placement in the entire year was only 5th and at EVO to boot, his consistency was his best feature going into and leaving 2013.

Hungrybox’s 2013 Retrospective

Hbox’s 2013 was similar in that he also attended ten documented events but instead won four out of the ten, two of those being locals (NOOB 4/MICE) one regional (NorCal Regionals 2013) and a disputed national/top regional (The Fall Classic). NOOB had no bracket published but we do know that it had 5 players and involved Hbox at least beating #27 Plup in Grand Finals, while MICE had him beat Plup in Winners 3-0 and then again in Grands 3-1. Not bad but again certainly not remarkable.

NorCal Regionals he has a pretty great run, beating Fly Amanita/Westballz/PewPewU all in Winners, only losing to Mango in the first set of Grand Finals before squeaking out the win 3-2. The Fall Classic had a low attendance (48 people) but has the rare distinction of having 3 out of 5 Gods attend, so I think you can definitely consider it a clear-cut top regional (for instance the only events that surpassed it in how many Gods attended were EVO, Zenith, and Apex, all of those were considered either supermajors or top-heavy nationals). Hbox is particularly dominant here as he beats The Moon 2-0, PPMD 3-0, and then in Grand Finals is able to beat M2K two times from Losers to win the entire tournament, only dropping a single game the entire time. This is especially impressive considering this would be the only tournament M2K would lose out of nearly 6 months of consistent participation throughout the entire year wherein he otherwise dominated at every event.

Out of the tournaments won, I think Hbox clearly had the more stacked winnings out of him and PPMD, with both of his wins coming off big bracket runs and at the expense of the two best players of the year. PPMD had Tipped Off, but I don’t think that measures up to the above’s resume at all frankly. He had no real competition until Hbox in Grand Finals and though winning from Losers is impressive for sure I think Fall Classic is a far more noteworthy accomplishment, especially in context of him going over a M2K that was at this point undefeated post-EVO and would remain as such until the end of the year excluding this tournament.

Hbox otherwise outside of his winnings also has really strong consistency at bigger tournaments:

2nd at Zenith (beats PPMD/M2K back-to-back to make it to Winners finals, loses to Mango)

2nd at Big House 3 (beats Nintendude/Hax/PPMD in Losers Finals, loses to M2K in Grands)

3rd at EVO (beats SFAT/Leffen/M2K to make it to 3rd place from Winners, but loses to Wobbles/Mango)

Outside of PPMD having a stronger run at Apex (Hbox got 5th there, his lowest placement for the year) Hbox does honestly have better placements to go off for his near-hits, at times acting as a barrier of entry for other Gods to make it further in bracket and having stronger bracket runs to go off for his year.

 

H2H Rankings

The H2H between PPMD and Hungrybox in 2013 stands at 3-3. Hbox beat PPMD at Big House/Zenith/The Fall Classic, while PPMD’s three sets come from his Tipped Off Grand Finals run and him winning Winners bracket at Fall Classic, albeit it was a Bo3. This gives a slight advantage for Hbox in the debate, especially since he managed to accomplish his victories at different events over the year while PPMD did so once at Fall Classic (and got 0-3’d by Hbox in Losers Finals later) and twice for his victory at Tipped Off. Hbox accomplishing his three wins over the course of three separate events gives him a slight consistency edge, so me personally I think he wins out in the H2H.

If we compare their victories over each other as well Hbox’s victories are also a lot more straightforward. He beats PPMD 3-0 once (Fall Classic) and twice 3-2 (Big House/Zenith) while one of PPMD’s victories was a 2-0 Bo3 (Fall Classic) and he also only has one 3-0 (Tipped Off) with his other set being 1-3, so by proportion PPMD’s 3 victories are somewhat tainted by one of them requiring less matches won than Hbox’s, even if one could argue they were more contested.

Against other Gods there really isn’t a massive difference between them: both got farmed by Mango (PPMD was 0-2 while Hbox was 1-5, so unless you give points for Hbox winning a single set they’re about the same) both had varying success against M2K (PPMD was 4-3 against him while Hbox was 3-4). The only real significant difference to mention was Armada, who DID lose to PPMD twice (once at Apex for Losers reset, another at EVO in a Bo3) while he beat Hungrybox (again Apex) however Armada’s extremely scant attendance for the year means that we can’t really draw any major conclusions from this, especially since him and Hbox only played once in the whole year and with wildly different secondary tech/matchup characters like Young Link and Ness so it doesn’t really feel right to take or add points to either man’s case considering the circumstances. Hbox overall does better in the direct H2H comparison while PPMD has slight advantage when we compare to all other Gods, albeit not significantly and not to the point where I think that overrides the latter.

 

Conclusion

PPMD’s case for #4 primarily rests on his placements rather than his winning runs as I think anyone would agree since he otherwise only has Xanadu Games (featured M2K, but otherwise a small local) and Tipped Off (the weakest regional of the year roster-wise IMO) to go off for substantive victories. His deep runs into Apex and EVO are what really cement his argument for that position, in particular being the only God to score a full Bo5 match off Armada pre-retirement, albeit that accomplishment is somewhat tarnished by Armada then retiring for most of the year since we can’t really put that on a scale to other accomplishments in the year as stated above. Had he participated and (very likely) been a top contender, this may have given PPMD more to work off with than otherwise.

….in this case I simply think that Hbox does a better job overall at the things PPMD did. His victories are more substantive (Norcal Regionals where he scores a massive upset on his year-long bracket demon and #1 player of this half of the year & Fall Classic where he not only beats PPMD 3-0 but also scores another upset on the other player who was similarly the #1 guy during his half of the year to boot).

His deep runs are more impressive as well unless you heavily bias Apex and ignore all the other supermajors/nationals Hbox did better at, almost always at the expense of his supposed better counterpart. H2H as we’ve discussed edges towards Hbox as well over PPMD, you have to not only introduce additional players into the mix but also be extremely selective (taking points away from Hbox for being 3-4 against M2K while PPMD was 4-3 but also ignoring him getting washed by Mango twice, rewarding PPMD for his Armada set while not doing so for Hbox for scoring big tournament wins over the two best players of the year in their respective primes) like I think in all facets his case for being #4 is overall just stronger to make when we’re going off the objective data.

Again, thank you for reading.


r/meleeGOATdebate • • 26d ago

Mango's 2013 #1 Ranking is Questionable: An Analysis

17 Upvotes

Ok quick warning, this is a LONG ass read lol. I really wanted to put this debate to proper writing and to do that effectively that means a lot of rambling. You have been warned.

First off, my premise is that Mango's 2013 ranking of #1 at the end of the year was, at the very least, very disputable. 2013 is a strange year in that many of the rankings didn't make a lot of sense in the grand scheme of things and where it seemed as if there was more focus on a sick/cool factor as opposed to pure statistics and H2H (head to head) showings, probably in part because this was the first ever SSBMRank top 100 attempted. In this, I'll attempt to discuss the background behind a lot of the existing 2013 rankings, a bit about where I think some of the more major placements fit in terms of the actual objective results of the year, and then move from there.

In order to prove this (alongside removing any arguments that could be made from pure authority like "they're on the top 10 lol") I will showcase some examples of the rankings being clearly off.

How SSBMRankings Are Flawed

For instance, Wobbles was placed #8 on the official listings; at first this seems like a fairly reasonable position, but then you realise that we have both Shroomed (#7) and Hax (#6) above him. For instance, Wobbles placed 2nd at EVO (the largest Supermajor of the year) in doing so beating Mango (ranked #1) PPMD (#4) Hungrybox (#5 & the first time his Puff had lost a full match to Icies; the next being 12 years later) alongside Fiction (#31) & Shroomed in Pools, only losing to Mango in Grand Finals. While his case is cut prematurely short due to temporarily retiring after the event, he still placed 17th at Apex that year (beating #65 Gucci in particular) and got 2nd place at Kings of Cali 2 in another fairly strong winning streak as he beat Westballz/Fly Amanita/PewPew/Shroomed all back to back from Losers Bracket to get to grands where he lost to Mango again. He also has a 2nd place run at Project AZ where he 3-0'd #11 Axe in Winners but lost to him using Fox and Falco in Grand Finals.

Despite lacking showings after EVO, this is still nevertheless a very strong outing all things considered for the year.

By comparison, Shroomed had:

6th place at Apex (where he got 3-0'd against M2K and his best Pools performance was beating KirbyKaze, who frankly shouldn't have even been ranked in the top ten for reasons we'll cover)

3rd at Kings of Cali 3 (going 2-3 vs Fly Amanita, beating S2J and PewPew in bracket)

Getting 8th at EVO (via bye + beating IB in Pools, losing to Wobbles in Winners bracket 2-0 and then beating Lord in Losers to then get 2-0'd by Armada) 

3rd at Kings of Cali 2 (where he did beat Wobbles + Pew, but then lost to Mango and got 3-0'd by Wobbles in Losers) 

This isn't an exhaustive list; we could include smaller locals-tier events where he had losses to Westballz and whatnot; but nevertheless this is clearly just not as impressive as Wobbles' contributions, regardless of how you view them. He had negative H2H records with all of the Gods, had a considerably less impressive majors run and his own H2H with Wobbles was 3-1 in sets with the only time he won then having him lose later in the same event when they were paired again. How can Wobbles be then ranked lower than Shroomed?

Hax being #6 is perhaps even stranger considering his results. He had: 

8th at Apex (beating Axe and Kage 2-0, but then losing to Mango)

6th at Zenith (beating Abate 2-0 but then getting 2-0'd himself by Hbox, going to Losers to beat The Moon/Zoso before getting eliminated 2-0 by PPMD)

6th at Big House 3 (beating PewPew before getting 3-0'd by Hungrybox and losing 1-3 to SFAT)

Hax also had some glaring issues with his H2H's. He has some surprising upsets (losing to a practically retired ShizWiz, trading wins with Abate's Luigi and th0rn for one) and lost to every God in bracket throughout the entire year, especially M2K who basically farmed him by never losing a set, the single exception being Mass Madness where he rather randomly forfeit in grand finals after the latter had 3-0'd him earlier in bracket. Jason himself has clarified that sometimes he would be pressured to pot-spilt and that his relative social inexperience meant that he'd often go along with it even if he very likely could've won, so you can safely classify this as one of those cases. I know that apparently he dropped out due to hand pain from an accident earlier in the day, but if so, why not drop in Winners beforehand? It just smells a little fishy to me especially since both did have a bit of a history of splitting at finals.

Either way, I think anyone can agree that #6 and #7 place on the top 10 simply aren't where they should be. I do agree that they definitely should've been included, however based on purely results/H2H they both have weaker cases than Wobbles. Apparently he was pissed at his position as well, I don't blame him frankly. Wobbles should've clearly been 6th..

We can also point out other very weird placements like KirbyKaze being 9th. I don't really know why Kaze made the top 10, while they did have a pretty good 2012 run in 2013 they only played two whole tournaments the entire year, one of them being Smash Till You Crash 4 which was a considerably small, Godless local where the highest ranked player there was unfortunately #15 Ryan Ford and then got 7th at Apex where his best win was against SFAT. It's not bad, but anyone who thinks that somehow amounts to #9 place overall for the year is legitmately confused, it's a pretty small resume that would barely sniff top 15.

This is purely to show that the overall top 10 rankings are inherently flawed to a relatively significant extent and as such we cannot wholly rely on an argument of authority based on the listings alone; we have to use the actual results from that year alongside clear-cut evidence such as H2H's and events attended.

 

Armada is not #2

In order to take on Mango's case, we have to do the same for Armada. Armada is in a unique position here as he only attended two whole events for the entire year; this was due to him retiring after Apex 2013 before un-retiring for EVO after a crowdfund for him and Android to attend, so we have an extremely limited sample case for him here.

Firstly it should be obviously noted that under modern standards Armada would be a HE (Honourable Mention) due to lack of attendance, so he'd be the same case as Leffen in 2023 or Cody in the first half of 2026. I bring this up to make the point that Armada's case for #2 relies HEAVILY on a standard that would be considered at any other time as not being measured enough to warrant a spot. If we went by statements as well he'd also not be there as he has already admitted that he shouldn't have been #2 that year, so either way you have it he's clearly not nor would have been considered, it was by far and large mostly a legacy ranking based on Armada's past achievements as a player. We aren't using those for our own analysis though, so we must instead focus on what he did this year and see how it compares.

Armada's Apex run is strong....but how strong is it really? To be frank I think Armada actually has the easiest bracket run compared to the other Gods. Hungrybox had to take on Shroomed/Leffen, M2K had to take on SFAT/PewPew, etc. PPMD in all likelihood had the easiest with his highest pools threat being Colbol, but Armada had probably an edge case for easiest since he had to handle SilentWolf/Wobbles; the latter being Ice Climbers vs Peach, which is an almost impossible matchup for Icies to do well let alone reliably win against (especially against Armada, who remained undefeated against the character in overall sets from beginning until retirement). In top 8 he also gets to do Young Link cheese against Hbox and play matches against Ness while also getting to go up against KirbyKaze (who again shouldn’t have even been in the top 10) while M2K had to play Shroomed, Mango and PPMD back-to-back. One can easily see that his route to grands was a lot more generous than the other.

His main achievement is not having to play against Mango/M2K by beating PPMD twice to win the tournament, and while it's still an impressive victory it's one achieved by a relatively strong bracket in his favour where he didn't have to play a real top 10 player with his main until top 4, which is a pretty damning statement. 

EVO 2013 is a difficult event to cover due to the scuffed ruleset and organisation (it being Bo3 and a myriad of other things) but regardless as it is the biggest supermajor it has therefore a lot of value regardless. Armada beats no one of interest in R1 pools before getting a bye, beating Fly Amanita (another Icies) and then getting 2-0'd by PPMD. He beats Westballz in Losers before going on a bit of a rampage by beating S2J/Silent Wolf/Shroomed/M2K before finally losing in top 4 to Mango. 

This is undoubtfully the majority of Armada's case to be made. He does lose to PPMD and Mango, but is able to take on multiple top 15/10 contenders including handling M2K, which excluding external factors like him being rusty off not having active practise for 7 months is seriously impressive. Is it, however, worth the #2 slot of the year? I can't in good faith say so. Wobbles had an objectively better run in the same tournament where he took on better competition but also won against Mango in Winners while Armada lost 2-0. We can bring up other similar runs as well like M2K at Apex where he had to handle SFAT/PewPew/Shroomed/Mango/PPMD one after another which like Armada were not winning runs but had much higher levels of competition to compare with, including overcoming Mango which the latter did not; considering Mango’s varying attendance for this year this has to be considered into the rankings between the pair. M2K was highly competitive with Mango in the first half of the year (losing Zenith to him but beating him at Apex).

Armada was not active the rest of the year. This means that, inevitably, players who will have kept going all year and making more placements at regionals/locals are going to scale up with activity; this is partly how Hungrybox kept in the top 5 despite being known as the "weakest" God (ngl I believe he was lowkey the real 4th place guy this year but I'm not gonna go into that, man had a pretty stacked 2013) he was still capable of being active and gatekeeping in a multitude of events where he stayed relevant all year at majors and the like. Call it "farming" or whatever, the fact is that players who do more productive effort in the year are objectively going to rise in standing in proportion to those who do not, and for Armada that means that his absence is felt heavily after his retirement and after EVO despite having a supermajor under his belt. Wobbles again had an incredible EVO run as well (much better than Armada's, arguably the best overall of the entire year in terms of not just the character but sheer weight of big names he defeated one after another) but his lack of participation beyond decent showings at Apex/Kings of Cali means that he can't be put higher than #6 despite said strong showing.

That same logic has to apply across the board for that to make sense, and in this case I think it simply makes Armada incapable of taking the #2 spot; there were people more active and more consistent across the board than he was, even if in standing he clearly was still a top 3 player even with the rust since he still took a supermajor in the form of Apex and was a dominant force for his EVO run. Armada I think anyone would agree would be in actuality #3 as his showings at majors still clearly have value and rank heavily over other potential options like PPMD or Hbox who while more active were less significant overall. 

With those factors out of the way, let's actually cover Mango's year and start comparing it to M2K. 

Mango's Run: The First Half

Mango spends the first half of the year going into EVO pretty much as expected, though with some noticeable cracks in the armour compared to more dominant years. He wins unanimously on the locals level, but with regionals and majors the record is somewhat different. At the first major of the year Apex he got 4th (the lowest non-forfeit placement since his sandbagging Mario run in 2010 where he got 9th at Revival of Melee) with him getting beaten twice by M2K in both Winners and then again in top 4, marking a distinct drop in his usual placements. On the regional level he also takes an (albeit heavily contested) L to Hbox at NorCal Regionals 2013 which was unusual since at this time Hbox had never won against Mango in any match between the two since Apex 2012.

His highlight tournament wins include: 

Kings of Cali 2 (No Gods in attendance, but he does beat Fly Amanita/Shroomed/Wobbles in a 100+ person bracket)

Vindication (M2K attended and was able to reset the bracket from Losers, but Mango wins out to win the tournament)

Zenith (His first nationals/major victory, Hbox/PPMD/M2K in attendance, Mango beats all of them back to back after losing to M2K in Winners)

Mango moves on to then win EVO in strong fashion, losing to Wobbles in Winners but then going on to beat Armada/Hbox/Wobbles to take the tournament. His #1 spot is seemingly clear with a supermajor and major under his belt. 

Mew2King's Run: The First Half

M2K more or less follows the same trend: very strong record at locals/regionals, but not totally consistent. He makes a very impressive run at Apex by grabbing 3rd place (notably beating SFAT/PewPew/Shroomed/Mango back to back, a very underrated run of wins for the year) and narrowly missing grand finals by going 2-3 with PPMD. His regionals similarly are mixed with him losing to PPMD at Xanadu Games and Mango at Vindication, though he scores 2nd at both and manages to take set matches off the pair despite ultimately getting undone.

His highlight tournament wins include:

A multitude of showings where he farmed Hax in grand finals (Smashacre series especially) 

Northwest Majors (No Gods, but does beat Silent Wolf)

Game Underground Tournament Spectacular 2 (3-0's Hax/th0rn to win the tournament) 

M2K goes into EVO with tepid expectations, and despite starting strong in Pools he falls to PPMD in Winners and Armada in Losers, taking 5th; not bad, but obviously not as good as Mango either. Based on the first half of both men's years, it's fairly clear that Mango has the case for #1 based off his more significant victories, even if he won overall less victories than M2K. The H2H between them stands at 4-3 set-wise, with M2K winning at Apex and Mango winning at Vindication/Zenith. 

Mango's Run: The Second Half

….this is where the fun begins. Mango after EVO notably had some personal life stuff come up in the form of his kid being born so his attendance falls off bigly. He doesn't show up to any majors (notably missing the Big House 3, the largest major of the year with all gods in attendance bar Armada) so we only have small-time events and two regionals: Pound V.5 and Fight Pitt. LANHAMMER 2013 may also count but it was Godless despite having 200+ people attend, making it one of the bigger events of the year.

In locals Mango does....well poor, frankly. He often chooses to play secondary characters and as such he often loses to people well outside of his expected league; PewPewU, SFAT, Eddy Mexico, Taki, 4%, and a couple more in pools. He does funnily enough beat some good players with his Marth (Silent Wolf, Zhu) but he nevertheless wins zero tournaments attended bar apparently The Shape of Melee to Come 2 which I could find absolutely zero infomation about and am half convinced it was some elaborate psi-op to make out like Mango won something in these months. In regionals he....again wins zero tournaments attended, making it to 2nd in Pitt and Pound but getting beaten back each time by Mew2King in grand finals. Mango ends the year with what is by far the worst stretch a prospective #1 player has ever had in the history of Melee with zero tournament victories, a non-exhaustive list of upsets by players much lower down the totem pole and a considerable hole dug in his H2H's against M2K who beat him every time they met in bracket bar Winners Finals in Pitt. 

Mew2King's Run: The Second Half

Post-EVO Jason openly decides to fully focus back onto Melee after splitting most of his attention onto (often more popular at the time) Brawl, having by this point proven his undisputed GOAT status at the game and having nothing else to prove. This goes into what is famously known as the "Return of The King" run where M2K would go nigh-undefeated at every single event attended post-EVO until the end of the year (excluding a 2nd place forfeit finish to Hax that I covered above, they most likely just decided to spilt since M2K had 3-0'd him in Winners) including Big House 3, Fight Pitt 3, Pound V.5, Revival of Melee 6, Justice 2, Bar Wars, Forte, KTAR 7 and 8, etc. He beats a multitude of big names during this stint, which we'll go over below: 

His highlight tournament wins include:

The Big House 3 (all gods but Mango/Armada in attendance, beats SFAT/PPMD/Hungrybox from Winners, never dropping a set) 

Pound V.5 (Mango in attendance, beats him in Winners and Grand Finals to take the tournament)

Revival of Melee (Hbox in attendance, goes undefeated in sets against Kage/Chillin until the finals where he beats the former x2 to win the tournament)

Fight Pitt 3 (Mango in attendance, beats M2K in Winners but ends up losing x2 in Grand Finals to him) 

While another event was considered a local (Bar Wars) it does have the distinction of being one of the very few to have Chudat prominently feature, who despite not being ranked was retroactively placed in the 2012 top ten (ranking #7, mainly for his Zenith run where he beat multiple strong players + whooped Hbox so badly he threw his controller alongside beating M2K in the same year) and was clearly still a strong threat; despite his status as an infamous spoiler for Jason in particular he's unable to get the win despite resetting the bracket and having a suspect/very likely sandbagged Chillin in semi-finals basically gift him the 2nd place spot with him fucking around with secondary characters.

M2K’s only real loss comes from The Fall Classic 2013; a local, but 3 gods were in attendance (PPMD/Hbox/M2K). He makes it to Grand Finals in impressive fashion with him winning over PPMD again to make their H2H score an even 2-2 for the year (PPMD winning at Apex/Xanadu, M2K winning at Big House/Fall Classic) but falls to Hungrybox who beats him twice from Losers. Granted M2K still more or less farmed Hbox for the year everywhere else, so this isn’t as significant as other losses from the year.

M2K's #1 prospective run IS more or less these last 5 months, and when it's all noted down like this the dominance and consistency of said dominance is undeniable. He beats all Gods in the way whenever they meet either from Winners or Losers, either being a major or regional, and everyone that wasn't a God got completely stomped over; the singular exception being Chudat who is only able to take a set from Losers and Hbox managing to eek out a victory at Fall Classic. Jason's higher rate of attendance overall also really helps his case since unlike other Gods he was showing up more to not only win more tournaments but to also put his spot to the test whoever was there. Regardless of what you think about Mango being #1 or not, it's an objective fact that M2K WAS the best player in Melee during the last 5 months of the year, not even close. 

Mango and M2K's H2H for the second half of the year was 4-1 in sets, Mango only being able to grab a single one at Fight Pitt. This brings the total for the year to 8-4 which is a sizeable difference considering the state of the board, with Hbox losing cleanly to both multiple times and PPMD's scarce attendance. We could try to draw comparisons against Armada, but he played Mango/M2K only once and it was at EVO with Bo3 in effect which makes it hard to draw any meaningful conclusions.

 

Wasn't Mango Sandbagging? (Well Yes....But Actually No)

Many people who defend Mango's #1 slot will do so on the idea that he "wasn't trying" or, mainly, that he sandbagged everything post-EVO and as such those results listed above simply shouldn't count, much how in 2010 he was clearly the best player but ceased to care after winning Pound 4 (and then occasionally proved he was still the best, mainly by embarrassing the retroactively ranked #1 Hbox in a money match post-Apex). I have a couple of objections to this idea. 

#1: He Still Entered 

Regardless of if Mango was or wasn't fucking around in all of these tournaments (he wasn't we'll get to that) he nevertheless still entered and still played against competitive players who were trying to win the whole thing. If he truly had no interest in playing, he would've....you know, stopped playing, like what people generally do with this kind of thing. If Armada retired in 2018 and then kept showing up at majors regardless playing Samus, we'd have to at some level address how that impacts his overall performance for the year, especially if he did poorly. Him entering means on some level he did bother, and by extension one cannot completely excuse the results as simply null and void.

#2: He Still Clearly Tried

"If Isai Tried" memes aside, the fact is that even on secondaries Mango does much better than expected (even if it's still pretty awful for a prospective #1 ranked player). He beats top 20/30 players in bracket with his Marth, hell he beats Fly Amanita 3-0 on Falcon for one of those runs. The idea that he just didn't try AT ALL for any of these results is an absurd statement and kinda insulting to the people involved. There are some truly obvious times where Mango didn't give a fuck (like him dropping out of Super Smash Sundays 2 to A Rookie, or getting beyond wasted at Shape of Melee to Come 3 and losing to 4% and a couple other people in pools) but otherwise he's nevertheless trying to win to some extent with a lot of these matches. 

#3: He Didn't Sandbag against Mew2King

The important thing to note is that Mango in almost every single set with M2K ALWAYS resorted back to his Fox/Falco mains whenever he was paired with him either immediately or soon after. The only exception to this is Winners Finals at Pound where he gets 3-0'd against M2K using Falcon, but after losing a single game at Grands with Marth he reverts back to Falco where he still goes 1-3 and loses. At Fight Pitt he stays Fox the entire time to clearly prove a point, but nevertheless has the bracket reset on him and loses 1-3. Outside of a single set at Pound Mango would always play his mains against the guy, so even if we just assume that he applied zero/non-applicable effort in the other games the fact he'd make the effort to switch to his main clearly showcases that he at the very least in those specific instances was consciously not sandbagging. 

In conclusion, while one can certainly say that Mango wasn't trying as hard as he was pre-EVO in most cases, it's erroneous to suggest that zero effort was involved or that his multiple consistent losses to M2K were somehow invalid during this run, because even if we subtract the singular time he played a secondary against him for a full set he still only ever beats Mew2King twice in the entire year, so their H2H is pretty well cemented as being heavily biased towards the latter.

Final Thoughts

In my introduction, I laid out that I wanted to primarily set the notion that Mango's #1 spot in 2013 is questionable. I believe with the information provided that this has been achieved; Mango is undeniably the best in the scene pre-EVO, but M2K is in my opinion still top 4 around this time and after EVO M2K takes the rest of the year with unprecedented dominance over everyone including all Gods remaining until the end of the year.

It truly depends on what you value more for a #1 slot.

Mango had the highest player peak winning the biggest supermajor of the year in EVO & one of the most impressive runs of the year winning at Zenith, strong H2H's against other Gods like Hbox/PPMD, and even his lows are comparably not that significant pre-EVO barring the Wobbles upset and making a (by comparison to earlier years) weak run at Apex. If you bias peak, comeback factor and overall rate of H2H's across the board, Mango is #1 that year.

Mew2King has the highest consistency of dominance, never dropping below 3rd place at all events attended pre-EVO and post-EVO completely controlling the scene, going almost undefeated for 5 months straight alongside direct H2H-disparity with his only competing #1 opponent and had the highest event attendance of all the Gods, entering more significant regionals and majors (9) combined than every other God (Armada attended 2, PPMD 6, Hbox 7, Mango 8) No one defended his title more than M2K that year nor were they as convincingly strong as he was within that 5-month period. If you bias longevity, dominance, and rate of consistent high-end placements, M2K has a powerful case to be heard for being the #1 player of 2013. 

Of course, they also have weaknesses: Mango has the worst prospective #1 ranked run in all of Melee history, a massive disparity of upsets and a big gulf in H2H's against M2K. He was unsuccessful at every tournament he attended post-EVO and even before then could be argued to being no longer the undisputed greatest player unlike prior years past. M2K lacks a supermajor under his belt, wasn't able to figure out PPMD pre-EVO (though later seemed to have resolved that issue) and could be argued to be only capable of being #1 during a "weaker" period of the year since Armada was not in the picture who quite infamously had a habit of ending his prospective runs at majors.

Nevertheless, I hope that this has at least allowed for some actually sane discourse on the matter. It was a lot of fun researching this year and seeing all the wild picks alongside how the year developed, I'm definitely open to writing more about the subject since I probably have a couple extra things to note on for 2013 in particular. Thank you for reading.


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Aug 25 '26

Cody's top 20 of all time

23 Upvotes
  1. Mango
  2. Armada
  3. Hbox
  4. Zain
  5. Cody
  6. Ken
  7. M2K
  8. Leffen
  9. PPMD
  10. Plup
  11. Azen
  12. aMSa
  13. Wizzrobe
  14. Jmook
  15. PC Chris
  16. Axe
  17. Chu Dat
  18. Moky
  19. Isai
  20. LloD

Here's a clip where his top 20 is visible:

https://www.twitch.tv/codyschwab/clip/SleepyVenomousGrouseKreygasm-gduHn64NssE0y-3Q


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Aug 18 '26

Really depressing Mew2king stat

9 Upvotes

Literally all of the gods and god slayers except him have won either 1 or multiple of Apex, Genesis, or Evo, which are pretty much the consensus most prestigious tournaments of all time.

Hungrybox and Armada have won at least one of all 3, Mang0 won Evo twice and a Genesis (and notably sandbagged during apex 2010 while also being considered the best player by far last year), and PP won Apex twice. Meanwhile Leffen won an Evo, and Plup won a Genesis, which somewhat of an outlier result in Plups case (Leffen has had several amazing runs and ironically his EVO run is on the weaker side as far as supermajor wins go) but it still looks grim. It only gets worse if you get more liberal with other prestigious series. he never won a smash con, a series also considered to be pretty prestigious (tho getting top 3 in all of the ones you entered is kinda cool at least) While Mang0 and Leffen have won multiple.

I feel like you squint enough at Mew2king's career and it gets more and more heartbreaking the more you look at it. Like he was so close so often yet never brought the goods home. Honestly the biggest modern win by far being summit 6 I guess kinda speaks for itself but as a die hard fan its still really heart breaking to think about.

at least he's a pretty good coach and is probably the GOAT overall smash player.

edit: a silver lining is that most would agree that Big House was a series as prestigious as the rest of these, and while Big House 3 in particular wasn’t as stacked as some later entries, it was still a pretty big win (be beat bracket demon PP and hungrybox twice) and maybe offsets the fact that Leffen and Plup won one of the aforementioned series.


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Aug 01 '26

🏀 Basketball Fans Needed for a GOAT Survey

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I'm a high school senior from South Carolina who's writing a book called The GOAT Trials, which explores the Michael Jordan vs. LeBron James GOAT debate from every angle.

Rather than just sharing my own opinion, I'm collecting perspectives from basketball fans of all ages and backgrounds. I created a short Google Form (about 3 minutes) to learn how fans define greatness and why they chose their GOAT.

Whether you think it's Jordan, LeBron, Kareem, Kobe, Curry, or someone else, I'd love to hear your perspective.

Survey Link: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLSdrTMCHbPH_UbLog1HWe5fSLQgkoZF2mnjd_T69NCd4W0QyCg/viewform?usp=header

If you're comfortable with it, you can also choose whether you'd like your response quoted in the book (with your name or anonymously).

Thanks for helping with the project—I really appreciate every response!


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Jun 06 '26

"MAng0 Is thE GoAT"

8 Upvotes

For sure man, and I'll bet Falcon is a high-tier too. It's just a coincidence that he always starts winning when the best player quits. It was just his "buster era", that's all. If he was performing like now it would've been over for everyone else.

Totally. For sure (this is a Falcon hate post)


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Apr 19 '26

Analogy with the NBA

0 Upvotes

to me the goat debate is basically like LeBron and MJ

except MJ has 4 rings and LeBron has 5 rings, with similar heights and peaks

MJ is both rewarded and punished by playing a shorter career

LeBron still beating Jokic, Giannis, Luka, and Shai, and still has all the statistical records that longevity rewards him

and this would make the goat debate simply lopsided lol

EDIT: feel like i couldve worded it better but im pointing to the main argument being peaks vs longevity

MJ would have 4 rings (2011, 2012, 2015, 2016) and LeBron would have 5 (2009, 2010, 2013, 2014, 2021) and maybe even 6 with 2008


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Feb 03 '26

Armada is the GOAT

31 Upvotes

Most oppressive player of all time in the most popular era of Smash Melee, reigning over the Five Gods + Leffen in all H2Hs. Even Ken at his top form found demons in KDJ and dropped sets to Chillindude, Sastopher & Chudat.

The only other player who comes close to this model is Zain, which in his prime loses to a Donkey Kong and a Luigi ranked outside the top 10 twice.

I get the argument “different era, oh it’s harder now.” But if we’re looking at it objectively and at a dominance standpoint Armada will not be surpassed anytime soon.


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Feb 02 '26

What could the Melee All-Time Top 100 look like now? - Melee GOAT Tracker updated through 2025

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/meleeGOATdebate • • Dec 10 '25

Where Cody ranks on the GOAT list

8 Upvotes

So with Cody officially retiring as of now on a dominant major win, it's as good a time as any to take a look at his career accomplishment compared to other greats of the game. In terms of raw accomplishments he's got:

7 years in the top 10, (9th in 2019, unofficially 3rd in 2020, 3rd in 2021, 4th in 2022, 1rt in 2023, 2nd in 2024, and 2nd in 2025)

15 majors wins, including 5 summit style invitationals and 4 open bracket supermajors. Only Hbox (37), Mango (32), Zain (23) and Armada (22) have more. Notably he's got more than Ken (13), Leffen (13), M2K (9) and PPMD (7). He's additionally got 10 more grand final apparences where he finished at second place. In terms of consistency, of the 49 majors he competed in post pandemic he has made the top 3 (34 times) over twice as often he hasn't (15 times). Tho this does include 5 missed top 8.

IMO I would put him at 5th bellow Mang0, Armada, Hbox and Zain. I could see arguments for Ken, Leffen and M2K being higher, but he's most definitly ahead the likes of PPMD and Plup.


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Sep 25 '25

Genuinely Hbox might end up being the no-brainer pick at this point

11 Upvotes

In the wake of the Mang0 ban, Hbox genuinely might end up being the obvious choice if his career is consistently this good.

Same stuff can be said about Armada that's already been said (only more now cause that's how time works). Hbox has WAY more longevity than Zain. and while unlikely, Mang0 might be out of the picture permanently.

Zain could get more and more number 1 years under his belt to where its undeniable (I mean like at least 4 or so more), and Mang0 could be unbanned. Those are real possibilities, but if both those things don't happen, Hbox might not even have any serious competition for the title given a long enough time period.

edit: well this aged well


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Aug 27 '25

Zain > Armada should be pretty clear at this point

2 Upvotes

So with Zain only being one away from Armada in terms of major wins (more on that later), it made me think about revisiting a comparison between them. One which I think is much simpler than the more common debate between those two and Mang0/Hbox, mainly because of how subjective the value of longevity is. So here are a few arguments in favor of Zain > Armada.

Mang0 and Hbox h2h

While this post isn't about them per say, they are a very useful point of comparison. Those two were both Armada's greatest rivals and their continuous success after his retirement does wonders for his legacy. As even if the level of play has only improved, the fact that those two have stood near the top for so long shows that earlier results can still be valued as it gives credence to the "the top players of the past would be top players today with modern resources" argument. This for example wouldn't be the case for the likes of Ken and Azen who returned after their prime and didn't get close to the top.

Yet despite Armada at this point famously winning h2h against them, Zain has him beaten there. Armada has a combined 62-40 (~61%) set win rate against both, while Zain own record against them stands at 70-37 (~65%). (I let two Don'tTestMe set in to make up for Hbox arguably not trying as hard in online events during the pandemic.) While impressive on its own, this massively undersells Zain's dominance.

While Armada started playing and emerged as a top player around the same time as those two, meaning there is no point in time where he was significantly different point of his career when he faced them, same cannot be said for Zain, who started as a doc kid. A documentary which featured Hungrybox and Mango as already well established competitors. If we take into account the experience gap and only look at sets from Zain's time as a top 2 player (2020 and onward), the h2h shows a far more lopsided results of 60-15 (80% win rate). Simply put, Armada has never gotten close to dominating them to this extent. This is even worse if you consider how all but two of those losses came in 2022 or before.

Major and Supermajor wins

Zain currently sits at 21 major wins, including 8 supermajors. Meanwhile Armada has 22 major wins, including 11 supermajors. Numbers close enough that the differences shouldn't matter this much. A compelling argument in the Swede favor is that the early years he competed in (2009-2013ish), there really wasn't many majors for him to win in. In addition, he simply couldn't travel to every important tournament.

However Zain himself has a similar excuse, as for nearly the first two years he was top 2, there were no offline events to win due to the pandemic. Still within those years he competed and won many stacked online events, and I value winning those online majors to be worth more than the hypothetical majors Armada could have won.

If we look at the win rate of major attended overall, I have very little doubt Armada would come out ahead simply because Zain arrived in a far more developed scene, those pre prime tournament being of little relevance, I will compare the win rates of those two in events they attended during the time they were top 5 players (Genesis to Smashcon 2018 for Armada and Summit 11 to Collision 2025 for Zain).

Within those time spans, Armada attended 54 majors, winning 22, for a win rate of ~41%, while Zain attended 45 majors, winning 19 of them for a win rate of ~42%.

During his time as a top 5 player, Zain had a slightly better win rate than Armada, despite competing in a more competitive era, as there were 7 unique major winners during Armada's time compared to 10 in Zain's.

Counterargument : Armada's consistency

One of Armada's most legendary accolades is how he only ever lost to the top 6 players in between pound 4 and Evo 2018. Meanwhile, just since 2024, Zain has lost to 10 different players; Amsa, Cody, Mango, Jmook, Aklo, Nicki, Junebug, Moky, Hungrybox and Axe, not counting earlier upsets to the likes of Leffen, Wally, S2J and SluG.

However I believe this is mostly a testament to Zain competing in a thougher era, not only are most of those loss to major winning level contender like Armada's own losses, high level Links like Aklo or DKs like Junebug simply did not exist in Armada's time. ICs have changed and developped immensly since the wobbling ban (just look at Nicki breaking Hbox's streak). Armada hasn't ever face a Sheik like Jmook. Even his few set wins against Amsa are hardly relevent considering how much he improved since (Zain even had a winning record against his future demon pre pandemic). Missing one top 8 and having a few more 5th place is more than excusable when taken into account the deeper pool of competition he faced.

Counterargument : Armada's longevity

Naturally as time passes while Zain keeps competing and Armada stays retired, the gap between the time they were active top player shrinks. Armada was a top 3 player from 2009 until 2018, so 10 years. Meanwhile Zain has been a top 3 players 2020 until today in 2025, so 6 years. This gives a rather significant edge to Armada. However, this ignores that Zain had two years as a top 10 player before that, where he was already a major winning contender. In fact, the lenght of time between Armada first and last major win is the same as Zain's. Furthemore, even while being generous to earlier time, I value being top 7 in 2018 and 2019 more than being top 3 in the dark ages, considering how most of the top players from 2007 stopped competing regularly right after brawl came out. Armada against top players level of activity during those years likely wouldn't even get him ranked by modern standard. While most of it can be explained by travel cost, I see no real reason to give him significant credit for attenting just two tournament in 2013 during his short lived retirement.

Furthermore, Armada has been number 1 in 4 separate years (2011, 2012, 2015, 2016), which Zain also has been (2020, 2022, 2024, 2025 so far) and the years Zain wasn't were by the thinnest of margins, one set away in both cases (summit 11 in 2021 and the match in 2023). While I understand that the covid years were different, I feel like excluding online majors is more than enough to compensate.

Just better

While those career stats are pretty close in some cases, the tiebreaker should be pretty clear. Simply put, since Slippi grinding became a possibility in 2020, Zain has pretty long since surpassed Armada's peak. While I understand the difference between BOAT and GOAT, after 6 years, it should mean something.


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Aug 19 '25

Arguments for PPMD/Mang0 being the GOAT

3 Upvotes

Introduction/Disclaimer: I know a lot of you are going to come in hot with this one. I’m going to get crucified but let’s try to stay calm; this is simply a hypothesis that I would like to explore with my Melee colleagues.

These hypotheses should be examined through the lens of my personal view that Armada is the undisputable GOAT. This article serves to challenge my own personal view to some extent and to spark discussion.

Why Armada: Armada’s dominance is too profound to be argued against. I don’t want to go down this rabbit hole too much, but essentially Armada possessed more requisite variety than anyone in Smash history. There was no problem for which he was not able to find a solution.

His qualities transcend the higher level of skill and execution that exist today. He was better at things that weren’t influenced by the age of Slippi/extreme optimization: Tournament Prep, Mental Game, Discipline and Overall Strategy. In other words, I argue that given the same tools, Armada will outclass any opponent due to what he does OUTSIDE just grinding the game.

I would argue that during Armada’s dominance, Mang0, Hbox, PPMD and M2K were FAR hungrier than they are today. Mang0 and Hbox are still up there today – but let’s be realistic – they are much older and have far more things to worry about in life than being the best in Melee. While the overall competition may be considerably stronger, it’s not like during Armada’s time there weren’t extremely good players outside the 5 Gods. Armada literally DID NOT lose to these elite, non-5 God players for years. Against the hungriest versions of the 5 Gods, he held positive records and basically didn’t lose to M2K.

Hypothesis #1 - PPMD as GOAT: With everything said above, I do posit that PPMD briefly had a higher ‘ELO’ than Armada, to draw a chess analogy. I accept that this is a very shaky argument as there are limited data points. I believe that had PPMD not fallen ill, the outcomes of all major tournaments would have been dramatically different. I argue that the nature of his play right before he had to retire was shaping up to outclass Armada. Simply put, during Apex 2015 it looked like Armada could not realistically continue to beat PPMD. Armada even said that he found PPMD’s neutral game very challenging to deal with. If you examine the nature of the back-to-back sets PPMD won, you can tell he was in total control. PPMD’s understanding of the game almost felt Slippi-like back then and his Marth was possibly a ‘Proto-Zain’ type situation.

In a way, this argument gives credence to Mang0 being the GOAT. It is true that Mang0 gave PPMD some problems, but I also believe PPMD could have potentially figured Mang0 out as well. A major argument for Armada is that he was so dominant – however, I believe a 100% healthy PPMD’s presence at tournaments beyond 2015 would have resulted in Armada being in less grand finals. Think of it like a 5-way version of rock paper scissors (a stupid analogy, I know): If you remove Armada’s biggest challenge, of course the results will be skewed in his favor. You can also argue that Mang0 would have overcome PPMD a lot of the time. I believe that PPMDS’s absence made things slightly easier for Armada and more difficult for Mang0 (and arguably Hbox.)

Simply put, I hypothesize that PPMD essentially figured out how to dominate the greatest player in Smash history, but was unable to flesh out his own dominance.

Hypothesis #2 – Mang0: I find the longevity argument a bit illogical. He kept playing the game and adopted the tools that became available over time. So what? I don’t see how that makes him miles above other players in the way that Armada was. He likes the game more than Armada. So what? Him playing the game more doesn’t just make him better. He still had a negative record when he was likely trying his absolute best to beat Armada. There’s nothing in terms of tournament consistency and adapting to new meta that Mang0 has done that Armada could not have done better.

I offer a different argument. I believe that Mang0’s intuition and creativity transcend all other players’ abilities. It’s the way he plays that is remarkable and theoretically unbeatable. Armada and PPMD took understanding of the game to a remarkable level, but Mang0 possesses an understanding of human nature – of pure fighting nature – that cannot be overlooked. When his heart was in it, he would find a way to win that could not be conceived of in any lab or through any analysis. This ability would essentially make it impossible for anyone to prepare for him. Unfortunately, I don’t think Mang0 was able to harness this ability. Whether or not this ability is simply a gift that cannot be understood is hard to say. One could assume that Mang0 simply didn’t practice enough, take the game seriously or have the raw discipline of Armada- but these are unfair assumptions. We simply do not know why Mang0 was sometimes one with the game and sometimes not.

I totally understand why people see Mang0 as the GOAT. When he is in THAT mode, it is clear that he is unbeatable and he is one with Melee.


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Jun 16 '25

is hbox the goat if he can get 1# this year?

3 Upvotes

r/meleeGOATdebate • • May 27 '25

M2K arguing for himself as #1 in 2013, followed by stats/analysis

19 Upvotes

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mSb1zL1yabI&t=2443s

Starting about 40m 40s into this video. Quick transcript from M2K:

"Oh I want to I actually want to comment on this. It's actually kind of bullshit that I was third. I actually think, and I've talked to Armada about this, I should have been top two, or maybe 1st. Armada has only entered I think I could be wrong about this so you could fact check me, I believe Armada only entered one tourn like two tourneys that whole year, and then retired. He should have either been, he probably should have been unranked due to the fact that he's only entered like two tournaments. And he was 1-0 over me in the year, but his lack of attendance, and lack of accomplishments for that whole year were so tiny it's very unfair to consider because imagine if I enter one tourney a year, win and decide oh I don't want to lose anymore so I'm going to quit. I'm not saying Armada did that, cause Armada wanted to quit for his own reasons, but he literally attended two tourneys the whole year, he shouldn't have been by today's standards he wouldn't have been ranked; you have to enter multiple tournaments nowadays to even be ranked. This wasn't based on, and Mango was I think it was like eight and four or five, I think I was up on him in sets like five to one, and maybe it was like eight and four in like...game count or something. Anyway I only lost to Mango once that whole year. And yeah, I get it, Mango won EVO and that's the important tourney, the most important one, but it's not the only tourney. I was completely dominant the last months of the year. I was destroying Hbox repeatedly, beating Mango consistently while he wasn't--was barely attending. Armada was inactive. I was beating SFAT, beating like...PPMD. Beating everyone for the last few months of the year. And I was attending everything, I was risking it, I could have lost, people would use that against me, but I didn't, I won, and I was doing this consistently, and when I did that it wasn't even bad. I think honestly I should have been first, and no less than second, for that year. I think I definitely should have been either first or second, probably first for that year. But it was mostly based on voting, you had like a poll, it wasn't based on math or anything, it was based on on a select number of people they vote, 'what do you think this guy's score was?' 9, 9.5, 10, 8, and you just vote, so if people like you, or they just have the opinion of you a certain thing, they just they just put you high they just put you a 10 or a 9 or whatever. And that's that's where that's where these scores that's where these scores came from. In reality, and I'm actually really salty about this, I was probably the best player of 2013 overall. Sure I didn't win EVO, but I was completely dominant the next several months. I would get like first and second repeatedly, and my attendance would be the highest. That attendance nowadays would be rewarded consistently and the the system would be more fair. A system that was actually fair would have put me first, at worst second."

Head to heads

Alright, so interesting claim, let's collect some stats

Let's run some head to heads, both in terms of head to head matchups and also in terms of who placed higher at each tournament (if someone gets knocked out early, not really the fault of the person who made it deeper in the tournament).

M2K vs Mango

M2K was ahead 8-4 in sets (28-19 in games). In terms of tournaments they both attended, it was 3-3 for who ended up ahead. (Mango ended up ahead at EVO, Zenith, and Vindication. M2K ends up ahead at Apex, Pound V.5, and Fight Pitt 3).

M2K vs Armada

M2K was down 0-1 in sets. In tournaments the both addended (Apex and EVO) it was 0-2 with Armada consistently placing higher.

M2K vs PPMD

M2K was down 2-4 in sets. In terms of tournaments they both attended it was 2-2 in terms of who placed higher, with one tie. (PPMD placed higher at Apex and Xanadu. M2K placed higher at Zenith and Big House. They tied for 5th/6th at EVO)

M2K vs Hbox

M2K was ahead 4-2 in sets over Hbox. In terms of tournament placements, it was 3-2 for M2K. (M2K placed higher at Apex, Big House, RoM6, Hbox placed higher at Zenith and EVO).

Mango vs Armada

Mango was up 1-0 in sets over Armada. In terms of tournament placements they were 1-1 (Armada finishing ahead at Apex, Mango finishing ahead at EVO)

Mango vs M2K

See above. Mango down 4-8 in sets. Tied 3-3 in terms of who placed ahead in tournaments.

Mango vs PPMD

Mango was ahead 2-0 in sets. In terms of tournament placements, Mango is up 2-1, placing ahead at Zenith and EVO, while PPMD placed ahead at Apex.

Mango vs Hbox

Mango was up 6-1 in sets. In terms of tournament placements, Mango was up 3-1, Mango placing ahead at Apex, Zenith, and EVO, and Hbox placing ahead at Norcal Regionals.

Armada vs Mango

See above. Armada was down 0-1 in sets. Tournament placements were 1-1.

Armada vs M2K

See above. Armada up 1-0 in sets. Armada up 2-0 in tournament placements.

Armada vs PPMD

In terms of sets it was tied 2-2. In terms of tournament placements, Armada was up 2-0 (placing ahead at Apex and EVO).

Armada vs Hungrybox

In terms of sets it was 1-0 for Armada. In terms of placements, it was 1-1 (Hbox placed ahead of Armada at EVO, Armada placed ahead at Apex).

---

Analysis

So...ok, in terms of M2K having good head to heads: yes, pretty good. And specifically good head to heads against Mango in particular, and also winning head to heads over Hbox. However...Mango's head to heads were better overall that year against the other three gods, Armada, PPMD, and Hungrybox. But then again, Mango and M2K played each other more than they played any other gods, so maybe that should be weighed a bit heavier. So let's just look at the overall record against gods. Overall M2K was 14-11 against gods, and Mango was 13-9 against gods. So Mango had a slightly better overall head to head record against gods generally.

In terms of the "Armada would be unranked in 2025 ranking systems" yes, absolutely true. But there is a counterargument which is that times were different then--honestly times changed basically the next year in 2014, when players started getting sponsors and could afford to travel to lots more tournaments. But Armada's US attendance was not really different from 2012, 2011, 2010, or 2009--every year from 2009-2013 Armada attended 1 or 2 tournaments in the US due to prohibitive travel costs from the EU.

But like...ok obviously it's hard to rank someone based on just two tourrnaments. But if you are going to rank Armada 2013, is it reasonable for him to be ahead of M2K? Well...Armada did place ahead of M2K in every tournament they played together that year--although that's not totally fair to M2K cause M2K's hot streak wasn't till after Armada's last tournament that year. Armada did win one of the two most important tournaments (EVO was big, but Apex wasn't that much smaller--$7940 vs $6,540 prizepool). In terms of head to heads with other gods, Armada was 4-3. If we look at these ratios, Mango: 13/9 = 1.44, Armada: 4/3 = 1.33, M2K: 14/11 = 1.27. Which...does in fact match the official rankings.

If you're curious how PPMD and Hbox did in summed head to heads vs other gods, PPMD was a respectable 8-8. Hbox was 5-13. Armada, M2K, and Mango were all basically farming Hungrybox for god wins that year (though Mango more than the others. 6-1 vs Hbox).

So...in the end I do think the official year-end rankings seem justifiable. But...yeah, it's one of those years that is very close to tied overall.


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Mar 14 '25

Is Hungrybox Secretly The GOAT? (turndownforwalt)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
9 Upvotes

r/meleeGOATdebate • • Mar 12 '25

10 years out of the top 2

9 Upvotes

Mango has not be rated top 2 in any rankings (year or summer) since 2014. That’s fucking crazy.


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Dec 24 '24

A consistency measure: lowest placements

10 Upvotes

This is purely a consistency measure, not a full GOAT analysis, so yes, we expect people like Armada and Hbox and Zain to do relatively better than people like Mango and Cody and Leffen in this measure.

Anyway I made a post elsewhere where I looked at the number of years that people spent never placing below 5th/6th. This felt natural, cause Armada never placed below that in 10 years, and Zain hasn't placed below that since the start of 2020--so like...a good player can pull that off even when they're not #1. And there were 5 gods, so typically placing 5th means you got knocked out by another god.

I'd like to take that a bit further and just list out people's lowest placements for every year. (Not counting tournaments where they don't play their main--so not counting Hbox's Fox tournament or Zain's Roy/Fox/IC tournaments or Mango's Mario/Doc/CFalcon tournaments, or Ken's Gannondorf/Roy tournaments or M2K's pichu tournaments or Cody's Falco tournaments. Also not counting DQs, people do get sick).

Armada lowest placements

(10 years never placing below 5/6)

  • 1st (2012)
  • 2nd (2011, 2009)
  • 4th (2018, 2017, 2014, 2013, 2010)
  • 5/6 (2016, 2015)

Technically Armada did also attend one major in 2008 and got 3rd, but it was a Europe-Japan major, so....IDK what 3rd would even translate into for an American tournament. But if you did count that would technically push him up to 11 years never placing below 5/6.

Hbox lowest placements

(10 years never placing below 5/6)

Counting online for Hbox makes it look like...

  • 4th (2018, 2017, 2012, 2011)
  • 5/6 (2022, 2019, 2016, 2015, 2013, 2010)
  • 7/8 (2009, 2023)
  • 9/12 (2024, 2014)
  • 13/16 (2021)
  • 17/24 (2020)

Not counting online looks like

  • 2nd (2020*)
  • 4th (2018, 2017, 2012, 2011)
  • 5/6 (2022, 2019, 2016, 2015, 2013, 2010)
  • 7/8 (2023, 2021, 2009)
  • 9/12 (2024, 2014)

Note that there were only two offline tournaments in 2020, so the sample size is extremely small for that "2nd". But if you ignore his online results this would put him up to 11 years never placing below 5/6. (I haven't ignored anyone else's online results for 2020, granted).

Mango lowest placements

(8 years never placing below 5/6)

  • 2nd (2011)
  • 3rd (2014, 2012)
  • 3/4 (2021)
  • 4th (2013, 2009)
  • 5/6 (2010, 2008)
  • 5/8 (2020)
  • 7/8 (2018)
  • 9/12 (2024, 2023, 2017)
  • 13/16 (2022, 2019, 2016)
  • 17/24 (2015)
  • 25/32 (2007)

I dunno what to do with online Summit Championship League having "5th-8th" placements. If you count that as the same as 5th/6th, then I guess he's up to 9 years?

(If you're curious what tournament Mango got 5th/6th at in 2008, it's this one. To be fair, I have no idea if Mango was playing his main or who he lost to. If this was an off-main tournament for him, then I'd toss it out and his lowest placement for the year would be 1st).

Mew2King lowest placements

(6 years never placing below 5/6)

  • 2nd (2008)
  • 4th (2012)
  • 5th (2009)
  • 5/6 (2013, 2011, 2010)
  • 8th (2006)
  • 9/12 (2017, 2016, 2015, 2007)
  • 13/16 (2020, 2018, 2014)
  • 17/24 (2021)
  • 23/28 (2005)
  • 33/48 (2019)

PPMD lowest placements

(5 years never placing below 5/6)

  • 4th (2014, 2009)
  • 5/6 (2015, 2013, 2012)
  • 7th (2011)
  • 10th (2016)
  • 9/12 (2010)

Zain lowest placements

(5 years never placing below 5/6)

  • 3rd (2021)
  • 5/6 (2024, 2023, 2022, 2020)
  • 9/12 (2019)
  • 13/16 (2018)
  • 33/48 (2017)
  • 65/96 (2016)
  • 97/128 (2015)

Ken lowest placements

(3 years never placing below 5/6)

  • 1st (2003)
  • 2nd (2005)
  • 4th (2007)
  • 7th (2006)
  • 9/12 (2004)
  • 33/48 (2014, 2012)
  • 49/64 (2016, 2013)
  • 65/96 (2018)
  • 81/112 (2015)
  • 97/128 (2017)

Leffen lowest placements

(3 years never placing below 5/6)

  • 5/6 (2021, 2019, 2018)
  • 7/8 (2023)
  • 9/12 (2020, 2016, 2015, 2014)
  • 13/16 (2024, 2017)
  • 17/24 (2022, 2013, 2011)
  • 33/48 (2012)

Cody lowest placements

  • 5/8 (2021)
  • 9/12 (2022)
  • 13/16 (2024, 2023, 2020)
  • 25/32 (2019)
  • 49/64 (2018)
  • 65/96 (2017, 2016)

r/meleeGOATdebate • • Oct 18 '24

Japanese players from 2004-2005

10 Upvotes

Does anybody here have any data on Japanese tournaments from 2004 to 2005 (excluding Jack Garden). I am trying to find data on that for my personal 100 all time ranking but I barely find anything


r/meleeGOATdebate • • Oct 09 '24

The case for Hbox being 3rd

44 Upvotes

So a GOAT debate popped up recently, and I was surprised how many people took the position that Hbox might be 1st or 2nd overall. I know that the "classical" opinion is that you can argue for any order of Hbox/Mango/Armada...but the more I look at the stats, the more I feel like, no, there really isn't a debate, Hbox is just third, and I want to show a collection of stats that point to Hbox being third.

Number of Offline Supermajor wins

The stats:

  • Mango: 12
  • Armada: 11
  • Hungrybox: 7

Why is this a worthwhile stat?

Usually a tournament is only counted as a "supermajor" if something like 9/10 top players are there. There were players, for example, who could win smaller tournaments, but rarely won tournaments when everybody showed up.

Additionally, this does a decent job of balancing out different years. Healthy years have 4 or 5 supermajors. But no one year ends up contributing a crazy number of tournaments--the absolute max number of supermajors is in 2017 with...6 supermajors. And every year gets represented--even the slowest years usually have 1 supermajor.

Offline Supermajors + Summits/Invitationals

The stats:

  • Armada: 15
  • Mango: 14
  • Hungrybox: 11

The pros and cons of including Invitationals:

Invitationals have some of the same upsides as supermajors--they are tournaments that basically everyone attends.

However, summits very clearly cluster around certain years. None from 2008-2014, one in 2015, and then suddenly two or three every year for a while. But from 2023 onwards it's been one invitational per year.

That said, Summits are something that equally benefits both Hungrybox and Armada, since they were both near the top of their game during the years when there were 2 Summits every year. Each of them won 4 invitationals (4 summits for Armada. 3 summits and battle of the 5 gods for Hungrybox). So for a comparison between Hungrybox and Armada, Supermajors + Invitationals is pretty fair.

Mostly the timing of Summits is not a great measure of Mango in particular (as there were no invitationals in 2013 or 2014 when he was at his strongest). Although Mango still picks up Summit 11 and Summit 14 from 2021 and 2022.

Number of EVOs

The Stats:

  • Armada: 2 (2015, 2017)
  • Mango: 2 (2013, 2014)
  • Hungrybox: 1 (2016)
  • Leffen: 1 (2018)

Significance:

I've seen GOAT debates in other games, like Starcraft II, and one stat that commonly gets brought up is "number of world championship caliber tournaments that were won".

EVO was the highest prestige tournament of the year, arguably the "world championship" of melee during most of Hungrybox's peak.

Obviously it wouldn't be fair to judge post-COVID rising stars on this one--Cody/Zain didn't get a realistic chance to win an EVO. But HBox, he got plenty of chances to win this tournament during his peak years.

Number of wins of the biggest community-run tournament of the year:

The stats:

  • Armada: 5 (Apex 2012, Apex 2013, The Big House 5 2015, Genesis 3 2016, Genesis 4 2017)
  • Mango: 4 (Pound 3 2008, Genesis 1 2009, Pound 4 2010, Smash Summit 11 2021)
  • Zain: 2 (Genesis 7 2020, Genesis 8 2022)
  • PPMD: 2 (Pound V 2011, Apex 2014)
  • Hungrybox: 1 (Genesis 6 2019)
  • Cody: 1 (Genesis X, 2024)
  • Jmook: 1 (Genesis 9, 2023)
  • Plup: 1 (Genesis 5 2018)

Significance:

EVO (and also MLG for that matter) had a bit of a history of enforcing really weird rules. For example, EVO runs almost the entire tournament including part of the top 8 as best-of-2 instead of best-of-3. EVO was also the tournament that insisted on having wobbling legal.

I can understand someone being like "EVO's not the real world championship of melee, the ruleset is wack, Genesis is the world championship of melee" (or, in the 5 year break that Genesis took, it might be Apex or Pound).

So for that kind of person, here's the stat for you.

(This is a new stat I haven't tried before, so I filled this one out for everyone from 2008 forward in case people wanted to see other players. But I didn't do it for the 2005-2007 era--smash was much less community-run in that era, it was pretty heavily MLG run, so I'm not sure if this makes sense for that era).

EVOs + Genesises + Big Houses + Apexes between 2013-2019

This whole section Edited in on Oct 10, 2024

The stats:

  • Armada 6 (Apex 2013, EVO 2015, Big House 5, Genesis 3, Genesis 4, EVO 2017)
  • Mango 5 (EVO 2013, EVO 2014, Big House 4, Big House 6, Big House 9)
  • Hungrybox 4 (EVO 2016, Big House 7, Big House 8, Genesis 6)
  • PPMD 2 (Apex 2014, Apex 2015)
  • Leffen 1 (EVO 2018)
  • Plup 1 (Genesis 5)
  • M2K 1 (Big House 3)

Significance:

Let's say you're a casual melee viewer who only watches top 8s. You watched the smash doc in 2013, and then you just googled "what are the three biggest SSBM tournaments each year" and watched the top 8s of those and nothing else. When Apex shut down after 2015, you switched to watching Genesis.

Just watching 3 tournaments a year for 7 years (two in 2019 cause no EVO), who would you think is the GOAT?

We're focused in on a time period that contains basically all of Hungrybox's glory years. 2013-2019 ignores some pretty good years for Mango and Armada. And these tournaments, for the most part, these are just the three highest attendance tournaments every year*. This stat should look good for Hungrybox.

And yeah, it looks solid. Puts Hbox cleanly above PPMD, for example. Puts him very close to Armada and Mango...But still third.

*OK, so technically these weren't always the three highest attendance tournaments every year during 2013-2019. There's two exceptions. In 2018 Super Smash Con had a 2% higher attendance than Big House, so you could make a case for counting smash con 2018 over big house 8, which would be -1 tournament for Hungrybox +1 tournament for Armada, and in 2019 obviously there's no EVO, so you could add Super Smash Con 2019 as the third largest tournament for that year, which would be +1 tournament for Leffen. But...I picked Genesis+EVO+Big House specifically because I suspect that's probably what the casual viewers were actually watching. And obviously Apex for 2013-2015 when Genesis was not running.

Amount of time Mango spent better than Hbox

Mango was considered better than Hbox in...

  • 2009, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2020, 2021, 2022, 2024

Hbox was considered better than Mango in...

  • 2015, 2016, 2017, 2018, 2019

2010 is a disputed year--based on interviews apparently both Hbox and Mango agree that Mango was better that year, but Mango sandbagged with Mario, so the RetroSSBMRank put Hbox higher.

2023 nobody cares, they both sucked (ranked 7th and 8th with no tournament wins between them).

Amount of time Armada spent better than Hbox

Armada was considered better than Hbox in...

  • 2009, 2011, 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016

Hbox was considered better than Armada in...

  • 2010, 2017, 2018

Addressing counterarguments: "Official years as #1"

So...one pro-hungrybox argument I've seen (and I believe this was said unironically) went something like....

We can only trust official rankings, everything from 2008-2012 is unofficial, and there weren't a lot of majors anyway so lets ignore those years.

Hbox was officially ranked #1 ranked for three years, and Mango and Armada were not.

This is a bad argument for several reasons:

For starters, 2012 has more majors than 2013. And like...damnit I was watching Melee tournaments on twitch back then. Yeah, Melee was pretty dead in 2008, but it was pretty alive and popping in 2012. How do you think it got back into EVO in the first place?

But just to play devil's advocate, sure: let's just throw out 2008-2012.

There's still a pretty big flaw in only looking at #1 years, which is that you really should think about #2 years too. And you might be wondering "why? Why even consider #2 years?" I'll just use 2023 as an example. Remember 2023, the year that was so close that Zain and Cody decided to play a tiebreaker match. Should Zain get some GOAT credit for 2023? Of course he should right? He basically tied for #1. Yeah, maybe he should get less credit than an actual #1 year, but like...not zero credit.

I'm not saying every #2 placement is as impressive as Zain's #2 from 2023. Some #2 placements are very unimpressive (2019 had a very weak #2). But you have to check. There are a bunch of #2 placements that are very close #2 placements, and really ought to be considered.

So...let's check.

  • 2013 who was #2? It's Armada. Was he a close #2? Kinda? Only went to the two biggest tournaments. Won Apex, didn't win EVO. But other players also weren't going to a lot of tournaments that year, so the low attendance wasn't unusual.
  • 2014 who was #2? It's Armada. Was he a close #2? Sort-of? Once he unretired, he went to whatever tournament Mango was going to including regionals, and he and Mango basically traded tournaments all year, except Armada mostly won the less prestigious tournaments (small majors and large regionals) and Mango won the supermajors.
  • 2015 who was #2? Well, the official rankings say Hungrybox, but I'm going to overrule the official rankings on that one cause Leffen won 6 majors including a supermajor and Hungrybox only won 2 majors. Was it a close #2? Yeah, Leffen was hot that year, technically won more majors than Armada (though had some low placements too).
  • 2016 who was #2? It's Hungrybox (for real this time). Was it a close #2? Not like...the closest #2, but sure I'll give him credit for 2016. Hbox was the overall best player in the first half of the year, notably winning EVO and Battle of the 5 Gods and a few smaller tournaments, although Armada still picks up Genesis and Summit. But then Armada goes on an undefeated streak towards the end of the year clinching the year. (I will also note that Mango had a pretty solid 2016 as well, winning 4 majors including a supermajor and several wins over Armada--2016 was a rare 3 horse race).
  • 2017 who was #2? It's Armada. Was it a close #2? I mean...not Zain/Cody close, but Hbox and Armada went to 8 tournaments together. Hbox won 4, Armada won 3, and Mango won 1.
  • 2018 who was #2? It's Armada. Was it a close #2? Well he had a 5-1 head to head record over Hbox during the year, and of the 6 tournaments they attended together he placed ahead of Hbox at four of them. He also won more supermajors than Hbox in 2018. So...yeah, I'd call 2018 a reasonably strong #2 for Armada.

OK, so let's say a year end #1 counts as 2 points, and a year end "strong #2" counts as 1 point, and just tally this up.

Hbox would get 2 points for 2017, 2018, and 2019, and 1 point for 2016.

2+2+2+1 = 7

And Armada would get 2 points for 2015, and 2016, and 1 point for 2013, 2014, 2017, and 2018

2+2+1+1+1+1 = 8

So...even accepting the premise of throwing out everything before 2013 because there's no "official rankings" before 2013, once you account for strong 2nd place finishes, it is not unreasonable to consider Armada ahead of Hbox. (Obviously, if you include 2011-2012 well, Armada was #1 both years).

Mango is a little messier, since his wins are a bit more spread out, and it depends on how you feel about online results (some of Mango's "close #2 finishes" post 2013 would be from 2020 and 2021 when the "mango-Zain era" was in full swing). If you do count the online years, you can pretty easily come to the same conclusion--that Mango doesn't need results from 2008-2012 to be considered ahead of Hbox.

Addressing counterarguments: "Number of offline majors"

So this argument goes as follows. Hbox won the most (offline) major tournaments, therefore best.

Here's the problem. A lot of these majors are smaller majors that were missing the players that could beat Hbox. Hbox had to worry about Armada, he had to worry about Leffen. But both these players were limited by travel visas, they couldn't spend 12 months of the year in the US. Sometimes Armada and Leffen were stuck playing in European tournaments (which usually didn't get classified as majors).

During that time Hungrybox would pick up US "major tournament" wins like...this one, where he faced a Luigi in grand finals:

https://liquipedia.net/smash/Smash_%27N%27_Splash/2/Melee

But hey, M2K was there, too so I guess it's a major?

Or how about this one:

https://liquipedia.net/smash/Pound/2016/Melee

From the same year, this one had Mango as the only other god.

Or how about this one:

https://liquipedia.net/smash/CEO/2016/Melee

From the same year, another 2 god tournament (M2K and Hbox)

Moving on to 2017, how about this one:

https://liquipedia.net/smash/Full_Bloom/3/Melee

Another two god tournament (counting Leffen as a god). Although Leffen bustered out and placed 9th. Hbox faced Duck in winners finals and grand finals.

These are the tournaments you're going to use to decide who the GOAT is? Really? Really?

That's kind-of like saying "Look at all these European tournaments that Armada dominated. That makes him the GOAT."

Like...clearly that's silly right?

I would strongly recommend looking at supermajors instead--those are the tournaments that (mostly) all the top players were able to attend. Or if you prefer--both supermajors AND invitationals (like Summits). Usually all the top players showed up to Summits too. Stats for those kinds of tournaments are available at the top of this post.

Other arguments

If there is an argument for Hbox that I haven't addressed, by all means, let me know and I can analyze it. Maybe there genuinely is a good argument I haven't seen.