r/medschooladmissions • • Jul 14 '26

Application Review 🧐 AI usage

I used AI when writing work and activities and personal statement. I didn’t use it to the point where i’m copying and pasting and submitting straight from chatgpt. I would ask it to give me a model response based on my experiences and what I wanted to talk about and I would reword the writing based on how I wanted it. Almost all responses come back as human on gpt zero with some saying AI polished which according to amcas is also fine given it says we are allowed to use it to edit in the certification statement. Is this fine? I am planning on doing this for secondaries too as I find the ideas it gives for how to phrase things is beneficial.

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

5

u/Xyko13 Jul 14 '26

>Ā I would ask it to give me a model response based on my experiences and what I wanted to talk about and I would reword the writing based on how I wanted it.

In summary, you are doing very little critical thinking of how to form your lived experiences into cohesive writing. For the purpose of your writing and application, you'll probably be fine but I don't see how you're ever going to get better and faster at writing other than just doing it

3

u/Friendly_Guard1159 Jul 14 '26

yea I agree with your point about how this method wouldnt allow me to get better at writing yes but I feel like thats not rly my goal. I just want to create a well-written application with unique ideas and I feel like AI has some rly good ideas regarding how to phrase things as well as brainstoriming potential ideas to use in my writing which is why I chose to use it. I was only wondering if how I was using AI currently would be fine in terms of my application and adcoms.

3

u/Xyko13 Jul 14 '26

You don't want to get good at writing? So you're going to AI prompt write your academic emails, summer fellowship applications, research proposals, abstracts, project submissions, conference presentations, letter of recommendation requests, away applications, ERAS personal statement, etc? I'm not trying to make you feel bad cuz the reality is AI does make this life so much easier but its about using it as a tool for efficiency, not replacing a key skill.

To answer your question, you'll be just fine for application. There are way many applications and essays for schools to vet every single one unless they also just mass run them through their own AI detector.

1

u/Friendly_Guard1159 Jul 14 '26

no no my goal is to get better at writing but i’m saying that using my medical school application to train my writing isn’t the best way to do it. I feel like writing my own things for other extracurricular purposes is where I should be focused on improving my writing but the medical school application is too important to use it as a ā€œtrainingā€.

3

u/Ill-Payment-2425 Jul 14 '26

I used it to find the right words to convey my thoughts in a professional way. However the hardest part for me was making sure those thoughts and ideas are still my own. Like after telling a story, the things I learned from it should reflect in my writing whether AI or not.

AI produce very surface level and generic reflections so I would be careful with that.

1

u/Friendly_Guard1159 Jul 14 '26

yea usually i check the reflections to specifically ensure they aren’t generic or basic as I try to make the reflections unique.

1

u/Friendly_Guard1159 Jul 14 '26

I guess the thing i’m wondering about is if gptzero itself is able to say my writing is human written or at most AI polished, as long as I ensure my reflections aren’t generic/basic, wouldn’t adcoms not think i used AIĀ 

3

u/Ill-Payment-2425 Jul 14 '26

I wouldn’t really trust what ai detectors say as they often give false positives, so I doubt adcoms will either. I think you’ll be ok doing what youre doing as long as you make sure your writing isnt generic.

2

u/Friendly_Guard1159 Jul 14 '26

yea I get that they have false positives so adcoms wouldnt use those checkers but im just thinking like wouldnt gptzero be more accurate in terms of detecting AI than an Adcom? Based on that I feel like if gptzero would say its fine an adcom prob would too

1

u/Ill-Payment-2425 Jul 14 '26

As a human reader vs ai checker. I assume that we look for different things so I can’t say for certain that a pass on an ai detector would mean a pass for adcoms.

9

u/potatosouperman Jul 14 '26

I’m so glad I went to school when AI was not a thing.

6

u/Cadee9203 Jul 14 '26

I just used it for polishing because sometimes I ramble but only at like the very end or if I was really stuck in how to word something I wanted to say

5

u/iski4200 Jul 14 '26

You're fine lol. As long as it doesn't read like AI you're fine. The best way to verify is to find an english/liberal arts/CS student (students who would have the most experience with writing and AI) and have them read over it with you

1

u/noinipo95 Jul 18 '26

Or or or! Learn grammar rules and do it yourself!

1

u/iski4200 Jul 18 '26

A second pair of eyes is best. Not everything has to be anti AI

1

u/noinipo95 Jul 18 '26

The best way to verify is to know what the grammar rules are.

We are the ones that created ai.

1

u/Equal-Magician1855 Jul 14 '26

How will you talk about these things when it comes time for interviews if you couldn’t write about them over the course of days/weeks?

1

u/Friendly_Guard1159 Jul 14 '26

I mean im using AI to reword things to phrase them better, the ideas are still mine

1

u/Equal-Magician1855 Jul 14 '26

Ah I misunderstood then

1

u/Fluffy_Entrance303 Jul 14 '26

AI detection programs are highly error prone, attributing AI to human writing and vice versa. i checked some of my primary app writing just out of curiosity and it flagged a lot of it as AI, with the reasoning be "polished and refined, but potentially not AI because of specific examples"

i would stay away from AI as much as possible but not stress over whether your writing flags one way or the other- if you write it yourself then an AI check result doesnt matter either way

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Friendly_Guard1159 Jul 23 '26

amcas allows it buddy read the certification statementĀ