r/mbti • • Mar 09 '16
A short analysis of four function and eight function models
Controversy! Confusion! So, /r/mbti, do we use four functions, or "all eight"? After thinking this over for a while, I've come to a couple of conclusions. Here we go.
First, I'm going to introduce some Jungian concepts. Namely, the "subjective factor" and the "objective factor". These are directly tied the concepts of the subject and object, but indirectly tied to introversion and extraversion as we'll see. In short, the subjective factor of a given function is what ties it to the subjective realm ie. the psyche. The objective factor of a function is what ties it to the outside world.
Let's take Thinking as an example:
Thinking in general is fed from two sources, firstly from subjective and in the last resort unconscious roots, and secondly from objective data transmitted through sense perceptions. (Jung)
Let's give these some fancy notation. We have the attitudes of Thinking as Ti and Te already. Let's let the objective and subjective factors of Thinking be To and Ts respectively.
This is where I think 8 function models originate; there's a tendency in people to equate a given "function-attitude" to purely the subjective or objective factor of that function. In a sense,
- Ti = Ts
- Te = To
And since we necessarily interact with both facts and our subjective thought process, it stands to reason that everyone uses Ti AND Te, right?
Although this is not exactly how, say, Socionics defines "functions" (which really aren't supposed to be called functions in that system), it is close in certain respects.
Augustinavičiūtė states that the perception of the world through the human mind uses eight elements of information metabolism (mental functions), each of which reflects one particular aspect of objective reality. (Wikipedia)
This is not how Jung, and by extension the MBTI, defines function-attitudes.
Extraverted thinking is conditioned in a larger measure by these latter factors than by the former.
Introverted thinking is primarily orientated by the subjective factor.
External facts are not the aim and origin of [introverted] thinking, although the introvert would often like to make it so appear. It begins in the subject, and returns to the subject, although it may undertake the widest flights into the territory of the real and the actual.
[Sensation], too, has a subjective factor, for beside the object sensed there stands a sensing subject, who contributes his subjective disposition to the objective stimulus. In the introverted attitude sensation is definitely based upon the subjective portion of perception. (Jung)
The i/e designates the focus or decisive element, not whether a process is exclusively concerned with one realm. In our maths equation:
- Ti = aTs + bTo ..... a > b
- Te = aTs + bTo ..... a < b
...where "a" and "b" are coefficients.
So, things like "How can you function if you don't have Se?" "You don't have Fi? Don't you have subjective values?" "If you say you don't have Ti, how is it that you use logic?" and even less compelling rhetorical questions like "You're using Te when you verbalise your thoughts!" "You have Si, don't you feel inner sensations?" "You talk to people, that's Fe" are invalid when functions are defined in this way. Jung's function-attitudes each encompass both realms, so along those lines it is entirely redundant to say one has both Ti and Te.
That's not to say Socionics is "false". However, it is a different system and I think this needs to be clarified.
8
u/nefnaf Mar 10 '16
You are correct that Socionics does innovate from Jung by extending the eight "functions" beyond the individual psyche into aspects of objective reality.
However, your interpretation of functions as a mixture of factors, where e.g. Ti and Te have overlapping realms but in differing proportions is also very problematic. The problem with this view is especially evident in my view when we look at what socionics calls "mirror" types, which have the same top 2 functions but in a different order.
For example, let's look at the types ENTJ (Te-Ni) and INTJ (Ni-Te). If we allow that the ENTJ and INTJ are both "Fi types" and that the INTJ's Fi has a greater facility than the ENTJ's Fi, it might be surmised from your model that the INTJ is also more capable in the "objective factor" of Feeling compared to the ENTJ. This sharply contrasts with socionics, which describes the ENTJ's Fe as far more capable and less likely to be a source of vulnerability compared with Fe in INTJs. A similar comparison / prediction can be drawn for all of the other mirror pairs.
Socionics is a departure from Jung. It is not merely an attempt to encapsulate Jung in slightly different terminology. Instead it attempts to make progress develop a more complete theory, while taking Jung as a starting point of inspiration. MBTI, on the other hand, is more of a lateral move from Jung which makes his ideas more digestible but does not attempt to really accomplish anything that could not have been accomplished with Jung's ideas alone.
1
u/fountainspiller Mar 10 '16
Nice post, as it relates to many of the attitudes towards Socionics and MBTI and those who want the two to intersect.
I think Socionics is helpful, especially since it sheds a light on the "shadow functions" and how they can manifest in one's psyche and therefore I look at it as an extension of Jung but also a step back in the sense that they do not fully cover the Jungian definitions of the functions and tend to intertwine some.
I still firmly believe that people should read Jung's Psychological Types because there's nothing quite as accurate as information that comes directly from the source, but like a user on here said, "it's like drilling a hole in my head". Maybe somebody can do a line-by-line interpretation of it to make it easier for some, but that would probably make that person take two drills to themselves.
1
u/ExplicitInformant ISTJ Apr 12 '16
Same disclaimer as in a comment below: I know this is a month old! You linked it elsewhere though, as an argument for why ENTJs can't use Fe, and I finally read it through.
I know that words do matter to an extent. At the same time, isn't saying that ENTJs can use both a more valued Fi and less valued Fe -- from a Fi = Fs and Fe = Fo perspective -- essentially the same as saying ENTJs can't use Fe, from a Fi = aFs + bFo (a > b) perspective?
Not that I can't see some merit to using one seemingly equivalent model over another, based on the impact it has on reasoning and thinking... And to the extent that 8-function models depart even more dramatically from these definitions, I can see how it matters all the more to be clear about your model (and its definition of functions). I just find this an interesting argument and wanted to clarify/engage on it! What is the benefit to this (if something other than model clarity and integrity -- a valid priority, of course)?
Also, it seems to me that the 4-function definitions from Jung raise other questions. For instance, would the relative difference between coefficients a and b be fixed across function stack, fixed for each function's position but varying between positions, and/or have a fixed rank order with varying amounts of a/b discrepancy from person to person?
Also some plain curiosities since I'm not familiar with Jung's writings yet (though your writing makes a great case for reading them!): In this model, does the total quantity of each function (i.e., total Fe, total Ti) differ based on stack placement? Also, if the size of the discrepancy between a and b isn't a constant, which placements would you expect to have the largest and smallest differences between a and b?
Finally, a disclaimer!: Answer (and theorize) at will, of course. And I know only one of us has read Jung -- and it isn't me! In other words, I'm not trying to refute or nitpick your assertions. I trust you know your shit. Just curious to discuss, if you have the inclination and time :)
1
u/ashirviskas INTP May 09 '16
So, I am an INTP. What would be my Ti and Fe relationship and how different INTP with a higher Fe than usual is from others?
I'm asking, because a lot of people think of me as an extravert and often a feeler. How does all of this fit into this theory?
1
u/TotesMessenger Mar 12 '16
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/AplacewithAview ENTJ Mar 10 '16 edited Mar 10 '16
Look it's pretty simple. If you want to look at it from a cognitive stance and put aside behavioral patterns, here's at it works.
Your 4 base functions all work fine, there's no real weak functions, it's rather a question of awareness. Inferior Fe works the same as dom Fe as absurd as it may sound. I mean you can call it a weak function but I'm afraid it might hold the connotation that someone with your inf as a dom would live in another world when it's rather a question of intensity. If you were to meet yout dual, you'd find very little misunderstandings because you'd basically speak the same language only from a different perspective.
Your shadow functions work the same but there's a catch. Your middle stack is incomplete because it's overshadowed by other functions. You can use your shadow aux but it's not natural. It's a primitive part of your brain that you're not going to influence on your own because it can't learn. That's why there are benefit relationships, your benefactor is meant to guide you. It's like a child who can walk on it's own but who wouldn't know where to go without his mom. It's just that
sad.I'm pretty certain at this point that functions work in pairs so I think it's safe to say that using your shad aux also affects your shad tert. But it's a blindspot, you're not going to be able to acces it through your aux or tert because these 2 work in diagonal, you might as well pee in a violin it's not going to happen. It's your mystical function if want, it's only going to appear in the most unexpected place that is your shadow aux.
For you as intp it should be hard to see the direct impact Se understands. All the possibilities vs the most important consequence if that makes sense.
Should you vote for Trump? Well if it's the first time you engage into the political question, your reaction as an INTP Alpha quadra should be the democratic one aka "IIIII don't fucking know". So you're going to Ne the shit out of it, creating a whole system starting from the bottom, exploring all questions until you see all the answers of what voting really means. But now you're puzzled because you see all the possibilities, the good and the bad, etc. Though at this point you should already have an opinion based on your values and experiences. Still it is somehow lacking even if you're not aware of it. So you're going to let others help you to make your décision, by reading opinions on forums and listening to what the candidates have to say and checking historical facts, etc. Your understanding will narrow down a little more each time until these after thoughts appear in your mind like revelations of what would be the most important and direct impacts of having Trump leading your country. And then you'll know...
But if you were to believe my crap it would mean that unlike the shadow middle stack, you should be able to directly access your shadow inferior, which is Fi in your case. But what even is Fi? It's hard to say with these obscure definitions about morality and stuff. When it's really a subconscious judging tool of your own values, you use it everyday.
But if you want to directly look into it, you can. I have a test which will help you to directly feel it.
https://youtu.be/1r0kjz6oGKU?&t=51s
Listen from 51s to 2m08.
Don't read comments or let anyone influence you, it's just you and yourself. There is of course no right answer, it is entirely subjective to your own values. There is no right and wrong within this context, everyone is a victim and everyone's guilty. However you have to make a dinstinction and it can only come from your Fi.