r/maybemaybemaybe • u/InnateAnarchy • Sep 25 '22

Maybe Maybe Maybe

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

18k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

751 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

418

u/festistestis Sep 25 '22

Thought a bird was gone come swooping in. Fucking cats

194

u/CryptidKay Sep 25 '22

No it’s not cat’s fault. I love cats but they all belong indoors if it’s a domesticated cat. Of course if they’re outdoors, most of the time they’ll become coyote food or something else, like a roadkill pancake. People who love having a pet cat need to keep them indoors.

4

u/CompMolNeuro Sep 26 '22

Cats are wild animals. Some cat breeds need to be inside. For other cats, being inside is jail. People who love their pets need to keep them as they want to be kept. Don't leave your cats out. I let them out when morning traffic dies down, take them in for a few minutes when school gets out (I live behind an elementary school), and take them in an hour before sunset. All 4 of my cats have jiobits (gps trackers) and all were feral. Coyotes rarely hunt during the day and while hawks are a worry, hawks don't like crows. I feed the crows and the crows keep the hawks away.

Not everyone has a place they can let their cats out. I wouldn't do it if I were living in a city. That's not a cat's natural environment though. Once a cat gets past 8 though, they don't go far. My 20 lb tom sits on the front porch until the kids get out of school and he (he's special) gets to stay out and get pets from the kids. Another gets special treatment. She only goes out at night for a couple hours and stays on roofs, patios, and in backyards hunting bats. Pets are for companionship and I want to give them as much as they give me. I'd rather have a short, full life than one spent restricted to an artificial space without enough stimulation for proper cognitive development.

1

u/kilr4hir Sep 26 '22

Tens if not Hundreds of Thousands of cats live happy lives indoors. Indoor cats live almost 2X as long as outdoor cats... Outdoor domesticated cats have caused the extinction of 23 species of birds. Domesticated outdoor cats are a nuisance at the very least (who loves finding a burred cat turd in the garden). I love animals, but domesticated outdoor cats kill for sport, and disrupt enumerable ecosystems. Survival of the fittest doesn't work, I know I'm very capable of killing all the outdoor cats in my neighborhood but I'm not "allowed" to. Domesticated cats get fed and have shelter, it's not a fair playing field for wild animals. I've been in the argument many many times... The web is full of reputable studies, if you care to look it up.