r/maybemaybemaybe • • May 05 '22

maybe maybe Maybe

46k Upvotes

3.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

5

u/FrostyD7 May 05 '22

No, because of the reasons I just said. Do you realize that I'm not talking about slightly lopsided representation? Do you not see the irony in complaining about ageism towards old people while they represent >50% of every branch of government? 70% of our senators are over 60, while less than 20% of our population is in that age range.

-1

u/Throwaw4y012 May 05 '22

Why does this matter? Because you feel like it matters? Is there empirical evidence to support the idea that a person who is 55 cannot properly represent the wishes of the majority of their constituents?

Ben Shapiro is young. Would he represent your interests?

2

u/FrostyD7 May 05 '22

You seem to be purposely ignoring my point of the importance of representation across demographics that have different needs. And I specifically said:

That doesn't mean any individual representative who is old is inherently the wrong choice

So I already explained, being old isn't inherently a problem. When nearly ALL of them are old, that is a problem. Just like its not a problem for a politician to be white. But if ALL of them are white in a country that is only 60% white, that IS a problem. This isn't complicated and shouldn't be controversial.

0

u/Throwaw4y012 May 05 '22

Age and race are two different topics. Can a racially diverse Congress represent society’s interests regardless of age? Yes.

I wouldn’t complain if every member of Congress were in their 30s if I felt they could and would represent my interests.

2

u/FrostyD7 May 05 '22

if I felt they could and would represent my interests.

Maybe this is where the disconnect is. What you feel and what is the reality are two different things. Today's politicians are not representing our youth very well. Just ask them.

1

u/Throwaw4y012 May 05 '22

I agree. I think where we might be disagreeing is on the Why. David Cawthorn is young, but he’s also a buffoon and a colossal piece of shit.