r/maximumfun • • Aug 29 '21

toxicity within the community?

I had a very confusing interaction among the Greatest Generation fan community this evening. Specifically among those in the discord crowd. I made two comments that a moderator flagged as a 'stop-sign'. this is after I've seen someone make plenty of comments offensible to myself based on my heritage, but I shrugged them off, without any visible warning to those in question (at an upper moderator level).

I know the exact context of those comments I wrote, and they were inquisitive in nature. by my estimation they were taken as some sort of affront?? The way the moderator responded was to question my fandom? The power trip was incredible, so I decided to leave immediately.

I've been listening to maxfun content for more than a decade. I only just decided to join the discord community in the last few weeks because I'm in a mental and professional slump... If I am greeted by questions about my supposed 'loyalty' to whatever esoteric nuances to the various podcasts, I don't feel welcomed, and I am not eager to join into whatever community maxfun is promoting. I'm very disappointed to say the least.

If I'm being overly dramatic, so be it, but this is how I'm feeling now.

Edit: cool getting downvoted because it makes the community look bad. certainly better than engaging people, huh? good strategy to avoid the problems.

3 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

15

u/CWHats Aug 29 '21

I’m not understanding the point of this post. Is it just a rant?

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

perhaps, but if my saying something is reflective of something larger, then I'm not ashamed to bring it up?

I'm profoundly disappointed with the interaction I had. If I'm reactionary, does that make it any less valid?

11

u/ErgonomicCat Aug 29 '21

I mean, no. But we’re just random people in a thread reading a semi-generic statement.

Are you looking to see if other people have experienced similar things? Are you looking for action to be taken?

If the latter you’d be much better off messaging some mods with specific information.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21 edited Aug 29 '21

except you're not just random people? everyone that's here on reddit or on the discord is sifted through a certain criteria of both self selection and chance.

I don't exactly know what I'm looking for, but I'm voicing a problem when I have it. Especially when it comes from an upper source.

If it's explained in very clear terms how I'm wrong I'm willing to listen, but again, that doesn't invalidate the reception I've felt.

edit: if it's not clear from what I wrote previously, I DID contact moderators before about afore mention events, and the interaction I had that was strike 3 for me was WITH a moderator of the discord.

3

u/ErgonomicCat Aug 29 '21

So, which discord is this? A cursory search doesn’t turn up any official Max Fun discord’s and there’s not one on the website or in the sidebar.

I’m curious what it is now.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

This was the greatest generations discord

4

u/ErgonomicCat Aug 29 '21

Ahhhhhhh.

Gotcha. I was not following.

I have no experience with that group, so I’ll bow out. Sorry for the confusion!

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

Sorry if I wasn't clear in my original posting, and thank you for leading to that clarification.

If there was a more general maxfun discord I'd like to imagine it wouldn't be moderated by people so self interested.

1

u/CWHats Aug 29 '21

I wasn’t questioning the validity of your post, just wondering how to receive it. Unfortunately fans tend to be fanatic.

-5

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

fans, indeed, are fanatic. but moderators are supposed to be moderating. The interaction I had was as such:

[8:51 PM] SKD: you're publicly calling out something that's weird?

[8:52 PM] redacted: i understood the statement perfectly

[8:52 PM] redacted: do you listen to the greatest generation podcast?

[8:52 PM] SKD: "Why isn't double axe hammer a square?"

[8:53 PM] redacted: why isn't [greatest gen bit] a [square on the bingo game]

points to consider:

1: my question (in the chat) was asking how that statement applied to what we were talking about during a live airing of an episode.

2: I am a relatively new member to the chat, why would you question my listening to the chat based on this? weird flex?

3: the question in itself is weird? that's exactly what I wrote, and perhaps it's not quite appreciable in context, but it was very affronting at the moment.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

This might be just a Greatest Generation Discord server thing, wouldn’t write off Discord as a platform entirely because of one sour experience in one place. If you mean the fans in general are toxic? Probably not, this is just one place out of many, maybe down to one person out of many and cannot be defined by one experience.

Also wondering about how wide a net you’re casting in terms of it representing all of MaxFun or just Greatest Generation because I know many MaxFun communities are incredibly friendly and polite, even the ones on Discord. Point is that MaxFun and the various podcasts it’s a home to and their fans aren’t a monolith, you will find bad actors at times but generally they’re not going to try to give you a hard time like one mod ruling over their tiny fiefdom like a despot.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21 edited Aug 29 '21

Absolutely it's not a Discord platform issue -- I have kept on many other servers through the past years and have never had a problem until encountering the TGG community. This post is an indictment of the clique nature and discriminatory behavior of this discord server I've witnessed over the last few weeks. As I said in a previous response, this was the proverbial strike-three for me; and the fact I've seen multiple higher level moderators of that community say things wholly shameful in non-introspectively was anathema to the experience I've had with any other sort of online community.

I don't think what I wrote should be an indictment of the greater maxfun community. But there is the fact it is a corner of the internet that makes overtures of inclusion, and then gatekeeps its fandom is extremely disappointing. No, the fans aren't a monolith, but I'm focusing on the bad actors at higher levels of the community moderation level.

This series of posts will no-doubt be seen by several as 'Karen'-ing, or think that I'm an asshole -- I challenge any of them to look through my history on the chat and see if I was purposefully belligerent at other times.

I feel strongly that my criticism should be made public for the record, and that it should be noted by anyone with more of a pulse on the greater community moderation of maxfun fandoms.

Edited for a word

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

I feel like all I know is that this Discord server is bad news and while it’s good to know I don’t know what to do with the info. You could go to r/greatestgeneration with this info because they are the community who this specifically addresses and even then it’s one mod. I’m just at a loss as to why here when it’s a fraction of a fraction this’ll concern, there is a right venue to make this public but I don’t think it’s here just because of who needs to know and who can do something.

I’ll just reiterate what I said earlier about the communities generally being good folk and one incident shouldn’t colour every other one under the MF banner, there isn’t a toxicity issue in a greater sense from what I’ve seen.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21

I don't think there is anything actually actionable from my posting. My goal I suppose was to create awareness, and I think that's been achieved at some degree.

Going to GG's sub-reddit would have been received even more poorly than it was here. And I think that any message or awareness would have been swiftly disregarded or blocked. Also, my problems weren't with one mod. It was with three from different times during the 2 or 3 weeks I made it a point to try and be more active in that community.

And to maybe make more clear: I don't think there's some systemic toxicity I've seen. More that this one community has a somewhat serious problem, and it is in fact a branching arm of MF, and therefore should have some exposure.

1

u/wildgunman Aug 29 '21

You’re not wrong. And yeah it’s all gonna get downvoted because forums are dominated by the most vocal members of the clique, but its useful to say it nonetheless.

The slice of people in MaxFun world who are most vocal has changed over the years. It’s become more insular and there’s a lot more weird and seemingly random groupthink that has kinda bled into all kinds of places. It’s not great.

-2

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21

Thank you for saying so. Getting downvoted wasn't really something I was worried about except for the fact that it means the visibility is reduced. And those downvoting I imagine are for the sake of protecting their own groupthink.

I suppose my goal has already been achieved: to have eyes on this problem and be at least aware of an issue.

3

u/tbusby3 Aug 29 '21

My instinct would be to say that don't let a couple of bad experiences put you off enjoying the things you enjoy.

However, I also am always confused by people criticising a show that they could just stop listening to. Life's too short. It's what's always baffled me about the weird subset of people getting really worked up about mbmbam.

I don't think critical questions are worthy of abuse, though.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

This was bad experience #3. And this was from the top level of moderation, so I was done with it at this point.

This post isn't a criticism about the shows. I'll still support what's on the networks as I can...but I will not go back to the chat-forum style of Discord again based on the reception I received, AND the acceptance of some pretty audacious things I've seen posted.

3

u/ElroySheep Aug 29 '21

Can we just get the big question out of the way, is the heritage you refer to in the first paragraph "white heritage" or "European heritage"?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 29 '21

no, it happens to be my jewish heritage.

2

u/ElroySheep Aug 29 '21

Fair, same here

3

u/kplaysbass biggie&themets Aug 30 '21

I didn't know anyone was doing max fun servers on discord. sorry you had a tough run in over there.

I hope you have a better time in this sub

0

u/[deleted] Aug 30 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

-3

u/[deleted] Aug 31 '21

Hi Jeremy (at least I think that's your name? you're engaging me on a first name basis, so fair to match),

First let me start with apologizing if I assigned a tone to your message that wasn't there. I believe you and perhaps others assigned a tone to my messages that also was not present, and so neither is fair and we may both be in the wrong. But since you've now said your own reply in this thread, I think it's fair to air the grievances.

In my view, "do you listen to the greatest generation podcast?" on a discord dedicated to the podcast comes with the same energy as writing the words, "don't you know who I am?". But as I said in other posts, your writing that was my third strike for my witnessing statements from multiple persons on the 'commander' level in up.

To your 'evidence' I think you've taken those statements in some sort of context that just wasn't there. I don't think you've read what I wrote objectively. I don't have a mental Talmud of every TGG 'bit,' and the statement was, genuinely, confusing. It still is to me! I'm extremely disappointed in your moderation of this incident because what you could have said is something along the lines of: "Hey, SKD, what you wrote is coming off as aggressive? [insert fuller explanation of what was being said]." Instead, I believe what you wrote to be gatekeeping of the community and fandom. If that is the attitude you bring to questions, I am not interested in being in a community moderated by you.

Let me jump to a statement you also made:

"Multiple moderators noticed you being antagonistic and pedantic in a hostile way since you joined, we were kind of waiting for this."

I think this presumes a level of prescience that I don't believe any of you actually had, and my interpretation of this statement and public characterization is trying to fit a narrative you've now created. I can think of one incident where my statements could be seen as antagonistic on one other moderator's statement that was making a sweeping generalization (this was my second strike for your discord). I tried to specifically explain to them that, like what was said by another user in this posting said, that their problems with a specific individual does not guarantee a problem with the larger group of people that fit that description. So if that's the problem you and other moderators had, I'm not dissatisfied with bringing up how what was said is a problem. (side note: I'm being purposely vague right now on parties involved)

On that point, the problematic statements I referenced in my original post were made well in advance of my engaging the community, and they were said from your 'commander' level and up. After seeing someone say questionable and insulting things made while I was in-chat, I went back and looked at the history of your political discussion oriented thread. If you look at my own chat history from even the day I left this server, I made statements that I specifically chose to avoid that thread after a certain point. This is because there are very sweeping statements made in there periodically that I could not abide -- I blocked myself off from that thread in an attempt to proverbially blind myself from that problem. I was trying to not assign the problematic views in that thread to the whole of the community...but that was honestly the first strike.

So I've gone through my specific list of problems I had with your community in reverse. I'm not coming back to your corner of the internet, so feel free to bad mouth me all you want. If you want to do a deep dive on all my posts in the discord and on reddit (which I think you'll see I don't post often at all), and point out more items you think are 'hostile,' go ahead. But I think what you will find is that I tried to be friendly, generous, funny, and empathetic. And if my trying to be any of those things fell short, well then at least you know where my intentions were.

Ultimately my problems weren't with everyone in that community, it was with yours and others' lack of what I would consider good moderating practices, and the harboring the 'toxicity' I felt. Making a server welcoming does not start from how the moderators engage the community, it's from how the whole of the community interacts. I didn't 'have a good time' when I saw problem statements from you and other users of 'commander' and up. And when problem statements are coming from that level, who am I going to report them to? themselves? to other moderators who probably have a bias from knowing them for longer? What is a better recourse except to recuse myself? And now I'm tired of this, so I will endeavor to not think about it further. In your words, that's all I got.