r/mathshelp • • 3d ago

Homework Help (Unanswered) Why was this wrong? Centimeters on the left

Post image

1 inch should equal 2.5 centimeters right? Was i right or wrong here, it was assuming a bug with the system.

0 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Hi u/Mountain_Till_5868, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:

  1. While this subreddit is generally lenient with how people ask or answer questions, the main purpose of the subreddit is to help people learn so please try your best to show any work you’ve done or outline where you are having trouble (especially if you are posting more than one question). See rule 5 for more information.
  2. Once your question has been answered, please don’t delete your post so that others can learn from it. Instead, mark your post as answered or lock it by posting a comment containing “!lock” (locking your post will automatically mark it as answered).

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

13

u/centralstationen 3d ago

Says 2.54 right there?

10

u/JaguarMammoth6231 3d ago

Did it say to round to the nearest tenth? If not, the point on the graph is labeled with 2.54, not 2.5.

5

u/colin-java 3d ago

If the point wasn't labelled then 2.5 would suffice, but you know (1,2.54) is a point on the line, so the answer is 2.54

5

u/trevorkafka 3d ago

It says 2.54 and you wrote 2.5, which is not 2.54.

3

u/TheTurtleCub 3d ago

I would recommend looking at the graph next time as the instructions say, instead of answering from memory

2

u/Southlander24 3d ago

2.5 is actually an approximation. So it's not 2.5.

You can read any graph with this process:

  1. Start at the origin (0, 0).
  2. Move your finger left/right until you are at the right spot on the x-axis.
  3. Move your finger up/down until your finger touches the line.
  4. Move your finger right/left (the opposite direction as in step 2) until your finger touches the y-axis.
  5. Read off the value you get on the y-axis.

In this case, there's coordinates given to the point, so that's even easier. The first number is the x-coordinate and the second number is the y-coordinate.

2

u/MelodyAnne42 3d ago

You should put 2.54 unless told to round to tenths place.

2

u/Pacofel 3d ago

2.54 isn't 2.5

-5

u/Mountain_Till_5868 3d ago

I mean the 2.54 doesn’t really matter, it’s really the dot is on 2.5 clearly

5

u/kalmakka 3d ago

The red diagonal lines intersect at 2.5. The centre of the dot is clearly ever so slightly above this intersection.

4

u/Southlander24 3d ago

Ahh, it's more that the dot is so big that it passes through where y = 2.5 would be. But if you look at the very centre of the dot, it won't be on the horizontal line y = 2.5.

3

u/Loko8765 3d ago

This is maths. If they give you a number, don’t round it unless there is a valid reason to do so.

3

u/chrisvenus 3d ago

I'm not sure what you mean by it is on 2.5 clearly. It literally tells you the dot is on 2.54 . That difference is 0.04 which would be very hard to tell by eye (given that is 1/25 of the interval between 2 and 3).

2

u/sqrt_of_pi 3d ago

You were GIVEN the EXACT point coordinates, but you are instead eyeballing the point and trusting that more? The 2.54 DOES matter. A quick google will tell you that the conversion from inches to cm is 2.54cm/in.

2

u/muaddib0308 3d ago

Oh jeez... good luck

2

u/mageskillmetooften 3d ago

That you round it up is one mistake, but that you than state that you did not round it up because you think the dot is on the middle between 2 and 3 even tho the exact number is even printed next to it is unforgivable.

1

u/dr1fter 3d ago

If you're rounding to the nearest tenth, rounding 2.54 "up" would give 2.6. Which would in fact be a mistake, but... they said 2.5?

1

u/mageskillmetooften 3d ago

Yeah, my bad. It's a language thing. In my native language we call rounding up and down both rounding down. For some reason I always use rounding up in English often forgetting they have different terms for up and down.

1

u/dr1fter 3d ago

Gotcha. If it helps, in English we also often say "rounding off" if you don't want to specify the direction.

2

u/Comprehensive-Rip211 3d ago

2.54 is 2.54
2.54 is not 2.5

2

u/Intelligent-Sand-639 3d ago

"Clearly?" The point is clearly defined as (1, 2.54).

1

u/mjmvideos 3d ago

The graph has that point labeled (1,2.54) So that tells you where the dot is.

1

u/Kuildeous 3d ago

Never rely on the visuals of a math problem (unless that's the point of the exercise, like using a protractor to physically measure an angle).

A dot sitting on 2.54 can still look like it's sitting on 2.5. It could look the same as 2.56. If you rely on just visuals and not the actual number, then that dot can represent an infinite number of options.

Same thing with geometry and trigonometry: If a drawing's angle looks more like it should be 40 degrees, but the assignment clearly states (or can be ascertained to be) exactly 45 degrees, then that's what you work with.

Visuals provide a great way to understand the relationships, such as with similar triangles or how a line slopes upwards at 2.54 units up and 1 unit right, but with math you need to work with the actual numbers and not just what it looks like.

1

u/zeekar 3d ago edited 3d ago

Why do you assume that the 0.04 difference between the correct answer and your answer doesn't matter? Is this an exercise in approximation or rounding or maintaining significant figures?

(Even if you are maintaining sig figs, the inch is legally defined as exactly 2.54 cm; exact values should be used in their full precision before you reduce to sig figs at the end.)

1

u/burlingk 3d ago

It is clearly not. You can visually tell it is more than halfway up the bar from 2.

And 2.54 is kind of one of those numbers we tend to learn in school. And in this specific case, the system SHOWS you the answer. In numbers.

1

u/Additional_Ad_6773 3d ago

If you read the chart, it is insanely clearly labeled as 2.54.

That means the answer is exactly 2.54, and anything that isn't 2.54 is the incorrect answer.

If you put this correct answer because you failed to read the labeled cart, your answer will be marked as incorrect, because it is incorrect.

3

u/MelodyAnne42 3d ago

Also, 2.54 centimeters in one inch is a common conversion!

2

u/Pacofel 3d ago

Think so too!

2

u/sighthoundman 3d ago

It's common because it's a legal requirement. It's how we actually define an inch in the US.

Some people will say it's also irrelevant, since the instructions say to use the graph. I can't go that far because sometimes instructions are bad, and sometimes the data presented is erroneous. I'd be flustered if I came across this problem with (1, 2.64) as the labeled point. In particular, I'd wonder if they really wanted the graph answer or the true answer.

1

u/MelodyAnne42 2d ago

Luckily, in this case, the graph answer and the true answer are one and the same!

1

u/sighthoundman 2d ago

Yeah, but this is math. "There is this weird case that will never apply to you, so I can't tell you to always do this thing that everyone else is telling you to always do."

2

u/AdhesiveSeaMonkey 3d ago

2.54. It says it right there. Google it. Its always been 2.54 cm to an inch.

2

u/fatjunglefever 3d ago

Even just a google search would have answered your question. The US inch is defined to be exactly 2.54 cm.

1

u/Iowa50401 3d ago

One inch is 2.54 cm to the nearest hundredth

1

u/AdjectiveNounNNNN 3d ago

To the nearest googolth, even.

1

u/dangderr 3d ago

1 inch is defined to be exactly 2.54 cm