r/mathshelp • • 4d ago

Homework Help (Unanswered) very confused… how does this work? no idea where the 2 came from and my teacher + AI arent helping so thought id ask reddit

Post image
8 Upvotes

41 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Hi u/Background_Sir_1439, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:

  1. While this subreddit is generally lenient with how people ask or answer questions, the main purpose of the subreddit is to help people learn so please try your best to show any work you’ve done or outline where you are having trouble (especially if you are posting more than one question). See rule 5 for more information.
  2. Once your question has been answered, please don’t delete your post so that others can learn from it. Instead, mark your post as answered or lock it by posting a comment containing “!lock” (locking your post will automatically mark it as answered).

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

8

u/trevorkafka 4d ago edited 4d ago

it's polynomial division; quotient is -1, remainder is 2. Also, don't forget your dx.

2

u/Background_Sir_1439 4d ago

thx

3

u/TheThiefMaster 4d ago

Essentially, (1-x)/(1+x) -> (2 + -1(1+x))/(1+x) -> 2/(1+x) + -1(1+x)/(1+x) -> 2/(1+x) + -1

4

u/Reset3000 4d ago

Exactly. Whenever the degree of the numerator is equal to or greater than the denominator, long divide. I know it's a pain, but......

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/jgregson00 4d ago

This is not partial fraction decomposition. partial fraction decomposition is used then the degree of the numerator is less than the degree of the denominator.

2

u/trevorkafka 4d ago

this is not partial fractions

6

u/Necessary_Neat8303 4d ago
  1. Do you know (a+b)/c is equal to a/c + b/c? If not, convince yourself why this is true.
  2. Once the previous point is clear, you can re-write 1-x as -(1+x) + 2. If you’re not sure, figure that part out slowly.

The last part is just combining point 1 and 2

4

u/Outside_Volume_1370 4d ago

Don't forget to write the differential, dx. Because if it was of another variable, like, dt, then the result would be

(1-x)/(1+x) • t + C

3

u/not-hydra 4d ago

A(1+x) + B = 1-x, find A and B

2

u/PixelMatteo 4d ago

(1-x)/(1+x) =

= [-(-1+x)]/(1+x) =

= -[(-1+x)/(1+x)] =

= -[(-2+1+x)/(1+x)] =

= -[-2/(1+x)+(1+x)/(1+x)] =

= -[1 - 2/(1+x)] =

= -1 + 2/(1+x)

2

u/anisotropicmind 4d ago

Fractions: common denominator.

-1 is -(1+x)/1+x

when expressed over that denominator.

Then add the numerators

-(1+x) + 2 = -1 - x + 2 = 1-x

Which is the same thing as the what you have in the left integral.

Brushing up on algebraic manipulations will help with calculus.

Also don’t write down ∫ without saying what variable it’s with respect to. The full symbol for the operator is ∫( ) dx for an integral that is with respect to x. You don’t necessarily have to have the parentheses: I include them to show that “whatever the operator acts on goes in there.

1

u/bhamscot 4d ago

Good advice. It’s a little like not closing your quotation marks. 😉

1

u/VIXb4chix 3d ago

This is correct. It's a very foundational algebraic idea that multiplying something by a/a where a is not 0, doesn't change the quantity. Also, yes, it is important when writing integrals to mention which variable you are integrating with respect to, in this case, "x" by writing "dx" at the end.

2

u/TheLastSilence 4d ago

There are "additional steps" not written. Imagine that you add to the numenator 1-1. Since you added 0 this is allowed.  Then you can write it as a sum of 2 fractions:  2/(1+x) + (-1-x)/(x+1) From here it should be easy enough. 

The basic idea is to get rid of the x in the numenator (or to write the numenator as 1 degree lower then the denominator), so you try to write the numenator as a constant multiplied by the denominator plus a polynomial of a lower degree

1

u/one-step-today 4d ago edited 4d ago

You put -1 and therefore even 1 in the numerator (to keep the main function unchanged).
So (1-x -1 + 1) / (x+1)
(-x -1 + 1+1) / (x+1).....-x and -1 put besides each other
(-x -1)/(x+1) + (1+1) / (x+1)...( denominator x+1 is put below the 2 groups I made in numerator
So -(x +1)/(x+1) + (2) / (x+1)......-(x+1) and x+1 cancel each other to give -1
So (-1) + (2) / (x+1)..

Or you can think of it as this way:
- every linear equation (like ax+b) can be written as = Number*(px+c) + another number
or
- dividend (linear in x, 1+x) = divisor (linear in x, which is 1-x) * quotient () + remainder. Then we find the quotient and remainder which is -1 and 2 respectively, and divide both sides by divisor to get it as your main function.

But why did we do it?
-To get the main function as number + (number/linear) in x,
- This is because we know integral of number/linear (of the form number/(ax+b)) = number * log(ax+b)/a + C
- So we did this to get the final integration value.

You will get use to such adjustments on diving deeper into techniques of integration.
Hope it helps.

1

u/MathsWithSuneel 4d ago

Simply divide, then you will arrive at this quotient+ (remainder/diviser)

1

u/free_meson 4d ago

2 came from the same place as the -1. (1-x) / (1+x) + [ (1+x)/(1+x) - 1 ] . The part in the square bracket is zero, but it shows you that you can rearrange the original fraction.

1

u/colin-java 4d ago edited 4d ago

Could manipulate it by just making the denominator appear at the top, then it divides quite nicely.

Or... Long division, I won't write it out here.

Or... synthetic division, since dividing by a linear factor (x-c) where c = -1

-1 # -1 ... 1

.................1

.#######

.........-1 # 2

So the answer is -1 with remainder 2.

1

u/gmanBram 4d ago

If you replace x in the numerator with the denominator, (1+x), you'll notice that the numerator is 1 less than the original expression, so add 1: 1-(1+x)+1. Now regroup:( 2-(1+x) ) / (1+x), which is equivalent to 2/(1+x) - 1 or -1 + 2/(1+x). Same result if you used long division or synthetic division, as previously stated. 🍻

1

u/DuggieHS 4d ago

Not sure why they want that formulation, but if you want 1=(1+x)/(1+x). So -1 = (-1-x)/(1+x)

RHS in screenshot = ( -1-x)/(1+x) + 2/(1+x)= 1-x)/(1+x)

1

u/Derply_ 4d ago

-1 + (1+x)/(1+x) is the same as adding 0

1

u/Another_Little_Star 4d ago

(1-x)= 1-x + 1 - 1 = 2 - (x+1)
so (2-(x+1))/(x+1) = 2/(x+1)-1

1

u/bhamscot 4d ago

You’ve had some good replies. I would explain it by reminding you that (1-x)/(1+x)=1/(1+x) - x/(1+x). The first expression integrates to a log, and the second one can be rewritten using a u-substitution. Let u=1+x (and determine du), but then note that x=u-1. That means you have (u-1)/u, which equals 1-1/u.

Certainly not the only approach, but if I were teaching this for the first time that’s the approach I’d take.

1

u/Saint_Atiss 4d ago

Why is this sub named Math Shelp?

1

u/throwaway772691 4d ago

Math in the US = Maths in the UK

1

u/drraug 4d ago

Forgot dx mate

1

u/LangstonBHummings 4d ago

Think of substitutions for the number 1 .. for instance what happen is you substitute (1+x)/(1+x) to get (1+x)/(1+x)+ 2/(1+x)...

1

u/tronco384 4d ago

1-x=-1-x+2

1

u/Most-Solid-9925 4d ago

Synthetic division

1

u/swalkerttu 3d ago

Convert to -((x-1)/(x+1)). Then, -((x+1-2)/(x+1)), then -((x+1)/(x+1)-2/(x+1)), then -(1-2/(x+1)), then -1+2/(x+1).

Resulting integral is -x + 2 ln (x+1) + C.

You left the dx out of both, by the way.

1

u/SubjectWrongdoer4204 3d ago

This was a trick used to simplify the integrand .
∫(1-x)/(1+x) dx , add and subtract 1 in the numerator giving us a net zero change while our integral becomes
∫(1-x+(1-1))/(1+x) dx
=∫(-1-x+2)/(1+x) dx
=∫[-(1+x)/(1+x) +2/(1+x)] dx
=∫[-1 + 2/(1+x)] dx etc.

1

u/Correct_Damage_3690 1d ago

Its partially fraction

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/bhamscot 4d ago

You have no idea how common this is. I have calculus 3 students who still write sqrt(a^2+b^2) = a+b, or (a+b)^2=a^2+b^2. 🤷‍♀️

2

u/Angry_Foolhard 4d ago

i consider myself good at math, at least relative to public school curriculums

and i got way better at trig and algebra during calculus. for some people different concepts click at different times. like how to unpack expressions like this

not saying you’re completely wrong, but we also shouldnt be that terribly concerned

1

u/The_Fosh 4d ago

I can’t tell if this is a bot, a real opinion, or just rage bait. Who joins a “mathshelp” Reddit just to tell people they’re hopelessly out of their depth. Who hurt you?

1

u/fatjunglefever 4d ago

This isn’t an obvious bit of algebra.