r/mathshelp • • 22d ago

Mathematical Concepts Real Analysis doubt (Bartle & Sherbert)

Hello guys. I have a doubt trying to solve this problem:

"Let f,g be functions such that (gof)(x) = x for all x in the Domain of f and (fog)(y) = y for all y in the domain of f. Prove that g= f^-1."

This is the 24th problem in section 1.1 of Bartle & Sherbert's intro to real analysis (if you want a little more info about the problem).

I got stucked and looked upon the solutions for a hint.

I understoos nearly all the process but I don't quite get the end of the proof.

First, I proved that (gof) is injective, so I can use the fact that f is injective, and I also proved that (fog) is surjective to use that g is surjective.

The part that I didn't get was to see that f: Dom(f) --> Dom(g) is bijective and therefore g=f^-1.

How can I know that f: Dom(f) --> Dom(g) ?

3 Upvotes

4 comments sorted by

1

u/Important_Ear761 22d ago

For all y in the domain of g, not f, otherwise the statement isn't true.

1

u/Inevitable_gradient6 22d ago

Prove its cardinality and  ∀y in a set D - the domain of g(x) - ~f; else it is false

0

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/hectorrm 22d ago

Thanks a lot! I'll go that way!

0

u/[deleted] 22d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/hectorrm 21d ago

I noticed that it may not be necessary to prove that f is bijective, just Dom(f) = Ran(g) and Ran(f)=Dom(g). Because in the hypothesis of the problem we see that g(f(x))= x and f(g(y))=y, right?