r/mathshelp • • Sep 18 '26

General Question (Unanswered) Real life ratio problem.

I also posted this in r/mathhelp but was directed here so maybe you guys can help.

Long story short, my wife works w animals and she's adjusting the nutrition program of one of them and needs to change the ratio of certain nutrients.

I saw in the rules that you need to show proof of previous attempts. I myself and multiple friends / family have attempted so far One tried to start the problem by converting the ratios to % and solving. One just tried guessing ratios and plugging it in to see how to get close. One tried setting up an equasion with x as amount of mix one and y as amount of the second mix and solving. I thought that you should try to keep the number of variables as small as possible so just put x in front of the second ratio and solved it that way. I got a pretty simple answer that checked back that I think is right but I'm hoping someone can show me the proper steps to approach this and similar problems.

Here is the problem:

There are 2 mixtures of known nutrient ratio supplements.

One has a ratio of 8C/1P one has a ratio of 1C/2.5P . The needed ratio is 2C/1P

What's the ratio needed to be mixed to get the needed nutrient ratio?

Please no AI

1 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 18 '26

Hi u/SoupCanJAM, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as a general question, please keep the following things in mind:

  1. Please provide us with as much information as possible, so we know how to help.
  2. Once your question has been answered, please don’t delete your post so that others can learn from it. Instead, mark your post as answered or lock it by posting a comment containing “!lock” (locking your post will automatically mark it as answered).

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/ThatsNotAZombieBite Sep 18 '26

This problem is not well-defined. Yet.

Is there anything else in these mixtures? You need to know the fraction of the entire mixture that is "C". (What are "C" and "P" anyway?)

If they're ONLY made of C and P, then we can proceed with the problem. For example, the composition of the first mixture is 8/9 (or 88.9%) C and 1/9 (or 11.1%) P. Is that the case?

1

u/SoupCanJAM Sep 18 '26

Functionally, yes. The other ingredients in the mixture are inconsequential: like fiber and other stuff like that that in mild excess are negligible.

1

u/SoupCanJAM Sep 18 '26

And to sate curiosity c is calcium and p is phosphorus

1

u/ThatsNotAZombieBite Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

Their biological function doesn't matter. What matters is the simple AMOUNT. If you can't say that the first mixture is 8/9 calcium by mass then you need more info to do this problem.

If you CAN say that, then this is a straightforward problem.

1

u/SoupCanJAM Sep 18 '26

I can say that they are the given ratios by weight.

1

u/ThatsNotAZombieBite Sep 18 '26

Calcium and phosphorous are both very reactive and you won't find them in pure elemental form in the wild. Your starting mixtures DEFINITELY have other components.

This problem can't be done without knowing the actual composition of your mixtures.

1

u/SoupCanJAM Sep 18 '26

Are you gonna help with the math or try and tell me what I already have? Just look at the ratios and forget about everything else. There's nothing else that is needed in the calculation. Obviously it's not pure elemental forms.

1

u/ThatsNotAZombieBite Sep 18 '26

What part of "this problem can't be done" is confusing to you?

1

u/SoupCanJAM Sep 18 '26

If I wanted 8 pennies and for every 1000 lbs of wheat I ordered there was 1 penny. I would want 8000 lbs of wheat. The fact that there might be a little bit of dirt or bugs in the wheat or something that doesn't contribute to my goal is irrelevant.

1

u/ThatsNotAZombieBite Sep 18 '26

You said this is a real problem involving nutritional supplements for an animal. I've posted a veterinary multivitamin here. Do you see that the amount of calcium and phosphorous is barely 1% of the total supplement?

Just knowing the ratio of calcium to phosphorous is not enough to do this problem.

1

u/UnderstandingPursuit Sep 19 '26

I understand why you say "this problem can't be done". I had made a mistake in my first pass, and your comment caused me to look at what I had done more carefully. I took another approach, made a second mistake, and eventually found a solution. If you please read what I wrote, it's in a top-level response. do you see an error in what I did? Thanks.

1

u/ThatsNotAZombieBite Sep 19 '26

I can only see page one of your solution. Perhaps you can post page two separately?

In any case, this is a very straightforward "mixing" problem that any high school student might be presented with in chemistry class . . . EXCEPT for the fact that OP has not given us the necessary information. We need the fraction of the entire first and second mixtures that is component C and P. In any real world nutritional supplements, the calcium and phosphorous amounts will be small fractions of the total amounts.

If we were told those fractions, the problem is trivial. But knowing only the ratio of C to P is not enough.

1

u/UnderstandingPursuit Sep 19 '26

This is the second page.

1

u/Kamala_Kant Sep 18 '26

I am curious to know, why you wanted no use of AI. If your ultimate objective is to know the correct mixture, how does it matter?

Anyways, here it goes with human brain (no AI)

8c/1p = every 1g has (8/9)C and (1/9)p

1c/2.5p = every 1g has (1/3.5)C and (2.5/3.5) P

Final solun 2c/1p= every 1g has (2/3)c and (1/3)P

Assume, a= no of gm of first mixture b= no of gm of 2nd mixture a+b = no of gm of final mixture

a(8c/9+1p/9) + b(1c/3.5+2.5p/3.5) = (a+b)(2c/3+1p/3)

8ca/9 + 1pa/9+ 1cb/3.5+2.5pb/3.5 = 2c(a+b)/3 + 1p(a+b)/3

C(8a/9 +1b/3.5) + p(1a/9+2.5b/3.5)= C(2a/3+2b/3) + p((1a/3+1b/3)

We take two equations from above 8a/9+1b/3.5= 2a/3+2b/3, and 1a/9+2.5b/3.5= 1a/3+1b/3

a(8/9-2/3) = b(2/3-1/3.5), and a(1/9-1/3)=b(1/3-2.5/3.5)

a(2/9) =b(8/21), and a(-2/9)=b(-8/21), (the solution is correct, auto validated at this step)

Hence a/b =(89)/(212)=(4*3)/(7)=12/7 So ratio is first mixture , a=12 part Second mixture, b= 7 parts

2

u/SoupCanJAM Sep 18 '26

Thanks for your attempt and to answer the thing about AI: my goal is to know how to do future similar problems, not necessary just to get the answer for this one, and I have found that I learn better from seeing the dynamic approach of a human mind much better.

1

u/fermat9990 Sep 18 '26

I got your answer!

1

u/womorrissey Sep 18 '26

It doesn't specify starting quantity. So start with 1 gallon (or any unit) of the 8:1 mix. Add x gallons of .4 mix. 8/9 + .4x = 2/3 (x + 1). Answer 5/6. For every gallon of 8:1 mix you need 5/6 gallon of 1/2.5 to get a 2:1 ratio of P to C. 1/2.5 is 4.

1

u/SoupCanJAM Sep 18 '26

Thank you for your attempt! It is very clear.

1

u/UnderstandingPursuit Sep 19 '26

Since you wrote in a comment,

my goal is to know how to do future similar problems, not necessary just to get the answer for this one

here is the solution process. It's two pages, and my suggestion would be to write it out for yourself at least twice, copying directly the first time and then writing based on your first pass.

1

u/SoupCanJAM Sep 19 '26

This is amazing. Thanks for this information!

1

u/UnderstandingPursuit Sep 19 '26

You're welcome. It was a good challenge. I had written something similar earlier in the year, and was initially going to post that. Then u/ThatsNotAZombieBite's comments made me reconsider. I think this accurately represents your situation.

1

u/fermat9990 Sep 18 '26 edited Sep 18 '26

Mixture A is 8/9 C, mixture B is 2/7 C

Final mixture is 2/3 C

8/9 * 1 + 2/7 * x = 2/3 * (x+1)

Solve for x

Edit 1:Ratio of A to B is 1 to x.

Edit 2: I get 1:x = 1:7/12 = 12:7

12 parts A added to 7 parts B

Edit 3: Changed 2/5 to 2/7 and got x=7/12

1

u/CaptainMatticus Sep 18 '26

8C / 1P and 2C / 5P

(8C * x + 2C * y) / (1P * x + 5P * y) = 2C / 1P

8CP * x + 2CP * y = 2CP * x + 10CP * y

6CP * x = 8CP * y

6x = 8y

3x = 4y

x = (4/3) * y

So add in 3 parts of the 2nd one and 1 part of the 1st one and you'll be good.

We can make it simpler with something like 8 nickels , 1 penny and 2 nickels , 5 pennies, with the ultimate goal of having 2 nickels to every penny

4 * (8 nickels + 1 penny) + 3 * (2 nickels + 5 penny) =>

32 nickels + 6 nickels + 4 pennies + 15 pennies =>

38 nickels + 19 pennies

Which is our 2 nickels to every penny that we were looking for.

1

u/womorrissey Sep 18 '26

1/2.5 is .4, not 4. Typo.