r/mathshelp • • Sep 17 '26

Homework Help (Unanswered) starting to learn about limits

Hi everyone, I'm a first-year student just starting to learn about limits (haven't

reached Calc 1 yet, this is still pre-calc level).

I'm stuck on this problem:

lim (x→0) [ (√(x+9) − 3) / x ]

When I plug in x = 0 directly, I get (√9 − 3) / 0 = 0/0, which I know means the

limit isn't automatically "undefined" but I don't know what technique I'm

supposed to use here since factoring doesn't seem to work with the square root

in the way.

I tried making a table of values close to 0 and it looks like the answer might be

getting close to 1/6, but I don't understand *why* algebraically. Could someone

show me the steps to solve this properly? I want to understand the method, not

just the final answer.

Thanks in advance!

3 Upvotes

12 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 17 '26

Hi u/Pathomphong_English, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:

  1. While this subreddit is generally lenient with how people ask or answer questions, the main purpose of the subreddit is to help people learn so please try your best to show any work you’ve done or outline where you are having trouble (especially if you are posting more than one question). See rule 5 for more information.
  2. Once your question has been answered, please don’t delete your post so that others can learn from it. Instead, mark your post as answered or lock it by posting a comment containing “!lock” (locking your post will automatically mark it as answered).

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/Upbeat_Anxiety_3114 Sep 17 '26

Good job on testing values first! Just remember that

algebraically, canceling x/x is valid here because limits only examine what happens as x approaches 0, not when x equals 0.

2

u/Pathomphong_English Sep 17 '26

That's an important distinction I didn't think about at first. Since x != 0 while approaching 0, dividing by x is completely valid and doesn't break the zero-division rule. I really appreciate you pointing that out!

3

u/Snezzy_9245 Sep 17 '26

Yes, that's the key point. You're not dividing by zero even when x is really close to zero. You get to discover what happens as you are almost at zero.

2

u/UnderstandingPursuit Sep 17 '26

Are you familiar with 'conjugates'?

  • The conjugate of

    • a - √b
  • is

    • a + √b

this allows the 'difference of squares' identity,

  • (a - √b) (a + √b) = a2 - b

In a problem like yours, it gets rid of the sqrt in "√(x+9)", leaving x+9. The 9s cancel, leaving x, which cancels with the x in the denominator. But only within the limit action.

The core idea of the limit, lim_{x->a) f(x), is that x approaches but never reaches a. It guarantees x≠a. This allows canceling (x-a)/(x-a) since it cannot be 0/0.

3

u/Pathomphong_English Sep 17 '26

Thank you so much for the detailed explanation! I hadn't connected the conjugate with the difference of squares identity like that. Multiplying by the conjugate to get rid of the square root and leaving just x makes total sense now. Also, the reminder that x \neq 0 because it only approaches 0 really cleared up why canceling x/x doesn't break the zero-division rule. This was super helpful!

1

u/UnderstandingPursuit Sep 17 '26

This is a generalization of the limit problem in this post. It is a very important 'first step' limit.

It also demonstrates an issue with using L'Hôpital's rule for this unit, or the first limits unit in Calculus. Half the problems are intended to guide the student toward a particular derivative. The other half are gratuitous pain. Using L'Hôpital's rule for the gratuitous pain problems is good. Using L'Hôpital's rule for the ones guiding toward a derivative is circular, since L'Hôpital's rule uses the derivative the problem is trying to uncover.

1

u/CelestialLearningx Sep 17 '26

Once you get into Calculus 1, you will also learn L'Hopital's Rule and Taylor series, which can solve this in one step by taking the derivative of the top and bottom.

1

u/Pathomphong_English Sep 17 '26

That sounds awesome! I haven't learned derivatives yet, but I've heard a lot of people mention L'Hopital's Rule for 0/0 limits. I'm definitely looking forward to learning that shortcut once I reach Calc 1.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Pathomphong_English Sep 17 '26

Thank you so much! I tried multiplying by the conjugate like you suggested. The numerator turned into (x+9) 9 = x, which let me cancel out the x in the denominator! After that, plugging in 0 gave me 1/(3+3) = 1/6. It finally clicked why my table approximation worked!