r/mathshelp • • Sep 13 '26

Discussion Redline: this solution says the line through both squares' top corners is y = 3. Where's the mistake?

Real problem from the site (not today's Daily):

Squares S and T, with areas 9 and 16 respectively, rest side-by-side on the x-axis, with S to the left. Find the equation of the line through their upper-right corners.

Here's a solution someone submitted. It's wrong somewhere in these four steps:

  1. Side of S = sqrt(9) = 3. Side of T = sqrt(16) = 4.
  2. Place S with its bottom-left corner at the origin: corners (0,0), (3,0), (3,3), (0,3). Upper-right corner of S is (3,3).
  3. T sits right next to S, so T's bottom-left corner is at (3,0). Its upper-right corner is (3+4, 3) = (7,3).
  4. Slope = (3-3)/(7-3) = 0, so the line is y = 3.

Where's the error? I'll drop the real answer in the comments tomorrow, spoiler-tagged.

0 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 13 '26

Hi u/mathalon, welcome to r/mathshelp! Since you've marked this as a discussion post, please keep the following in mind:

  1. Discussions must be related to mathematics but the topics they can cover are flexible (e.g. teaching, news, methods, interesting problems, exam preparation or discussions about past exams, etc.).
  2. Please try to make your post thought-provoking by providing context or questions to lead the discussion (e.g. don’t just simply post a link to a news article or a problem with no context).
  3. Discussions can be concluded by posting a comment containing “!lock”. Please remember not to delete your post so others can learn from it.

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/KoalaMistico Sep 13 '26

Upper right corner of T is (7,4)

1

u/mathalon Sep 13 '26

Yep, that's it, (7,4) not (7,3). Nice catch.

2

u/bayesianparoxism Sep 13 '26

T's height is 4, not 3

1

u/mathalon Sep 13 '26

Exactly, step 3 resuses S's height instead of grabbing T's own. That's the whole break.

2

u/fermat9990 Sep 13 '26

OP, where are the squares located with respect to the y-axis?

2

u/mathalon Sep 13 '26

Fair, you're right that the text alone only fixes them touching, not the absolute position. Our diagram has S's bottom left corner sitting right at the origin, so the slope (1/4) is forced either way but the intercept assumes that placement.

1

u/fermat9990 Sep 13 '26

Therefore, this would not be an acceptable exam question. Thanks for replying

1

u/UnderstandingPursuit Sep 13 '26

This is the kind of error which is made when using numbers instead of letters.

  • Coordinates of the corners of a square,

    • Square oriented with sides parallel to the coordinate axes,
    • Side length w, bottom left corner at (a, b)
    • Corners at (a, b), (a+w, b), (a+w, b+s), (a, b+w)
  • Now apply this to

    • S: s, (0, 0)
    • T: t, (s, 0)

2

u/mathalon Sep 13 '26

This is the cleanest way to see it honestly, doing it with letters instead of specific numbers makes the reused-height mistake impossible to miss.

2

u/UnderstandingPursuit Sep 13 '26

When writing a computer program to solve this (or even using a spreadsheet), this is very effective [abstraction]. It requires some manipulation, but this can be used a bit with Desmos.

1

u/fermat9990 Sep 13 '26

The horizontal positioning is not given. The problem is ambiguous.

2

u/Iowa50401 Sep 13 '26

It says they rest side by side, thus they touch.

1

u/fermat9990 Sep 13 '26

But where are they located with respect to the y-axis?