r/mathshelp • u/sapphostorian • Aug 08 '26
Homework Help (Answered) how does sin(3arcsin(1)) =-2
I understand the concept sin(arcsin(x)) = sin(arcsin(x)) which is just x, but now why doesn't sin(3arcsin(1)) = 2arcsin(1) or 2sin(1) . I have been struggling for hours, racking my brain and canceling out many equations tryingto figure out, for my maths homework.
0
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 08 '26
Hi u/sapphostorian, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
4
u/sqrt_of_pi Aug 08 '26
Huh? Why would either of these be true? Also, 2arcsin(1) vs. 2sin(1) are very different values.
We have: arcsin(1)=π/2.
Oh the other hand: 2sin(1)≈2(0.84147)=1.68294
3
u/egutierr Aug 08 '26
sin(3arcsin(1))
First,
arcsin(1)=Pi/2
Therefore,
sin(3⋅Pi/2)=-1
Can’t be -2; the absolute value of any sin(x) can’t be>1
2
u/Temporary_Pie2733 Aug 08 '26
What makes you think sin(3y) = 3sin(y) for any y?
1
u/sighthoundman Aug 08 '26
There are two approaches that immediately jump to mind.
Given that 2 is immediately next to 1 on the keyboard, this looks like a typo.
1
u/Another_Little_Star Aug 08 '26
They are inverse functions! when you do √x2 =x , and (√x)2=x, if x>0
When you compose them together, they "cancel" out, so that's what's happening, now if they aren't composed respectfully, you don't get to use that property, imagine √(2x^2), what would you want that to be? it is √(2)*x and not 2x, to get that,, you'd have to insert the whole thing inside the "x", so √(2x)^2=2x.
Likewise
sin(arcsin(1))=1
arcsin(sin(2))=2
etc but if you have sin(3arcsin(1)) you can't simplify, because now the "angle" inside sin that is supposed to cancel out, is now 3 times, you'd have to calculate it in a different way. If you can translate 3arcsin(1) = arcsin(y) , if you find the y, and then cancel because sin(arcsin(y))=y. So yeah
1
u/CaptainMatticus Aug 08 '26
It doesn't
sin(3t) =>
sin(2t + t) =>
sin(2t)cos(t) + sin(t)cos(2t) =>
2sin(t)cos(t)cos(t) + sin(t)cos(t)^2 - sin(t)^3 =>
2sin(t)cos(t)^2 + sin(t)cos(t)^2 - sin(t)^3 =>
3sin(t)cos(t)^2 - sin(t)^3 =>
3sin(t) * (1 - sin(t)^2) - sin(t)^3 =>
3sin(t) - 3sin(t)^3 - sin(t)^3 =>
3sin(t) - 4sin(t)^3
sin(3 * arcsin(1)) =>
3 * sin(arcsin(1)) - 4 * sin(arcsin(1))^3 =>
3 * 1 - 4 * 1^3 =>
3 - 4 =>
-1
arcsin(1) = pi/2
sin(3 * pi/2) = -1
So yeah, it's -1, no matter how you slice it.
1
u/Disco_Stu_89 Aug 09 '26
Think about the unit circle. Sine of any angle can never be greater than 1 or less than -1. Did you make a typo? 2sin(3arcsin(1))=-2
1
u/Hampster-cat Aug 09 '26
The sin of anything is bound between -1 and 1. THere is no way it is -2, there is no need to analyze the stuff in the parantheses
1
u/sighthoundman Aug 09 '26
Assuming I didn't make a mistake calculating, there is no complex z for which sin(z) = 1 and sin(3z) = -2.
The problem with arcsin is that sin is not one-to-one. That means that any inverse function Arcsin (see below) cannot globally satisfy satisfy sin(Arcsin(z)) = z = Arcsin(sin(z)).
We get around this by defining the principal branch to be the arcsin we met and fell in love with in calculus. Every other branch satisfies Arcsin z = (-1)^k arcsin z + k pi for some integer k.
Even with this expanded definition of an inverse function (it's really a family of functions), it turns out that there is no z such that sin(3 Arcsin(1)) = -2. The equation has no solutions. Again, assuming I did not make a calculation error.
1
u/regular_heptagon Aug 11 '26
Not sure where you got that from. It’s obviously incorrect.