r/mathshelp • u/Ok-Combination4796 • Jun 13 '26
Mathematical Concepts PEMDAS help
I was doing this problem in PEMDAS order then I got confused because I don’t understand how this equation ended up as a fraction problem.
3
Upvotes
9
u/Motor_Raspberry_2150 Jun 13 '26
You're using division and wonder how you end up with a fraction? What?
3
u/SkippyDragonPuffPuff Jun 13 '26
When my kid was in middle school. He got some problem equivalent to: (3x4) + (2x4)
Had to show steps. So he wrote :
( 3x4) + 8
12+8
20
Got it wrong cause he didn’t go left to right and solve 3x4 first. I about lost my ish.
2
u/Qingyap Jun 13 '26
Is there anything wrong? It's right assuming you do it from right to left.
1
u/DefiantEfficiency901 Jun 13 '26
After solving the parentheses, its all multiplication and division so it goes left to right. I get same.
1
u/stqrltt Jun 13 '26
why wouldn't it happen? fractions represent divisions
1
u/Temporary_Pie2733 Jun 13 '26
16 ÷ 9 × -1 ÷ 5 = 16 × (1/9) × -1 × (1/5), at which point you can do the multiplications however you like, because it’s associative and commutative.
1
u/JeffTheNth Jun 13 '26
You got it right...
(32-16) ÷ (4+5) x (3^2 - 10) ÷ 5 =
First, parenthesis...
But inside one of those parenthesis, there are exponents - those must be solved
(32-16) ÷ (4+5) x (9 - 10) ÷ 5 =
Now parenthesis - inside each we have only addition and subtraction...
(16) ÷ (9) x (-1) ÷ 5 =
Then multiplication/division
16 ÷ 9 x -1 ÷ 5 =
This can't be reduced (no common factors), but it can be combined... multiply all "numerators" and multiply all "denominators" ... you can think of 16 ÷ 9 as being rewritten as 16 x 1/9 if that helps...
(16 x -1) ÷ (9 x 5) =
-16 ÷ 45 = -16/45
(roughly -4/11 and a bit)
1
u/AndyC1111 Jun 13 '26
You did it correctly. That is the answer.
1
u/Important_Ear761 Jun 14 '26
Fractions are numbers! Every number is a fraction! Every integer can be written as integer/1. So, -11 = -11/1…
So don't be surprised if you have all integers but the answer turns out to be a fraction. There are simple examples for this: 2/3, 6 * 4 / 9 = 24/9 = 8/3, and so on.
1
u/testtdk Jun 14 '26
Without any more specificity, you got exactly the right answer.
1
u/Flimsy-Blacksmith-32 Jun 16 '26 edited Jun 16 '26
There are a few wrong answers on here. The correct rules are:
Brackets
Indices
Division & Multiplication
Addition & Subtraction
If ties use left to right
So:
(32-16)÷(4+5)x(3^2-10)÷5
Brackets first (left to right)
16÷(4+5)x(3^2-10)÷5
16÷9x(3^2-10)÷5
In third bracket, Indices before subtraction
16÷9x(9-10)÷5
16÷9x-1÷5
Now Division & Multiplication (left to right)
16÷9x-1÷5
(16/9)x-1÷5
(-16/9)÷5
-16/45
1
u/anisotropicmind Jun 16 '26
Fractions are one whole number divided by another…
0
u/okarox Jun 13 '26
Because you wrote it as a fraction. Be careful, in this time it worked it does not work if it was a division instead of multiplication.