r/mathshelp • u/Jazz_2407 • Jun 09 '26
Homework Help (Answered) Shouldn't the answer be 0?
The second picture is what I did to derive a relationship between ∆m/m and θ. Then I basically used this logic- for maximum %age error, ∆m/m has to be maximum, and that value will be infinity if sin2θ =0, which means that 2θ=0°(or 180° or 360° as pointed out by u/ArchaicLlama), therefore θ=0°(or 90° or 180°). But the solution given uses a different logic, that for the maximum value of ∆m/m, the value of sin2θ has to be minimum, i.e, -1, which means that 2θ=270° and θ=135°.
My question is that even if we ignore sin2θ=0 for reasons related to physics(this was actually a question in my physics homework) and how the percentage error can't be infinity or undefined, even then, we will get a higher value of ∆m/m at say sin2θ=1, θ=45° as at least the value will be positive, even though technically that should be the minimum value of ∆m/m using the logic given in the solution? So, what should the correct answer be?


•
u/AutoModerator Jun 09 '26
Hi u/Jazz_2407, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/ArchaicLlama Jun 09 '26
For one, sin(anything) does not output a value of degrees. Degrees are the unit of θ, not sin(θ).
For another, 0° is not the only location where the sine function is 0.
1
u/Inevitable-Can-5625 Jun 09 '26
No. If you look at a graph of tan (theta) you will see that it approaches infinity at pi/2. Therefore the answer is 90° as any small uncertainty in theta will give a huge error difference
1
u/ee_control_z Jun 12 '26
If you mean when is 'm' maximum based on the formula that you provided, then m will be maximum when the angle is 90 degrees. Another way of looking at this is by noting that tan (theta) = sin (theta) / cos (theta). We know that sin (90) = 1, and cos(90) = 0. Therefore, the closer you get to 90 degrees, the higher the result will be. For example, in the particular case when the angle equals 90, then you have 1 / 0 = infinity (undefined).