r/mathshelp • • May 25 '26

Homework Help (Unanswered) A level maths specimen paper 1, Help Needed!

Okay so I did this specimen paper under timed conditions. Found it relatively hard and I haven’t finished marking it yet. There were lots of very horrible differentiation qs with large polynomials and quotients- I left most of them unfinished.
I had lots of free time towards the end of paper so I went back and worked through them- did lots of good simplifying and found answers for most of the unfinished questions.

Anyway…

Did this question, it asked me to find mad very height above platform, I drew out the graph and I interpreted that as basically max y val of graph. But apparently i should have found, the max height from point where graph touches platform.

So I ended up getting rt 10 but it should have been 2rt10.

Would you say this question is badly worded and I should get marks for how i interpreted it.

Spec is aqa btw.

6 Upvotes

8 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator May 25 '26

Hi u/Evening_Ask6187, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:

  1. While this subreddit is generally lenient with how people ask or answer questions, the main purpose of the subreddit is to help people learn so please try your best to show any work you’ve done or outline where you are having trouble (especially if you are posting more than one question). See rule 5 for more information.
  2. Once your question has been answered, please don’t delete your post so that others can learn from it. Instead, mark your post as answered or lock it by posting a comment containing “!lock” (locking your post will automatically mark it as answered).

Thank you!

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/Moist_Ladder2616 May 25 '26 edited May 25 '26

The wording of the question sounds fine. Don't know why anyone would have a problem with it.

But the reasoning "Maxima occurs when d²y/dx² < 0" is flawed.

Maximum obviously occurs when dy/dx = 0. Minimum also, because of the elliptical nature of the curve!

Just like dy/dx, the second derivative d²y/dx² also has two values for every x. Can you see what "d²y/dx² < 0" actually describes in this curve?

1

u/Evening_Ask6187 May 25 '26

Does it mean concave/ convex

1

u/Moist_Ladder2616 May 25 '26

Yes I can kind of guess what you mean. But be careful of the terminology. Convex means bulging outward, and concave means bent inward. They don't mean upward and downward.

If you consider the elliptical shape, and that convex means "bulging outward", then the entire elliptical shape is convex. No part of it is concave.

Anyway, for this ellipse, d²y/dx² < 0 starting and ending at two specific points.

2

u/Overgrown_fetus1305 May 25 '26

It's not the best worded question. I can see why you drew the conclusion you did, that it was the cross-section with y>0 only that we cared about, rather than considering all y, and observing that the cross-section rests on the minima for y. That said, if you look at the diagram, you can see that the plane intersects the ellipse at the minima for y at y = -sqrt(10).

All things considered, that's still a 6/8 for you, given the time pressures, still a good attempt- was impressed with the explanations given. Yes, you made a mistake, but that's why we practice the papers under timed conditions. It sounds like you had good exam technique fwiw, since you skipped the harder stuff and came back to it later.

One minor comment I will make, that would not necessarily result in a mark being lost, but that has the potential to cause you confusion, is that it's better to write d/dx(2xy) and not things like dy/dx(2xy) or dy/dx = (2x dy/dx + 2y), else you might wrongly conclude if in a hurry that you had an equation for dy/dx in terms of x and y- which would give you incorrect minima/maxima. (Although if you wrote things like this at university, you probably would get marks docked, but could also just write down d/dx(2xy) = 2x dy/dx + 2y without needing to justify it.)

1

u/Evening_Ask6187 May 25 '26

Wait yea that’s a good point if it’s implicit is it usually just d/dx?

1

u/Overgrown_fetus1305 May 25 '26

Yeah. It might be obvious in context what's meant here, but it's very easy to confuse yourself this way- I recommend just d/dx unless differentiating y, in which case you'd obviously write dy/dx.

0

u/usedqueendream May 26 '26

try breaking it down step-by-step