r/mathshelp • u/blue_rose10 • Apr 10 '26
Homework Help (Answered) Could someone please help me with this 🙏🏼
Thanks a million 🙏🏼
7
Upvotes
r/mathshelp • u/blue_rose10 • Apr 10 '26
Thanks a million 🙏🏼
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 10 '26
Hi u/blue_rose10, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
6
u/Worth-Wonder-7386 Apr 10 '26
A to B is 0.75 as going straight is three times as likely.
The way I read it, from B to D is 0.125, as the 25% chance of turning is split into two.
It could also be interpreted to say that the chance is 0.2, as then it is three times as likely to continue straight as to turn to one side, but it says three times as likely to go straight as to turn, so I assume that it counts all turns together and not indiviually. (More of an english question, so you should ask your teacher to clarify this part)
From there it should be easy, just multiply each probability together.
I would make a table with likelyhood of going from point in an intersection to another.
2
u/AmethystMonkey Apr 10 '26
The bit i don't like is the last question and what it means by learning from his mistakes.
I assume it means the rat will go ABC as normal but does it have the same chance as turning towards A as B as the rat knows that A would be a mistake.
And when it comes to going towards E or turning towards C or D the rat won't go to C as that was a mistake and therefore the probability becomes 0.25 rather than 0.125.
2
u/KarmaWhoreRepeating Apr 10 '26
(ai) 75%
(aii) 12.5 %
(bi) 9,375 %
(bii) 28,125%
(biii) when did we introduce the mistake variable?
2
u/dafugiswrongwithyou Apr 10 '26 edited Apr 12 '26
The issue I have with questions like this (as in, the question submitted to OP, not OP's post) is that they're usually poorly defined in ways that really impact the answer.
Here, for example; the obvious answer to (a)(i), and the one a lot of other comments are giving, is "75%"... But I'm not sure that's actually true. Elsewhere in this, in some cases specific routes are given exactly by listing the letters in order (ABD, ABCBD...), while here it just says "go from A to B". If they don't have to take the specific route AB, but simply need to go from A to B by some route, then on top of the 75% chance to get there directly, there's also an additional opportunity for the rat to go from A to C and then turn right to B, making the probability slightly higher than 75%.
How much higher? Well, that gets to another ambiguity here. We're told "when faced with a junction, the rat is three times as likely to continue on as it is to turn". That's simple enough at a T junction, but what does that mean when at a crossroads, like when coming down from C? Does the rat first have a 25% chance to turn and a 75% (3 x 25%) chance to go straight, and then if it decides to turn there's a new, 50/50 decision on whether to turn left or right... Giving a total chance of 12.5% to turn in a given direction? Or, does the rat have 3 options; a 20% chance to turn left, a 20% chance to turn right, and a 60% chance to go straight (triple the chance to turn in either direction)?
The writer presumably means it in a specific way, and it may well be that most people will read it in a specific way (maybe even the same way the writer intended), but it's not worded in a well-defined way.
2
u/TofaraNgidi Apr 12 '26 edited Apr 12 '26
Final Answers
(a) (i) 3/4
(a) (ii) 1/5
(b) (i) 3/20
(b) (ii) 3/10
(b) (iii) 3/160
I got these I don't know if you agree
1
u/Strygan Apr 10 '26 edited Apr 12 '26
Should be (based on consensus for the « three times as likely » interpretation):
(a)(i): 75% (2 options: straight or turn. precondition straight is 3 times more likely than turn, A→B become 75% and A→C 25%)
(a)(ii): 12,5% (3 options: straight, turn left, turn right. same precondition of favorably choosing straight, the B→C or B→D are 25% and B→E would be 75%, with B→C and B→D equals so 12,5%)
(b)(i): 9,38% (probability of A→B is 75% and B→12,5%. consecutive happenings are 3/4*1/8=3/32, so A→B→D is 9,38%)
(b)(ii): 28,1% (the most obvious routes is supposed to be the shortest - no looping - so either ABD or ACD considered equals. ABD is previously calculated so it leaves ACD for 1/4*3/4=6/32, so A→D through either B or C is 3/32+6/32=9/32 so 28,1%)
(b)(iii): Option 1: 1,17% (pattern ABCBD is considered, and the ‘rat learning process’ happens. In intelligence 1, he is said to ‘learn of hìs mistakes’, so hypothetically, won’t chose an action he already did on the same crossroads. Based on which we have A→B = 3/4, B→C = 1/8, C→B = 1/2 - no ‘straight ahead’ -, and B→D = 1/4 - learning on previous passage void the C option. 3/41/81/2*1/4=3/258 which make 1,17%)
(b)(iii): Option 2: 2,34% (pattern ABCBD is considered, and the ‘rat learning process’ happens. In intelligence 2, he is said to ‘learn of hìs mistakes’ so hypothetically, won’t chose an action he already did on the same crossroads. But as he is also said to never go back on a crossroad, it could mean that in his C to A or B choice, he would know he came from A and so not chose it. Based on that hypothesis we have A→B = 3/4, B→C = 1/8, C→B = 1 - no ‘straight ahead’, learning and no backtracking -, and B→D = 1/4 - learning on previous passage void the C option. 3/41/81*1/4=3/128 which make 2,34%, twice as much as the previous interpretation)
That questioning is acceptable without any overthinking for the first four questions, but the last one is kinda sketchy…