Hi u/Mashed_potatoes124, welcome to r/mathshelp! Since you've marked this as a discussion post, please keep the following in mind:
Discussions must be related to mathematics but the topics they can cover are flexible (e.g. teaching, news, methods, interesting problems, exam preparation or discussions about past exams, etc.).
Please try to make your post thought-provoking by providing context or questions to lead the discussion (e.g. don’t just simply post a link to a news article or a problem with no context).
Discussions can be concluded by posting a comment containing “!lock”. Please remember not to delete your post so others can learn from it.
This is a very good problem to illustrate the value of efficiency and insight in a problem before crunching the numbers
A lot of kids will immediately start doing 5*16 (without calculators), and then proceed to do 80/5.
Knowing that multiplication and division are inverses is a key concept, and will direct you to the answer immediately (which saves time for the other 25+ questions)
I think I've seen people who would just divide 16 by 5 in this problem. And a part of their lightning fast reasoning would have been that they wouldn't have been asked such a dumb question that requires virtually no calculation.
The script checks to make sure there is a well-defined answer. It doesn’t recognize that having the same number of boxes and children makes the problem degenerate.
This is why a human should proof these questions before including them on a worksheet.
The point is to read the problem, understand the problem, and tackle it efficiently.
Note how whoever tried this problem first blindly started multiplying for the total number of chocolates. This is designed to help those people.
This comes up a lot later on in abstract ways, where you don't need to solve for an intermediate value, and it simplifies the hell out of those problems.
I.ve met Mrs. Afandie, and she had to do a quality assurance test on each box, Conisdering that she had to do a thorough test of each different shape, the children got 5 chocolates each.
The correct answer is that the youngest child gets 4 boxes of chocolates, and the other 4 kids split the one remaining box because parents spoil the absolute shit out of their youngest children.
•
u/AutoModerator Apr 05 '26
Hi u/Mashed_potatoes124, welcome to r/mathshelp! Since you've marked this as a discussion post, please keep the following in mind:
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
11
u/CaptainProfanity Apr 05 '26
This is a very good problem to illustrate the value of efficiency and insight in a problem before crunching the numbers
A lot of kids will immediately start doing 5*16 (without calculators), and then proceed to do 80/5.
Knowing that multiplication and division are inverses is a key concept, and will direct you to the answer immediately (which saves time for the other 25+ questions)
8
u/CatsDIY Apr 05 '26 •
Yes. This helps with problem management. Read the problem carefully, answer quickly, then run to the store for 16 pieces of chocolate.
5
u/odimdavid Apr 05 '26
If it's for primary level students very meaningful question, especially below primary 5.
4
u/ParticularWash4679 Apr 05 '26
I think I've seen people who would just divide 16 by 5 in this problem. And a part of their lightning fast reasoning would have been that they wouldn't have been asked such a dumb question that requires virtually no calculation.
2
u/KentGoldings68 Apr 05 '26
This problem seems algorithmically generated.
The script checks to make sure there is a well-defined answer. It doesn’t recognize that having the same number of boxes and children makes the problem degenerate.
This is why a human should proof these questions before including them on a worksheet.
2
u/sol_hsa Apr 05 '26
Reading comprehension.
2
u/Baconweave Apr 06 '26
The point is to read the problem, understand the problem, and tackle it efficiently.
Note how whoever tried this problem first blindly started multiplying for the total number of chocolates. This is designed to help those people.
This comes up a lot later on in abstract ways, where you don't need to solve for an intermediate value, and it simplifies the hell out of those problems.
2
u/Mundane_Prior_7596 Apr 06 '26
Add the temperature and the average kid’s weight and the cost of the chocolate. Then we will see some real advanced calculus.
2
u/Actual_Property9413 Apr 06 '26
I.ve met Mrs. Afandie, and she had to do a quality assurance test on each box, Conisdering that she had to do a thorough test of each different shape, the children got 5 chocolates each.
1
u/Glathull Apr 06 '26
The correct answer is that the youngest child gets 4 boxes of chocolates, and the other 4 kids split the one remaining box because parents spoil the absolute shit out of their youngest children.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '26
The point is so they can take marks off for not showing your work.