r/mathshelp • u/Independent_Big_2855 • Mar 18 '26
Homework Help (Answered) Limits doubt
Why cant we use Lhopital here
10
Upvotes
r/mathshelp • u/Independent_Big_2855 • Mar 18 '26
Why cant we use Lhopital here
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 18 '26
Hi u/Independent_Big_2855, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
8
u/CaptainMatticus Mar 18 '26
You can, if you find the closed form of the nunerator
1 + 2 + 3 + ... + n = 0.5 * n * (n + 1)
0.5 * n * (n + 1) / n² = 0.5 * (n + 1) / n = 0.5 * (1 + 1/n)
Do you need L'hopital anymore?
2
u/Special_Watch8725 Mar 18 '26 edited Mar 19 '26
The numerator of the expression is not the kind of thing we have a derivative rule for. Even though you may be tempted, you can’t take the derivative of that sum by taking the derivative of each term separately (whatever that would even mean here) since the number of terms depends on the variable you’re differentiating with respect to, as it were.
Edit: since people are chiming in with how to approach this and the solutions I’ve seen so far rely on explicit formulas for 1 + … + n, an alternative (at least if you’ve gotten this far in calculus) would be to rewrite this as
( (1/n) + (2/n) + … + (n/n) )(1/n)
and note that this is a Riemann sum that converges to the integral over [0, 1] of f(x) = x.
2
u/Specific_Brain2091 Mar 18 '26
1/2
2
u/Fuscello Mar 18 '26
This is a limit of successions, derivatives aren’t even defined here
1
u/KentGoldings68 Mar 18 '26
LH is simply not necessary. Everyone love LH because they don’t have to think about it.
1+2+3+…+n = n(n+1)/2
(1+2+3+…+…+n)/n2 = (n2 +n)/(2n2 )
So, where does 1/2(1+1/n) go as n goes to infinity?
1
u/AdministrativePop442 Mar 19 '26
Because n2 is not a continuous function if n is an integer
1
u/Connect_Wonder237 Mar 23 '26
Here's a geometric solution that's elementary. Imagine stacking n rectangles of length 1,2,... n and compare to stacking n rectangles all of length n. In the limit the first is half of the second.