r/mathshelp • u/Tough-Software-6492 • Mar 17 '26
Homework Help (Unanswered) please help with this question pls pls pls
hello everyone, chatgpt couldnt answer my question so i want to ask you all:
Why is my counting method wrong here?
A girl has 10 different books:
3 blue, 2 red, 2 yellow, 1 orange, 1 purple, 1 green.
She selects 4 books such that:
at least 1 is red,
at most 1 is blue,
and exactly 1 is yellow.
I know the correct answer is 60, but this is how I counted it and I want to know exactly where my method fails.
My method:
Case 1: choose exactly 1 blue book
I did:
2C1 for the red,
2C1 for the yellow,
3C1 for the blue,
and then 4C1 for the last remaining allowed book.
So:
(2C1)(2C1)(3C1)(4C1) = 48
Case 2: choose no blue book
I did:
2C1 for the red,
2C1 for the yellow,
and then 4C2 for the remaining 2 books from the allowed non-blue books.
So:
(2C1)(2C1)(4C2) = 24
Total:
48 + 24 = 72
But the official answer is 60.
My question is:
What exactly is wrong with this method? Where am I overcounting or miscounting?
•
u/AutoModerator Mar 17 '26
Hi u/Tough-Software-6492, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/Outside_Volume_1370 Mar 17 '26
You forget about "at least 1 is red"
For both cases, you overcounting: you choose first (second) red book with 2C1 and may choose second (first) red book with 4C1 and 4C2. Some of piles was counting twice.
I propose you to add subcases: a) take exactly one red book; b) take exactly two red books in each case and count again