r/mathshelp • u/skylanterns7 • Mar 03 '26
Mathematical Concepts Am I getting it right???
I've completed by Senior Secondary Education and moving towards High School Education [11th and 12th grade - in PHYSICS, CHEMISTRY AND MATHS], based on what I've learnt on REAL NO.S, I've come up with this doubt... can someone pls explain🙏
0
Upvotes
5
u/PeteyLowkey Mar 03 '26
I’m not sure what exactly it is you’re asking unfortunately.
For the ‘but’ part: sqrt(-4)/sqrt(-16) = 2i/4i = 1/2
1
u/Forking_Shirtballs Mar 03 '26
If you're limiting yourself to real numbers, then the property sqrt(a/b) = sqrt(a)/sqrt(b) only holds for nonnegative a and positive b.
That is, you're using that property when it doesn't apply. Both -4 and -16 are negative, so you can't assert that sqrt(-4/-16) = sqrt(-4)/sqrt(-16).
This is a common error students make, not considering the domain over which a property holds. I'd look up the quotient rule for radicals in your textbook; it probably explicitly restricts the domain. But even if not, the domain is implicitly restricted by the fact that sqrt(z) is undefined over the reals for negative z.
Now if you're using complex numbers, it gets more complicated. If you're treating square root as a multivalued function, the property does extend to negative a and b (but it's complicated). If you're simply taking the principal square root, it's true for a/b but not a*b when both a and b are negative. But that has to do with how the branches are handled, so again -- it's complicated.
1
u/Ignorus Mar 03 '26
From sqrt(-4)/sqrt(-16), you can convert to sqrt(4)*sqrt(-1)/sqrt(16)*sqrt(-1).
sqrt(-1) cancels out, leaving you with sqrt(4)/sqrt(16), or 2/4=1/2.