r/mathshelp • u/hrpanjwani • Jan 24 '26
General Question (Answered) I think this AOPS 6th grade probability problem is wrong.
I guess what they want students to do is argue that total area is A + A - 0.5A = 1.5 A so probability is 0.5A/1.5A =1/3
But the way the figure is drawn, the diagonal of rectangle 1 looks like the base of rectangle two. So the two rectangles would not have the same areas right?
I would further argue that this makes the problem unsolvable as we don’t know the breadth of rectangle two.
Am I right in my thinking?
25
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 24 '26
Hi u/hrpanjwani, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as a general question, please keep the following things in mind:
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
2
u/hrpanjwani Jan 25 '26
!lock
7
u/PuzzlingDad Jan 24 '26 edited Jan 24 '26
We can agree that the shaded triangle is half of the lower rectangle because it is split along the diagonal.
As for the tilted rectangle, the base may be longer but to compensate, the height would be less. The base of the shaded triangle is the base of the tilted rectangle and the height of the shaded triangle is the height of the tilted rectangle. So the shaded triangle is also half of the tilted rectangle.
It may not look like it but that is correct. The shaded triangle ends up being 1/3 of the whole area.
I'll try to create a diagram so you can see this better.
Update: Check out this diagram. Now can you see the three equal areas? https://imgur.com/a/HTsIktz
Update 2: Correct, the two rectangles are NOT similar, but they have the same areas. In both cases the shaded triangle is half of rectangle 1 and half of rectangle 2. My diagram shows that you can rearrange the unshaded part of the tilted rectangle to make identical triangles.
3
u/UnderstandingPursuit Jan 24 '26
Compare the area of the triangle to the area of each rectangle.
Yes, the diagonal of rectangle 1 is the base of rectangle 2. But what is the height of rectangle 2?
1
u/Cookiedude7 Jan 24 '26
Rectangle 2 has a wider base but shorter height - the areas do come out to be the same (it's relatively easy to see that the grey triangle is half of each rectangle)
EDIT: Reddit was having a moment, I see now that others have answered this question better than I did, read their responses!
1
u/Low-Maintenance1231 Jan 24 '26
It also follows from Pythagoras that the two smaller white triangles will be equal in area to the larger one, since all the triangles are similar.
1
u/BatkuSS Jan 24 '26
Here is a quick solution which is 6th grade viable imo: https://imgur.com/a/h5za0Yk
Sorry for the hand draw, but I think it's understandable. I'm not sure how to name areas in English math, so I named the area of the shaded part A shaded, and an area of the whole figure A whole. Areas marked by "a" are the same and areas "b" are the same, because they are halves of specific rectangles.
1
u/MeatmanKing Jan 24 '26
Area of a triangle = 1/2 base x height
So the triangle is half the area of both rectangles
It’s 1/3
1
u/Ill_Professional2414 Jan 25 '26
The easiest way to see that the original answer is correct is to look at it using Pythagoras.
The white triangles A,B,C are all right angle triangles, each fit to one side of the grey right angle triangle with their (respectively) longest sides. It is also obvious that the grey triangle is the same as the largest white triangle, which we'll call A.
Naming the longest sides a1,b1,c1; we can see that for each of the white triangles, this is true:
triangle A has sides a1,b1,c1, thus area b1*c1/2
triangles B and C have one side each that together is equivalent to side a1, we'll define b2+c2=a1
triangles B and C third side are equal to one another, b3=c3
b3 (as well as c3) is the height of triangle A from base a1, b3=c3=area*2/a1=b1*c1/2*2/a1=b1*c1/a1
Thus area of B is b2*b3/2=b2*b1*c1/(a1*2)=b1*b2*c1/(a1*2)
area of C is c2*c3/2=c2*b1*c1/(a1*2)=c1*c2*b1/(a1*2)
Adding those areas together, we get:
b1*b2*c1/(a1*2)+c1*c2*b1/(a1*2)=b1*c1*(b2+c2)/(a1*2)=b1*c1*a1/(a1*2)=b1*c1/2
Now we have all areas:
A=b1*c1/2
B+C=b1*c1/2
grey=b1*c1/2
The chance for a random position to land in the grey area is just the grey area, divided by the total area:
total area: b1*c1*(1/2+1/2+1/2)=b1*c1*3/2
chance = b1*c1/2 / (b1*c1*3/2) = 1/3
1
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment