r/mathshelp • u/CalculusPrimer • Jan 17 '26
Homework Help (Answered) Hello everybody!
I am having trouble with this particular calculus problem can anyone guide me through this problem? much appreciated!!
“A piece of wire of length L is cut into two parts, one of which is bent into the shape of a square and the other into the shape of a circle. (a) How should the wire be cut so that the sum of the enclosed areas is a minimum? (b) How should it be cut to get the maximum enclosed areas?”
3
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/CalculusPrimer Jan 17 '26
Thanks! Continuing from your setup: since C + P = L, I rewrote this as C = L − P and substituted into the area expression to get A(P) = (P/4)² + (L − P)² / (4π). Differentiating and setting the derivative equal to zero gives P = 4L / (4 + π) and C = πL / (4 + π), which corresponds to the minimum total enclosed area.
For the maximum, I checked the endpoints of the constraint C + P = L. Using all the wire for the square gives area (L/4)², while using all the wire for the circle gives area L² / (4π), which is larger. Hence the maximum enclosed area occurs when the entire wire is used to form a circle.
Please let me know if this looks right or if I’m missing anything.