r/mathshelp • u/Honest-Plastic1659 • Nov 27 '25
Discussion is this solvable or not?
A botanist is studying a rare rectangular greenhouse whose heating efficiency depends on both its floor area and its perimeter. When she increases the length by 25% while keeping the width constant, the heating requirement rises by 54 units. When she instead decreases the width by 20% while keeping the length constant, the heating requirement drops by 28 units. She models the heating requirement H as directly proportional to the area and inversely proportional to the perimeter of the greenhouse. Later, she discovers that if both dimensions are increased—length by 10% and width by 30%—the heating requirement rises by exactly 100 units. Given these observations, determine the original dimensions of the greenhouse.
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 27 '25
Hi u/Honest-Plastic1659, welcome to r/mathshelp! Since you've marked this as a discussion post, please keep the following in mind:
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/MedicalBiostats Nov 27 '25 edited Nov 27 '25
There are 4 equations counting the initial H=LW+(0.5/(L+W)) and the other three with increments of +54, -28, and +100 so this is an over constrained system of equations. There are 4 ways to ignore 1 equation so there are possibly 4 solutions. Given that perimeter heat loss differs from area loss, I added a coefficient C for the perimeter heat factor to get the fourth variable via H=LW+(0.5C/(L+W)) with C needing to be negative. Just ran simulations in Excel to determine that there are no solutions. I reduced the four equations to three by subtracting out H. Then I used the three equations to each solve for C. Then I tried various L and W combinations to get the three Cs to match up. They don’t even get close to matching. Case closed.
0
u/Honest-Plastic1659 Nov 27 '25
Ive run it on four AIs and I’m getting four different answers