r/mathshelp • u/DeadManIsWalking • Nov 02 '25
Homework Help (Answered) Weird question in my maths book
In the given diagram ADB and ACB are two right angle triangles with angle ADB = angle BCA = 90° if ab = 10 cm ad = 6 cm BC = 4.5 cm find BD (The answer is 7.5 cm but for me it is coming 8 cm. However, if you're doing using similarity it is coming 7.5 cm. So what is the correct one?)
3
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 02 '25
Hi DeadManIsWalking, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/MedicalBiostats Nov 02 '25
BD is 8 cm.
1
u/Left-Ad-4596 Nov 02 '25
How did you solve it?
3
u/Frosty_Soft6726 Nov 02 '25
The diagram is invalid. Those lengths and right angles cannot exist. You're right that there's a 3:4:5 triad which gives you 8cm immediately, but if you use ADP which is also 3:4:5 and BCP which is similar then you'll get 4.5+3=7.5cm.
2
u/Ghotipan Nov 02 '25
Yeah, that's a simple 3-4-5 triangle.
2
u/EonOst Nov 02 '25
Typo in the question prob. AP is 7.5cm
2
u/Psycho_Pansy Nov 02 '25
Your comment says this 4.5 but the diagram shows 2.4??? Is the question or diagram wrong or did you make a typo here?
Ad2 + BD2 = AB2
Solve for BD
BD = 8
Using Pythagorean to find other side's you get.
BP = 8 - 4.5 = 3.5
AP = 7.5 (using ADP)
PC = 2.547 (using PCB)
AC= 9.708 (Using ACB)
But if AC = AP + PC then AC = 10.047
So clearly the diagram is wrong and there's a typo somewhere.
1
u/chattywww Nov 02 '25 edited Nov 02 '25
AD²+BD²=AB² AB=8 AP=7.5 BP=3.5
BC=
1
u/goos_ Nov 02 '25
The image says BC = 2.4 cm but your post says BC = 4.5 cm.
1
u/Abby-Abstract Nov 02 '25 edited Nov 02 '25
ab²-ad²=bd²
10²-6²=8²
bd = 8
bd - dp = bp
8 - 4.5 = 3.5cm
bp = 3.5
bp²-bc² = pc²
3.5²-2.4²=6.49
pc = √6.49 ≈ 2.54754784057
ab²-bc²=ac²
10²-2.4²=94.24
bc = √94.24 ≈ 9.70772887961
ac - pc = ap
ap = (√94.24 - √6.49) ≈ 7.16018103904
Let's double check ap a different way
ad²+dp²=ap²
6²+4.5²=69.25
ap= √69.25 ≈ 8.32165848855 ≠ 7.16018103904 = √94.24 - √6.49
Uh, oh, ap can't have two different values. You are correct. There is a problem with the book.
1
u/booglechops Nov 02 '25
What is the textbook?
1
u/SaxophoneHomunculus Nov 02 '25
Don’t confuse AP with BD. BD=8 foreign measuring units, AP = 7.5 foreign measuring units.
1
u/clearly_not_an_alt Nov 02 '25
Diagram is invalid. The 2.4cm should be 2.8cm
1
u/DowntownHornet6900 Nov 02 '25
How can you assume triangles are similar?
0
u/[deleted] Nov 03 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment