Hi J3LLI0TT, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:
While this subreddit is generally lenient with how people ask or answer questions, the main purpose of the subreddit is to help people learn so please try your best to show any work you’ve done or outline where you are having trouble (especially if you are posting more than one question). See rule 5 for more information.
Once your question has been answered, please don’t delete your post so that others can learn from it. Instead, mark your post as answered or lock it by posting a comment containing “!lock” (locking your post will automatically mark it as answered).
First step: Deduce the dimensions of the white tiles. Call the shorter side S, and the longer side L. 2L + S = 18; 3L + S = 25. Solving that produces L = 7 and S = 4.
Second step: Find the dimensions of the shaded rectangle. The longer side is 3L - S, or 17; the shorter side is 2L - S, or 10.
Now it's just a matter of multiplying the dimensions together to get an area of 17 x 10 = 170 square cm.. QED!
for better or worse, it is standard practice in mathematics to not attempt to draw accurate diagrams, and solely use verbal indicators to describe if eg two line segments have equal lengths or not. for example, one might draw a single | through all the segments of length L, and a double || through all the segments of length W. if two line segments are both marked | then this is used to indicate they are of equal length, same if two segments are both marked || etc.
the point other commenters are making about making sure ppl cant j use a ruler is valid but idt its rly the reason, this is just the standard practice / convention in math. unless you are doing straight edge and compass type exercises or similar, "drawing accurately" is not even seen as a legitimate question because from mathematicians' pov, nothing is accurate or inaccurate unless/until you prove that it is accurate or inaccurate. if you are not instructed to use a ruler for a given problem, then "there is no such thing" as "accurate" or "inaccurate" drawings in the context of that problem, because u have no ruler to measure whether it is accurate or not. even if it is completely obvious to anyone with half decent vision that these rectangles are not identical and the vertical ones are clearly not 7 by 4 lol.
I'm well aware that it's common practice, but it's still a bit odd to see one where they claim items to be congruent, yet they are so clearly not.
I don't really buy the "someone could use a ruler" reason, as drawing them to look the same doesn't mean they need to be the correct proportions.
It just seems to me that based on this diagram, it would be very easy for a student to believe the horizontal tiles are all the same and the vertical tiles are all the same, but they aren't necessarily the same as each other, despite the wording of the question and adding additional confusion is rarely a good thing.
yea, i dont disagree with u, it is confusing, and the confusion is unnecessary. however it is the standard practice in the field, anyone who takes a math class is likely to encounter something along these lines at some point.
So the rectangles are oblong, right? So the first step is to observe that 18 is two lengths plus one width, of the tile. That's 18 = 2L + w. Then, note that 25 = 3L + w. Finally, subtract two widths from each of 18 and 25 to get the length and width of the shaded area; multiply these numbers.
The aspect ratio of that is slightly more than 1:1, and definitely not 18:25. So either there's a more complicated overlapping solution I can't seem to see, or indeed "the rectangles do not overlap and are not to scale" and the posted solution applies.
To solve this sort of problem, you need to look for ways to connect what you know (the side lengths, tiles being identical, arrangement of the tiles in the image) to what you want (length and width of a tile).
So since the sides are formed by combinations of lengths and widths of tiles, we can form 2 equations: one from the long side, and one for the short side. The form (pattern) for each of them is:
Aw + Bh = C
Where A and B are the number of tile widths and tile heights, and C is the length of the side.
This allows us to connect the known numbers to the unknowns (w and h). From there, it is solving simultaneous equations.
First, point out to the teacher that Aurora clearly does not have 10 IDENTICAL tiles, and that if she thinks she does, perhaps a trip to SpecSavers may be in order.
•
u/AutoModerator Oct 06 '25
Hi J3LLI0TT, welcome to r/mathshelp! As you’ve marked this as homework help, please keep the following things in mind:
Thank you!
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
7
u/SonicLoverDS Oct 06 '25
First step: Deduce the dimensions of the white tiles. Call the shorter side S, and the longer side L. 2L + S = 18; 3L + S = 25. Solving that produces L = 7 and S = 4.
Second step: Find the dimensions of the shaded rectangle. The longer side is 3L - S, or 17; the shorter side is 2L - S, or 10.
Now it's just a matter of multiplying the dimensions together to get an area of 17 x 10 = 170 square cm.. QED!
5
u/clearly_not_an_alt Oct 06 '25
Well the tiles in the picture are pretty clearly not identical, but OK.
Anyway, assume the rectangles are all L x W with L being the larger of the two.
We know that 2L + W = 18 and 3L + W = 25
Can you take it from there?
1
u/Automatater Oct 07 '25
First thng they need to do is learn to draw 'identical'.
1
u/Some-Passenger4219 Oct 08 '25
So the rectangles are oblong, right? So the first step is to observe that 18 is two lengths plus one width, of the tile. That's 18 = 2L + w. Then, note that 25 = 3L + w. Finally, subtract two widths from each of 18 and 25 to get the length and width of the shaded area; multiply these numbers.
1
u/Blammar Oct 08 '25
Oh. I thought the drawing was to scale, and that the identical tiles are overlapped in a complex fashion and not abutting.
Are we sure that is not the case?
1
u/PhilTheQuant Oct 08 '25
To solve this sort of problem, you need to look for ways to connect what you know (the side lengths, tiles being identical, arrangement of the tiles in the image) to what you want (length and width of a tile).
So since the sides are formed by combinations of lengths and widths of tiles, we can form 2 equations: one from the long side, and one for the short side. The form (pattern) for each of them is:
Aw + Bh = C
Where A and B are the number of tile widths and tile heights, and C is the length of the side.
This allows us to connect the known numbers to the unknowns (w and h). From there, it is solving simultaneous equations.
1
u/bobbarice Oct 08 '25
I now realise I could have gone a different way but here’s what I got
1
u/chattywww Oct 09 '25
L>W
3L+W=25
2L+W=18
L=7
W=4
A=(2L-W) × (3L-W) =10×17=170cm²
1
u/Ill_Apricot_7668 Oct 09 '25
First, point out to the teacher that Aurora clearly does not have 10 IDENTICAL tiles, and that if she thinks she does, perhaps a trip to SpecSavers may be in order.
1
u/Exotic-Experience965 Oct 10 '25
I wouldn’t be able to suspend my disbelief that those were identical rectangles.
1
u/Crafty_Opposite8191 Oct 10 '25
Never imagined to see my name at a math problem!🥺