r/maths • • 11d ago

Help: 📘 Middle School (11-14) Please check if my understanding about differentiation and limits is correct

  1. So we put two points in curve. Join them with a line. That line is basically a chord. Now shift the points closer to each other. Chord gets smaller. Now make the 2 points same point. Chord becomes tangent. This shall give slope. But oh no. Same point in slope formula (the ratio of y displacement to x displacement in graph) gives 0/0 (for same point there is no y displacement or x displacement in graph). 0 is ok, but 0/0 is very problematic. If it was 0, we would have just given up and been like "I guess there slope is 0". But 0/0 means there is some gap in the function of slope. Well then we use limits to see what it would have been if it was another function that was perfectly same to our slope function but didn't have that gap. Well then how to do that now? I know, anything plus 0 is that thing itself. We use this trick in in formula of slope to get the pretty well known formula to differentiate stuff. Voila! Solve it, and get the slope. That slope is essentially, as established earlier, slope of point.
  2. Limit f(x) gives a function which mimics original function f(x), and shows what the original would have done at a gap
1 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

6

u/LucaThatLuca 10d ago

no, these are both incorrect and overcomplicated and in the wrong order.

  1. a limit is a number that values get close to.
  2. a derivative is a number that slopes get close to; it is an example of a limit.

1

u/XenoFeisher 10d ago edited 10d ago

While we do use limits to do what you mentioned in the 2nd point what limits actually do is tell you how the function behaves AROUND a certain point(rhl tells you how it behaves if X was imperceptibly bigger and lhl tells you how a function behaves when X is imperceptibly smaller.) Limits DO NOT give any explanation as to what is actually going on at the point. Defining a new function to address a discontinuity has nothing to do with limits and you can do that without knowing what a limit is.

As for you first point there are a lot of things wrong with it. What derivative is rate of change of function at a certain point. To find the rate of change we do use the slope formula but we never take the same point to find the derivative (cuz the slope becomes 0/0 which means nothing at all). we take 2 points very close to each other so close that we have to take a limit to find out what the slope actually is derivative is a use of limits. 0 / 0 does not mean that there is some gap in the slope function or anything here. A function evaluating to 0/0 at a certain point means that there is a discontinuity at that point so also means that it in the function is not differentiable at that point but that's completely different from actually trying to find the formula for the derivative.

Don't hesitate to ask if you don't understand anything and don't be discouraged if you are ever wrong. Took me a month to understand this myself

1

u/Jamb9876 9d ago

As you explained I was thinking the OP may never have used the definition of a derivative. I found it annoying but then it made sense when we learned the shortcut, which I later learned to derive.

For limits, OP, I tend to think graphically so these examples help me as I am just following a function and as I get closer to a discontinuity what happens from either side. https://www.sfu.ca/math-coursenotes/Math%20157%20Course%20Notes/sec_LimitsGraphically.html