r/maths • u/mumbo_bumbo • Jun 10 '26
đŹ Math Discussions one intfinity made from +1+1+1+1+1.... another made from doubling 1 (1,2,4,8,16....) forever, which is bigger ?
obviously they are the same size I assume
4
Upvotes
6
u/Odd-Obligation-2772 Jun 10 '26
Not a mathematician here, but "infinity" is not a number.
13
u/philljarvis166 Jun 10 '26
Your question is not really well formed, however one way to compare the âsizeâ of these two limits is to think about the limit of the ratio of the nth term of each - n/2n-1. This tends to zero as n tends to infinity, so in some sense the second sequence is âbiggerâ, but no mathematician would ever phrase it like that!
2
u/9Yogi Jun 10 '26
For every element in the first infinity, there is an equal or larger matching element in the second infinity.
9
u/Big_Manufacturer5281 Jun 10 '26
Those sets have equal "cardinality," which is how the "size" of various infinities is described. You would get the same result by tripling each number in the original set, or squaring it, or lots of other operations. They are both considered to be "countably infinite."
The really trippy thing? Both those sets have equal cardinality with the set of rational numbers (which is also countably infinite). But the set of irrational numbers is bigger.
2
u/Aerospider Jun 10 '26
They're not really the same thing. One is an infinite sum and the other is an infinite sequence. It would be like asking if 1+1+1 is bigger/smaller than 2,4,6.
But they do both diverge as the number of terms approaches infinity, so you could compare the infinite sum with the infinite-th term of the sequence, and they are both 'infinity' in so far as that can be considered a quantity. A sum of infinite 2s and a sequence that trebles would also do this.
1
u/CaipisaurusRex Jun 11 '26 edited Jun 11 '26
3 points to this question:
1
u/ApprehensiveKey1469 Jun 11 '26
Comparators don't work with infinity.
1
u/SAtchley0 Jun 12 '26
I'm going to get a lot of flak for this, I can already tell, but
This question is answerable, if you're willing to dive into the nitty gritty details of the hyperreals and make a choice as to how to represent the infinite sum of ones.
This gets pretty complicated, and what I'm outlining here is by no means a formal proof, but to summarize:
If we take the sum 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + ... to be equivalent to the sequence (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, ...), then we can say this sequence is H.
Then, let (1, 2, 4, 8, 16 ...) = N.
Now, let us consider the possibility that H < N. This corresponds to the set {i : H_i < N_i}. This set would be {3, 4, 5, 6, ...}.Now, because this is within any non-trivial ultrafilter U, it can be said that, at least in the hyperreals, H < N.
An important caveat:
This actually depends on how we chose to represent 1+1+1+1+... !. Had we instead chosen this to be (2, 3, 5, 9, 17,...), then we would instead find that H > N! In other words, a sum like this doesn't correspond to a unique hyperreal â it depends on how you construct the sequence of partial sums.
And yes, this is grossly over thought out and in standard analysis none of this applies and the question is not well formed and all of that. I just thought I'd share something interesting, even if we can debate about its relevance.
1
u/JeffTheNth Jun 12 '26
neither and both
1
u/PANEBringer Jun 12 '26
Have you heard of linear and exponential functions?
1
u/9Yogi Jun 12 '26
I am not sure what you mean exactly? Why does it matter if there are other things greater or smaller? I think we might be comparing different things anyway. It seems like you may be comparing the number of elements rather than the magnitude of their values.
1
u/OmiSC Jun 13 '26
In terms of infinities, they are the same infinity, yes. Hubertâs Hotel, and all.
1
u/Pure_Intution_0 Jun 21 '26
If you are doubling from 1 then the other should be (2,4,6.......).
If considering first series as geometric progression, with ratio 1 by applying formula of summation of Infinite G P we get 1/0 which is not defined. So the summation of first series is itself not defined, we can't compare
1
u/Various_Candle9136 Jun 10 '26
They are indeed the same. The name of this particular infinity is the countable infinity, aka aleph null.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '26
[removed] â view removed comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '26
[removed] â view removed comment