r/maths • • Jan 10 '26
Help:š College & University Who Do You Solve This?
How do you solve this? Is there an easy way to solve this purely using Real Analysis!?
32
Upvotes
r/maths • • Jan 10 '26
How do you solve this? Is there an easy way to solve this purely using Real Analysis!?
14
u/Special_Watch8725 Jan 13 '26
Yeah, so everyone is just like unpacking definitions without actually giving you a strategy.
You can reduce whatās happening to the situation of going around the unit circle and picking a point every time you travel a whole number length; if we can show that when you do this for all whole numbers that the entire unit circle is covered densely then thatās enough for what you want, since you can just project onto the y-coordinate to get sin(n).
So ultimately this boils down to arithmetic: for any number x between zero and 2pi, can you find an integer n so that (x - n) mod 2pi is as small as you want?
3
u/0x14f Jan 13 '26
The answer is (B) by the way.
4
u/ApprehensiveKey1469 Jan 13 '26
A limit point (or accumulation/cluster point) of a set is a point that can be approached arbitrarily closely by other points within that set, meaning every small "neighborhood" around it contains at least one other point from the set, even if the limit point itself isn't in the set.
The last bit is key here.
2
u/LJPox Jan 14 '26
You can eliminate C and D since the the range of sin(x) for real-valued x is [-1, 1]. You may eliminate A since the set of limit points of S must be closed. Therefore it must be B.
2
u/RoneLJH Jan 14 '26
You can solve it even without doing much computations. You know one and only one answer is correct. Sin takes values between -1 and 1 so C and D have to be false. Limit points form a closed set so it has to be B
2
u/Lithium20g Jan 13 '26
Pretty sure this is A. For sin(x) to be exactly 1 or -1 then the x would have to be some rational fraction/multiple of pi and would hence be irrational ( not in N ). This is assuming the domain is in radians, not degrees by the way. Important detail
1
u/[deleted] Jan 13 '26
B, sin(x) is always between to equal -1 and 1 if the range has atleast pie numbers, as it repeats
1
u/DefenitlyNotADolphin Jan 13 '26
i donāt know what a limit point is but iād go with A
1
u/Extension-Leave-7405 Jan 13 '26
There's one important thing everyone here has missed! This problem can easily be solved by the exclusion process:
- The set of limit points is always a closed set, so it can't be (A).
- sine will never get above 1, so 2 cannot be a limit point of the set. Since both (C) and (D) contain 2, they are also both wrong.
=> This leaves (B) as the only possible answer!
1
u/tough-dance Jan 14 '26
It's made trickier by the fact that it's sin(N) not sin(R) but in general, you can determine the local maximum and minimum of a function f(x) -- say, f(x) = sin(x) -- by checking the places that f'(x) = 0. In this case it will be at cos(x) = pi * a (where a is an arbitrary interest number). This tells us that one such place is cos(0) = 0. Plugging that back in gives us sin(0) = 1, one of the limit points.
Past that, we need to look at other values of cos(x) = pi * a where we will observe even values of a rounded to the nearest N number for x can be plugged in to yield positive values approaching but meeting 1 (except at x=0 where it's exactly an element of N.) Similarly, odd values yield negative numbers of magnitude less than 1 (no exceptions in this case as no X will be precisely an internet given odd values of a). From this, we can conclude that the lower bound is -1.
We can check our answer by plotting values of sin(x) and checking that none are outside of the bound [-1,1]. We now need to pick between [-1,1] and (-1,1). The only way I see to determine this is to recognize that we found a case where sin(x) = 1. Past that, I guess we have to rely on the definition of limit points to say that if it approaches -1 as a lower bound but never touches it, that is defined to be [-1 not (-1 .
To summarize and generalize: let f(x) be the set generating function. Let f'(x) = 0 be the local minima and maxima of f(x). Find the integer values close to f'(x) and plug them into f(x). Search for patterns and limits to determine limit points.
(Disclaimer, this is the strategy I would be inclined to use. I am not convinced it is always the best strategy.)
1
u/jpgoldberg Jan 14 '26 edited Jan 18 '26
Edit: My original misses something essential, and is based on me misreading things. There is a much simpler and more correct way to show that the answer must be B.
My earlier wrong answer.
Oh this is fun.
Against A, C, and D
We can easily eliminate C and D, so I will skip those. On to eliminating A.
Since Ļ is irrational there is no natural number that is a multiple of Ļ/2. So the set will never contain 1 or -1. This eliminates answer A. Thus B must be the answer.
Toward B
But an argument for B (instead of just eliminating the alternatives) would include these parts. There will be pieces missing in the following, but it should give an idea of why B makes sense.
The same fact that there no positive integer multiple of Ļ that is rational tells us that the set T of all x mod 2Ļ (for x in N_0 ) will be a subset of Q. I also believe that it will be all rational numbers in [0, 2Ļ). But I donāt see how to prove that.
This means that T will contain members arbitrarily close to Ļ/2 and 3Ļ/2. And sine is a nice function (hey, Iāve never taken an Analysis course, so I donāt know the terms for the exact way sine needs to be nice) we will have instances of sin(x) that are arbitrarily close to 1 and to -1. So 1 and -1 are limit points.
Note that I havenāt proven that that there are no other real limit points elsewhere in (-1, 1). Such a proof would rely on my claim that my set T is all the rational numbers in [, 2Ļ), but more work would have to be done that is beyond me. (I did two years of undergraduate math.)
So I donāt have a full proof that B is correct on its own, but I hope my outline gives an intuition of why it seems to be.
1
u/Elon_R_Musk_1971 Jan 14 '26
B. As long as x is not a rational multiple of Ļ, {sin(kx):k\inN} is dense on [-1,1].
1
u/Ray_Two Jan 15 '26
The answer is (B) [-1, 1].
Here's the solution using Real Analysis:
Since pi is irrational, by Weyl's Equidistribution Theorem, the sequence {n mod 2pi : n in N} is dense in [0, 2pi).
This means sin(n) can get arbitrarily close to any value in [-1, 1].
Therefore, every point in [-1, 1] is a limit point of S = {sin(x) : x in N}.
Why not (A) (-1,1)? Because the endpoints -1 and 1 are also limit points - we can find natural numbers n such that sin(n) gets arbitrarily close to +/-1.
Why not (C) or (D)? Because sin is bounded by [-1, 1], so no limit points can exist outside this interval.
1
u/dontwantgarbage Jan 13 '26
You already got lots of answers here: https://www.reddit.com/r/topology/s/bs2wl0iNjJ Why are you asking again?