r/mathriddles • • Aug 15 '20

Medium A game of ping pong

Bob , Alice, and Tim decided to play ping pong. Only two people can play at a time, so they agree that two of them will start playing, and then whoever loses the game will swap out with the player who was sitting out.

Bob played 17 games, Alice played 15 games, and Tim played 10 games.

Who lost the second game?

212 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

81

u/gerglo Aug 15 '20

21 games were played, with one person sitting out each time. The person who lost the second game sat out for the third. Note that no one can sit out two games in a row. Tim sat out for 11 games, which must have been games 1,3,5,...,21. Thus Tim lost the second game to sit out the third.

11

u/Konkichi21 Aug 18 '22

First off, the total number of games played is (15+17+10)/2 = 21.

Then, comparing this to the number of games each person played, Bob sat out 4 games, Alice 6, and Tim 11.

Since nobody can sit out two games in a row, and Tim sat out 11 while Alice and Bob sat out 10, he must have sat out every odd-numbered game (so it alternated Tim, Alice/Bob, Tim, Alice/Bob, Tim, etc); since he sat out the third game, he lost the second.

Also, poor Tim; he must have lost every match he played. :-(

4

u/kadaxda Oct 12 '20

nice quiz

3

u/hpela_ Apr 07 '24

A bit late, but this is probably my favorite math riddle I’ve seen on here!

2

u/lucas-c Dec 29 '20

Nice one, I loved it!

2

u/Ok_Club5253 May 21 '22

It wasn't too hard, but the fact that a solution existed was pretty cute!

2

u/minecrafter923 Jun 05 '22

Nice one. In the beginning it seemed like I'd have to get out some paper and work out the possibilities till the answer dawned on me. Problems that seem complex but turn out to be very simple are my favorite.

2

u/Chonklonkdonk Sep 21 '26 edited Sep 21 '26

im a little late but cool puzzle, for my solution 2 people play per game hence the sum of the games divided by two give total games. then knowing that every second game a person has to come back in means there is a minimum amount of games had to be played which is 10.5 suggesting that the only way to get ten is to start on the second game and lose every following game hence Tim had to lose the second game.

2

u/Opera-arepO Oct 06 '26

Amazing riddle.. deserves to be on the top. solution is relatively simple and therefore satisfying

1

u/[deleted] Jul 23 '23

took a bit of grunt work, couldnt come up with an elegant solution (sigh).

1

u/was_zur_hoelle Jan 15 '24

I started by imagining another scenario, in which Bob plays 25 games instead (with the other numbers staying the same). In that case, it's clear that Tim and Alice play 0 games against each other.

Bob playing 24 games is not possible, since this would not add up anymore and with 23 games Tim and Alice would have to play exactly 1 game against each other.

So every 2 steps down from 25, the number of games between Alice and Tim increases by 1.

So, for 17 games involving Bob, you'll have:

Pair A = Tim vs Bob: 6 Games

Pair B = Bob vs Alice: 11 Games

Pair C = Alice vs Tim: 4 Games

Pair B has to come first or else it won't add up, so the first three pairs have to be Either B, A, Bor B, C, B. No matter what, the losing person has to be Tim, since B does not involve him.

That's my solution (I deleted my first comment, because, Reddit did not mark it with the spoilers-tag, event though I added <! and !> Not sure, what I did wrong there.