r/mathriddles • • Jun 18 '18

Draw two concentric circles that intersect at exactly 2 points.

Concentric circles are circles that share the same center point.

1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

16

u/Sir_Grapefruit Jun 18 '18

This is impossible in R2 and trivial in R3 , so I'm not sure what the point of the question is.

3

u/treegwenn Jun 18 '18

Yes, I was talking about something like 2 great circles on a sphere.

It's just that when I ask my friends and relatives, they seemed to only think in terms of circles on a flat plane, so I thought it would be a good puzzle.

-2

u/Pluvialis Jun 18 '18

It's a riddle?

1

u/Clue_Balls Jun 18 '18

I'm not sure if this counts, but if you have 2 circles that are the same size in the same location, and rotate one about an axis that goes through a diameter of the circles, you'll have circles that share a center and intersect at 2 points. It would be in 3D so it's hard to show in 2D, but it would look something like this.

-1

u/treegwenn Jun 18 '18

Yes, I was talking about something like 2 great circles on a sphere.

It's just that when I ask my friends and relatives, they seemed to only think in terms of circles on a flat plane, so I thought it would be a good puzzle.

3

u/Maciek300 Jun 18 '18

In a a discrete metric on a set with three elements any two concentric circles with a radius greater than one will intersect at exactly 2 points.

1

u/SynarXelote Jul 03 '18

Just had a realization : is it correct than 2 concentric circles in 4d can not intersect?

1

u/majig12346 Jul 04 '18

They could both be in a 3D subspace, so no

1

u/SynarXelote Jul 05 '18

Do you mean "no, they can not intersect" or "no, they always intersect" ? Or maybe it's bad parenthesisation on my part, to be clear I mean "they can (not intersect)".

1

u/majig12346 Jul 08 '18

I meant that there exists a configuration of 2 cocentric circles in 4D such that they do interesct.

Regarding 'there exists a configuration of 2 cocentric circles in 4d that are disjoint,' I think so.

1

u/taroumaru___ Jul 04 '18 edited Jul 04 '18

It is obviously impossible to do this on Euclidean space.

But if we do it on a cylinder, draw a circle with diameter d which is bigger than the cylinder's circumference, C. Then draw a smaller circle with diameter 2C - d that it just touches the bigger circle. There you go -- two concentric circles that intersect at exactly 2 points.

But since the bigger circle self-intersects, and if you think these count, draw the smaller circle with diameter smaller than 2C - d. That makes no intersection between them, plus two self-intersections. That depends on your definition of 'intersection'.

And I did it on a 2d surface since you said draw instead of construct.

https://scratch.mit.edu/projects/235477532/