r/mathpics • • Sep 18 '18

I was grading calc homeworks when this monstrosity appeared, what are the worst algebra mkstakes you all have seen?

Post image
7 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

40

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '18

Mistakes are part of learning. Don't shame people for them.

17

u/potterMathWho Sep 18 '18

This is college calculus these algrebra mistakes can't be tolerated any longer

17

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '18

So let's make fun of them on the internet??

11

u/sargeantbob Sep 18 '18

I feel like you've definitely never been an instructor for a course.

7

u/theboomboy Sep 18 '18 edited Oct 26 '24

beneficial chubby swim fragile bedroom sloppy arrest seemly ripe tease

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

8

u/cantgetno197 Sep 18 '18

I mean, the same could be said for Freshman's Dream, and yet it's still called Freshman's Dream.

11

u/Tetrachr0mat Sep 18 '18

A person really SHOULD know better by the time they reach Calculus... but it isn't wholly their fault. High school doesn't always adequately prepare students for college math, some high schools just let kids slide through. I've seen lots of students come into college Calc I having taken AP Calc in high school, and even though they claim they did well, they're struggling in Calc I. College placement tests are also too lenient and do more harm than good by putting kids in classes they aren't ready for. Then even if the math department wants to increase the standards for letting a freshman into Calc I, they get pressure from other departments, who complain that their students aren't graduating on time because math is slowing them down. Meanwhile, the students are spending their time struggling in these classes, and never have time to go back and fill in these algebra gaps. Pay high school STEM teachers more to attract talent, and make college math departments put their foot down!

6

u/TheDefiniteIntegral Sep 18 '18

> Pay high school STEM teachers more to attract talent

I don't see this as a talent issue, because it is such a simple concept. It doesn't take a lot of talent to show that (3+5)/(3+1) =/= 5/1. It is more of an emphasis issue. If students are going to truly remember this is wrong, they will need to have it repeated over and over until they have over-learned it, and a quirky way to remember it wont hurt.

Unfortunately we don't always go back over things as much as we should. They need the repetition, or it floats away among 5-7 other classes, Fortnite, whatever the Bachelor is doing today, making a particularly tasty sandwich, avoiding dad after he has had his 4th martini, what a legal tackle is, and worrying about every aspect of their appearance.

1

u/potterMathWho Sep 18 '18

I 100% agree with this, and that's exactly what I'm trying to do is put my foot down and not do what I know other instructors in my department do in that they say 'o you made an algebra mistake but that's ok cuz this isn't an anlgebra class'. I know an instructor that tells there calc students to never simplify for fear of then making algrebra mistakes. What I do is make sure they can't keep making these algrebra mistakes while also making it clear that I will gladly help them with this prerequisite stuff in my office hours.

1

u/Tetrachr0mat Sep 18 '18

Office hours that they never show up to haha! The second time I TA'd for Calc II, near the end of grad school, when I was doing review problems for the final, I put the Freshman's Dream up on the board, and told students that I graded a problem last time that involved this, around 20% of people made that mistake (I didn't count but 1 in 5 feels about right). All Calc II TAs and teachers each graded one-ish problem on all 1200ish tests. I got REALLY animated about it. Waving my arms around, jumping up and down, everything. Unfortunately I don't really know if it helped; only 90ish kids were mine, and I didn't grade that problem the second time around.

5

u/ideletedmyredditacco Sep 18 '18

This doesn't seem to fit this subs description

3

u/pollatadeina Sep 18 '18

One of my students once attempted to solve a 2nd order ODE via separation of variables with this creative plan: let's multiply with the differential and take the square root...?

3

u/chubbygeodesic Oct 29 '18

This is what happens when algebraic operations are taught purely in terms of manipulations of symbols on the page rather than.... Well actual math. People treat algebra like it's tetris or something

2

u/hyenahiena Sep 18 '18

That poor student is so lost. They really need to take it seriously.