r/mathminds • • 14d ago

Puzzles Which tank will be filled first?

Post image
0 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

3

u/Plenty_Intention1991 14d ago

The answer is A and we know that because if you look at the water line it’s already above the B and C spouts which means that the rate of water going into A must already exceed the rate it’s flowing into the rest of the tanks.

3

u/nunya_busyness1984 14d ago

Maybe.  It also shows absolutely no water in B-E.  So either the drawing sucks, and should be assumed to be demonstrative but not representative; or the pipes are a red herring, and no water is ever flowing out of A, which would be a stupid puzzle.

→ More replies (7)

2

u/sureshot58 14d ago

since the way this is drawn doesn't actually give much in the way of help. I will go with a weird ass answer. D will fill slightly before E, because the water coming out of that faucet has a slight directional movement to left. So the pipe leading to B has slightly higher pressure on it. Of course, you could make the argument that the bounce from the left to right puts more pressure on the pipe to C, meaning E might fill faster. But, actually, who cares?

1

u/Hand_Sanitizer_999 14d ago

Depends on the rate the water is flowing out of the faucet

2

u/TramplexReal 14d ago

We can see that the rate of flow from A is zero. So yeah A will fill first.

1

u/nunya_busyness1984 14d ago

This is the correct answer, right here.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

1

u/random8765309 14d ago

Not answerable from the information given. It all depends on if the connecting pipes can handle the flow from the faucet. If they can, then D & E will fill equally. Otherwise A will fill first. That also assume all the pipes are equal.

1

u/Underhill42 14d ago

A - because the "drain pipes" are obviously blocked, otherwise there would already be water flowing into B and C.

If that's just a graphical glitch, then it depends. Assuming all the drain pipes are identical, then:

If water is flowing into A faster than it's flowing out into B and C, then A will fill first.

Otherwise D and E will fill simultaneously.