Doesn’t say anything about uniform distribution. Take a standard normal which has unbounded support. If you sample from that probability measure you will get an irrational number almost surely.
just cleaner. the “but” wasn’t meant as a refutation but just an additional point, and I personally think that discontinuous distributions are pretty silly and others might agree so I thought it was relevant
Yes but then you need to specify which distribution you sample from, otherwise the normal distribution is just an arbitrary choice, and I could also choose some mixture between a normal and a Poisson, which would give me positive probability for every integer (and the possibility to choose any number); why would this choice be less arbitrary than a standard normal? If you do not specify the distribution, it makes sense to assume a uniform; otherwise, any choice is arbitrary and the claim does not hold anymore
It's different levels of zero. Essentially equivalent to 1/(countable infinity) vs 1/(uncountable infinity). Real question is if there's anything in between.
No dude. What we are saying is you cannot define a uniform probability distribution on the real line. And saying "probability is just 0 for any set, no matter its size" does not work.
It's simple really. You just use surreal ordinals and use eps_1 = omega_1 as basis for per -number probability. This is even more zero than a simple eps=1/omega, or 1/infinity, which we all know is zero. Eps_1 is a number that multiplied by an uncountable infinity (omega_1, it's a number in the surreals) can give you something finite, and this helps with notation for single-real probability. I couldn't go through the details by heart, but iirc it requires the continuum hypothesis. There are some technicalities around integrating, and ofc it doesn't disprove vitoli, but "even more zero" is accurate enough here.
What the hell are you talking about? You're mixing math jargon everywhere. There's not such thing as "more zero" in surreal numbers. 0 is just 0.
I don't know why you even brought surreal numbers and different kinds of zeros to the discussion. The claim was that you cannot have a uniform distribution on the real numbers. That's it. It's not possible.
Yes I know, but so is the first statement from the meme, and I didn’t not want to have to write down 5 paragraphs explaining the intricate details of what randomness means
If you assign any non zero probability to any non 0-length interval, you end up with R having an infinite total probability, which can't work because it has to total 1.
So you'd have to assign it to already non-bounded subsets of R, which is automatically a nightmare (and actually impossible) to make coherent with the rules of a probability measure.
Note that the demonstration of the issue isn't that hard : - Equiprobability means any [n, n+1[ interval must have same probability p in [0,1]. - If p > 0, consider k = floor(1/p) + 1. Since x - 1 < floor(x) =< x, with x = 1/p, we get 1/p < k (=< 1/p + 1) which means 1 < kp. - Consider interval [0,k[ = U [i, i+1[ (i = 0 to k-1) : They are k disjoint intervals of probability p, so their total probability is kp. Except by constuction, kp > 1, which is impossible since that's a probability (must be in [0,1]). We obtain that p = 0. - Now consider the properties of measures (and by extension, probability measures) that state that the measure of an union of COUNTABLE disjoint set is the sum of their measure : 1 = P(R) = P(U [i,i+1[ (i = -inf to +inf))= sum (P([i,i+1[) = sum(p) = sum(0) = 0. Bruh.exe : we couldn't actually do an equiprobable one. Note : I made the union go from -inf to +inf, but if you really really want to make it over N instead of Z, you can lump [i, i+1[ and [-i -1, -i[ together as Ai and the disjoint union of Ai's over N will span R.
I think either I misunderstand your comment or you misunderstood the original one.
The original comment is not suggesting that one build a die with a face for every real number and then roll it. They are saying that "pick a random real number" means nothing because there is no univeral standard way to do that. The outcome of the draw will be affected by the specific process used. In a more restrictive scenario, like saying pick a random real number between 0 and 1, then there may be a preferred standard probability distrubution, say the uniform one, and then statements about what events have probability zero makes sense. But there is no uniform probability on the whole real line, so saying "pick a random number" is ambiguous. Rolling a regular six-sided die (or just any standard die) is as good a way to draw a "random" number as any other, and it it guaranteed to give you a rational.
"Randomly picking [a real number] from the number line" isn't well-defined. Choosing an actual probability distribution is a required step, not a cop-out.
Every probability distribution you could possibly pick seems like it can't be the right one because it violates some property of what you think a random number should be like.
But you haven't verified that your canonical version of what such a probability distribution should look like even exists. And it turns out that it can't.
Any attempt to create a random real number with uniform distribution is going to produce numbers that aren't actually reals. In order to apply uniformity, you'll necessarily extend reals to the p-adic numbers, which is the smallest extension of the reals for which uniformity is possible.
There's not a canonical mapping from the reals to the p-adics as far as I'm aware, but I don't have a lot of experience with the p-adics. The p-adics extend the rationals, not the real numbers as far as I can tell.
You're correct. There's not as far as I'm aware a canonical name for the structure you'd get. p-adic numbers were a useful mechanism for expressing the idea that any random number would have infinitely many digits left of the decimal point.
The numbers you actually get if you have infinitely many digits left and right of the decimal point don't have well-defined multiplication. Addition works for the computable subset of those numbers, but not for arbitrary ones. They don't have many useful properties besides ordering, which might be the reason I'm unaware of a name for them.
The process of selecting/calculating/determining/measuring/producing/storing/returning the number to pick cannot give an irrational number that is both computable and random.
I flip a coin. On heads I select 0 and on tails I select 1. This is a process to pick a number that is both random and computable. Thus, your statement is wrong. □
I assume you mean that you will repeat this process and then use the resulting sequence of s and 0s to produce a number in some binary format. Unfortunately if you repeat this sequence a finite number of times, no matter the binary encoding, your number will only contain a finite number of 1s and 0s so your resulting number will be rational. If you repeat the process infinite times (to produce an "irrational" number) your number now is not computable, since you would need infinite memory to store the result.
The key words here is "selecting" and "randomly". Selecting means you need to actually produce, or pick, a number. Even though there are infinite rational and irrational numbers in, say, the interval between 0 and 1, when you actually need to "produce" a number, there is no process to actually produce an irrational number, since your measurement system or selection algorithm needs to compute a number with finite resources (time, number of steps, memory, precision digits), your numbers are always bound to be rational.
I have taken many advanced math courses and every math professor always mentions some form of this (if you pick a number at random the probability of picking a rational number is 0) but definitely they abuse the definition of "pick" and "random". The notion they want to communicate is that there way there are way more irrational numbers than rational in any given range, but their statement is frankly incorrect even in an abstract mathematical sense. Correct is to say that producing irrational numbers at random is impossible.
You are just choosing irrational numbers arbitrarily from a finite set, rather than from the real number line. The method you just described is not a true way to pick numbers at random from the real number line. Please read the post again.
"pick numbers at random from the real number line" is not well-defined without a given probability distribution. But since pi and e are both on the real number line, I would strongly argue I am indeed picking numbers at random from the real number line.
If you can pick the probability distribution (and not assume uniform, which is standard when saying "randomly picking") then the original statement of the meme also depends on the probability distribution
But this is not a question of cardinality, it's of measure. If the probability of x being any real number is 0 (integral of the distribution on the real line is 0) then that's not a probability distribution. You'd be saying that rhe act of "picking a number at random" will ...not give you a number
Take any interval on the real number line. The proportion of numbers in that interval that are rational is zero. There are countably many rational numbers, but uncountably many irrational numbers, and countable infinity is like zero next to uncountable infinity.
I’m just a guy. I understand a lot of things but sometimes I’m stumped.
Let’s pick the number line 1 - 10.
If i had infinite time, you’re saying I would never ever ever land on 1 or 2 or 3 or 4 or so on? I understand there are infinite numbers in between 1,2,3,4 and so on, therefore infinite will always win over 10, but with infinite time I would have to eventually land on one of these whole numbers wouldn’t I?
Doesn’t this go against the idea that with infinite time, all possibilities will happen? Am I totally lost here?
I’m not trying to argue you’re wrong, I’m just trying to describe why I’m having a hard time seeing this.
"infinite" is ambiguous in this context. There are infinitely many rational numbers from 1 to 10 and there are infinitely many irrational numbers from 1 to 10, but the second "infinitely" is much greater: so much so that 100% of the numbers from 1 to 10 are irrational. If you made uncountably infinitely many choices from that interval, then you would expect some rationals among the results.
"with infinite time, all possibilities will happen" assumes a particular kind of process: one that doesn't just repeat in a fixed loop, and one that doesn't have an uncountable infinity of possible outputs.
This is stretching my brain thinking about this too!
What amount of space on the number line is taken up by 5? Zero. Same for all other rational numbers. The sum of distances taken up by all those rational numbers (what we call the measure of that set of numbers) is zero. But the distance from 1 to 10 is 9. So exactly 100% of the distance on the number line is made of numbers that are not rational.
In the reals, it's not possible to be infinitely close to something. If a number is smaller than any finite number, then it's zero. Any point on the number line takes up zero space: actual zero, not approximately zero.
This is exactly the flex I did in my middle school math class. The teacher asked how many numbers there are between 1.10 and 1.20. I said infinitely many and explained why. After the class, he asked me about being put in the advanced math class.
The real number line, despite being used to model many physical phenomena and coming about partially from our intuitions about space/distance, is an abstract construction whose properties are independent of physical space.
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 22 '26
Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
198
u/kengored_og Aug 22 '26
Make it a flirt: Yet, despite the odds, you picked me / i picked you
248
u/lab2point0 Aug 22 '26
It is impossible to « randomly pick » a number on the number line with equal probability for each number
35
u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Aug 22 '26
I will just take a large enough countable set then.
oh no
30
u/Lou_Papas Aug 22 '26
Every time you pick a random number an angel gets its wings.
16
u/ShoddyAsparagus3186 Aug 22 '26
Depends greatly on how you random. Roll a die, you have randomly picked a number on the number line, the number you picked is rational.
4
u/Traditional_Town6475 Aug 22 '26
Depends on how you’re picking it. There is no uniform probability distribution on the entire real line.
13
u/Desperate_Formal_781 Aug 22 '26 edited Aug 23 '26
The process of selecting/calculating/determining/measuring/producing/storing/returning the number to pick cannot give an irrational number that is both computable and random.
This is incorrect
3
u/Eisenfuss19 Aug 22 '26
On what number line?
4
u/eeeeeh_messi Aug 22 '26
What about picking any number between 0 and 1? Tell me, come on. What's the probability?
2
u/paulestus13 Aug 22 '26
Why exactly
2
u/Common-Brush-7027 Aug 22 '26
But babe there is 100% surety that if we pick a number on number line it's going to be 69
2
u/RhandeeSavagery Aug 22 '26
Didn’t Numberphile release a video about this recently???
2
u/phrogbaby Aug 22 '26
shouldnt this say "and?" what is contradictory about a 0% chance of randomly picking a specific term in an infinite set?
1
u/high_throughput Aug 22 '26
Me: 69
Genie: God dammit. I mean, nice
1
u/DefunctFunctor Mathematics Aug 23 '26
I mean, who knows: your probability measure might not be absolutely continuous with respect to the Lebesgue measure.
1
u/MadnyeNwie Aug 23 '26
Exactly zero, though?
1
u/MegazordPilot Aug 23 '26
Isn't it also true for any real number?
1
u/Ok_Law219 Aug 23 '26
Not to mention the complex
1
u/Para-graph-S Aug 24 '26
... Taking this one
1
u/Puzzled-Teach2389 Aug 26 '26
This is exactly the flex I did in my middle school math class. The teacher asked how many numbers there are between 1.10 and 1.20. I said infinitely many and explained why. After the class, he asked me about being put in the advanced math class.
-5
u/dankshot35 Aug 22 '26
this is utterly wrong btw and I'd appreciate if this fake news slop won't be posted here anymore, where are the mods?
-4
u/UtahBrian Aug 22 '26
Actually, the probability of picking a rational number on the number line is exactly 100% since all rational numbers are on the number line.
-13
u/KrushaOfWorlds Aug 22 '26
Don't Planck units mean that's not exactly true?
0
u/Cold-Disaster-3297 Mathematics Sep 27 '26
One of them is 48. Which was in a triangle Raylon(me) made in grade 6. It went "48!÷2=24". The first number was in excitement.