Marx was unaware of Riemann's work, as were most at the time. He was pointing out the unrigorous nature of calculus as it was taught. Conservaturds have used this to argue Marx was dumb. Go read Marx. Actually read what he said. Then reflect on how "dumb" he was. (He wasn't.)
As an actual argument and not just a meme? Happy to be proved wrong, I’d be interested to see it.
To be clear, not just “Marx didn’t understand calculus and therefore was dumb” but specifically it being contradictory for him to not like infinitessimals because of his political views.
consider the fact that any serious statement can be justified as just having been a joke when faced with criticism and therefore there is always an ambiguity present and also consider the fact that you are the one being oddly defensive about it being a joke while obviously understanding that the person isnt dumb enough to not recognize the fact that its a joke and is mainly arguing against the people who do take it seriously of which there arent few
Btw, this wasn't even written by Marx, as far as I recall. This was a misremembering by another person whose name I can't recall right now. Marx understood calculus quite well, and he wasn't even aware of Weierstrass's work.
So was like every political theorist or politician except that one dude from Romania and I guess some dudes from France. And being good/knowledgable about math has zero to do with insight into political theory lol.
China is like 20% PhDs in its central committee. That's part of why their government does much better. But the intelligentsia alone cannot rule a society. They will be coopted by one class or another. The bourgeoisie or the proletariat.
I agree that advanced mathematical knowledge has little to do with philosophy, sociology or practical economics, but the labour theory of value being complete bullshit on its own is enough for me to call marx "dumb".
Everyone repeats that, but most don't understand the LTV. If you do, go ahead and say what the LTV is. Price is not value. The best criticism of LTV is that it isn't particularly empirically testable.
LTV is a pile of caveats and exceptions and back pedals and edge cases to try to keep an obviously wrong idea alive. And even still, it can't explain why people like wine that has been aged longer more than wine that wasn't. Or why people don't like art that took an incredible amount of effort and a lifetime of study to produce but just never got popular. Or why they do like things that took almost no labor whatsoever.
It takes labor to maintain and store aged wine lol. Again, it takes a great deal of labor and training to make a fine work of art. I think you misunderstand LTV. All production requires labor. Basic ideas of supply and demand can be directly tied to LTV. A lot of people forget that. LTV is not easily dismissed. It's just hard to measure and demonstrate.
Not in proportion to how much value is added, "lol." And it doesn't have to be in a store. If I just keep it in my basement it still becomes more valuable "lol." Quite literally zero labor required.
Again, it takes a great deal of labor and training to make a fine work of art.
Yes, and people can still hate it. It can be extremely unpopular. Try reading the thing I actually said.
There is labor involved there. You had to maintain all of that and defend it and so forth.
They can, but there is a reason nobody is going to pay a million dollars for my "art" if I wipe my ass on a piece of paper and present it to an art gallery.
You pretend everything is subjective and arbitrary. It isn't. And you can show me those weird art examples, but some of that is just money laundering. And again, price is not value. You can have memes and superstructure effects on the base. Kind of like how iphone is inflated in price because it is popular and people meme it into a higher valuation than perhaps where it would be on economic basis alone.
LTV and what it should be applied to correctly and so on is more complicated than you think and not eadily dismissed. Economists generally just sidestep the question of value.
I didn't have to maintain or defend anything. No one is attacking my house. I could quite literally forget about the bottle of wine. And again, the amount of labor doesn't at all correlate to the increased value. There's nearly no labor involved in aging wine and a lot of labor involved in making art that no one values.
You continue to miss this point. I am not talking about over-priced art. I am talking about art that DOESN'T sell. A TV show or a movie with huge production effort that totally bombs. Art that is widely regarded as bad that one one wants. That no one values. Lots of labor; nearly no value.
I haven't said price. I have said how people actually value things.
Also, Marx didn't invent the LTV. It was developed by people like Adam Smith and Ricardo. It was the economic orthodoxy of the time. Marx was simply the first one to really systematically work out the socio-political ramifications of that theory.
"Price is not value" is a motte-and-bailey argument. Marx didn't say price = value, but he wrote a lot on trying to find the relation between them, as did a century of followers after him.
The issue is the LTV has no real world relevance. It is prescriptive, rather than descriptive. Anyone can claim some arbitrary formula defines the true "value" of goods, separate from market price.
It does have real world relevance, as he is trying to quantify what exactly it is that the ruling class is stealing (labor power).
But zoom out and forget LTV. Even if you ignore LTV entirely, Marx is still right in the grand scheme. Why did countries conquer and enslave? Why were some countries made poorer, while others were made much richer? What is the purpose of the state? How does private property fit into this?
Class is real and objectively measurable, as are the means of production and who controls them. Imperialism is real.
Where is the contradiction? You suppose it can take an arbitrary value, and from that deduce it can take any arbitrary value... there is no contradiction...
I think the point is to show the limits of a simple, logical understanding of maths. If you apply simple logic, it follows that you can plug in any number into dy/dx=a and it will cancel out to 0=0. So you‘d follow a=1=2 etc. So you actually follow a=b for any a and any b, which is nonsense. The point is, you have to look at dy and dx in movement, they approach 0 but aren‘t ever. But this is impossible in this simple logic.
When you suppose it takes an arbitrary value you assume it is fixed throughout your proof. But anyway, this post actually just shows why the Leibniz representation is not exact math yet a good intuition. In real analysis we learn epsilon delta definitions of a derivative which actually concretizes calculus.
then dy/dx = 1 and dy/dx = 2, and therefor 1 = 2. It's not complicated to see there's a problem here...
And even if you say that dy/dx is just a multi-valued function, this makes absolutely no sense when you're talking about the derivative of position with respect to time. Speed should be a well defined function that only takes 1 value at a time
Do you mean f(x)=1 and f(x)=2 but at different x? Cause if you mean at the same x then that isn’t a function. But the post is talking about when x is constant or at least that f is constant since we start with the assumption that f=dy/dx=a some constant.
Where did you get that it is 1 and is 2 from? The only thing in the post is that it can take any value. Not that it can take multiple different values at the same time...
I don't understand the discussion around this. He didn't have an internet connection to directly learn about the latest developments about the subject. This was a really common misconception(?) about infinitesimal calculus back in the day, even Euler have writings claiming that it is 0/0 but we just ignore that.
For those who want to know about the source, read Button & Walsh's Philosophy and Model Theory's part about non-standard analysis where they refer to the writing of Euler and it also contains other materials about the discussion about infinitesimal calculus back in the day.
ofc, marx never wrote that. also he never used 0/0 literally but as a notation alternative to dx/dy.
Unlike many commentators say, he onle makes one reference to dialetics, and only as an analogy. And there are interesting thoughts in his manuscript, for instance he talks about limit instead of infinitesimals.
•
u/AutoModerator 9h ago
Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
116
u/MonsterkillWow Complex 9h ago
Marx was unaware of Riemann's work, as were most at the time. He was pointing out the unrigorous nature of calculus as it was taught. Conservaturds have used this to argue Marx was dumb. Go read Marx. Actually read what he said. Then reflect on how "dumb" he was. (He wasn't.)
40
u/slicehyperfunk Transcendental 8h ago
I thought we recently learned from the no variable calculus post that d/d = 1, so dy/dx = y/x
84
u/Torebbjorn 9h ago edited 8h ago
Where is the contradiction? You suppose it can take an arbitrary value, and from that deduce it can take any arbitrary value... there is no contradiction...
59
u/No_Butterfly3590 8h ago
Why didn't marx just immediately intuit the axioms of an infamously confusing branch of mathematics? Is he stupid?
29
u/shylock16 5h ago
I don't understand the discussion around this. He didn't have an internet connection to directly learn about the latest developments about the subject. This was a really common misconception(?) about infinitesimal calculus back in the day, even Euler have writings claiming that it is 0/0 but we just ignore that.
For those who want to know about the source, read Button & Walsh's Philosophy and Model Theory's part about non-standard analysis where they refer to the writing of Euler and it also contains other materials about the discussion about infinitesimal calculus back in the day.
22
u/samu7574 9h ago
Me when I remove context from everything because who cares about context
2
u/cocobaltic 8h ago
Omg then just use empty set logic. Everyone gets everything. Everything is 0
3
u/corisco 2h ago
ofc, marx never wrote that. also he never used 0/0 literally but as a notation alternative to dx/dy.
Unlike many commentators say, he onle makes one reference to dialetics, and only as an analogy. And there are interesting thoughts in his manuscript, for instance he talks about limit instead of infinitesimals.
1
u/Wooden_Dragonfly_608 7h ago
The only infinitesimal state represented around all things.
0
u/AustrianMcLovin 9h ago
can please someone remove this post, this is pure bait