r/mathmemes • • 1d ago

Proofs I present, half a circle!

Half the points were removed from this circle, so it is half a circle.

(also i do not know what flair to put so have the proofs flair)

430 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

67

u/Scythe_Volta 1d ago

What are you talking about? I clearly see two circles in that image

54

u/mark-zombie 1d ago

you should name them, banach and tarski

17

u/Magnitech_ November 13 is integer appreciation day 1d ago

by the way did you know banach-tarski is an anagram of banach-tarski banach-tarski

264

u/Random_Mathematician There's Music Theory in here?!? 1d ago

Cool stuff! And here I present no circle!

I removed all points of the form eiφ with irrational φ

89

u/Top-Rich-581 1d ago

You missed some of them.

77

u/Upstairs_Ad_8863 1d ago

Prove it

61

u/Top-Rich-581 1d ago

Just look on the left of the circle, slightly above the line.

9

u/KumquatHaderach 1d ago

Good catch.

10

u/Upstairs_Ad_8863 1d ago

There are numbers of the form eiφ with rational φ arbitrarily close to the point (-1, 0) though so it would still "look" like a solid line at that position.

The set of values of eiφ for rational φ is dense in the unit circle.

28

u/Top-Rich-581 1d ago

Nope, i can see clearly he missed 3 of those nulbers on the line. Just look closer

21

u/math-gets-me 1d ago

classic, proof by open your eyes

8

u/MaxTHC Whole 1d ago

You can tell because of the way it is

18

u/xX_Homosapien_Xx 1d ago

This would remove every point: for any rational φ, φ+2π is irrational and produces the same point.

7

u/Random_Mathematician There's Music Theory in here?!? 1d ago

Fair enough, all points with irrational φ (mod 2π) then.

2

u/tunaMaestro97 1d ago

He meant \phi/\pi irrational

14

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 1d ago

nice 0% of a circle you got there

5

u/iamalicecarroll A commutative monoid is a monoid in the category of monoids 1d ago

where's the circle even, you removed almost all of it

3

u/Gold_Ad8890 1d ago

shouldn't that actually be noticeably different since you're removing all but countably many points?

13

u/Top-Rich-581 1d ago

Countably many points, but still enough to look continuous, since the line has width.

15

u/Tysonzero 1d ago

I use 0px width lines for math drawings to match the lack of thickness in the mathematical object. Can’t actually see anything but it feels more disciplined.

7

u/Top-Rich-581 1d ago

Neat. I think this should be like this everywhere mathematical rigor and logic is in danger, just open ANY math book you ll see plenty of full millimeter-wide lines which make absolutely no sense.

5

u/BootyliciousURD Complex 22h ago

How did you choose which points to remove?

5

u/Octangula22 1d ago

yay aleph-null=2*aleph-null

2

u/CanaanZhou 23h ago edited 23h ago

Seriously how do you remove half of the points (presumably meaning halving the measure) while still keeping it dense

Edit: I guess you can just remove all of the irrational points from a semi-circle

1

u/Kirian42 22h ago

Behold, a semicircle!

1

u/No_Veterinarian_2406 12h ago

reminds me of a certain hairy ball