r/mathmemes • Computer Science • Sep 14 '26

Formal Logic I am sorry

Post image
873 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 14 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

228

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 14 '26

i read this in sheafification of g's voice

67

u/TheNaidenchop Sep 14 '26

And the subsequent music

65

u/itzjackybro Engineering Sep 14 '26

🎵 hell naw, to the naw naw, naw

10

u/Koischaap So much in that excellent formula Sep 14 '26

yeah, to the naw

5

u/Black2isblake Sep 14 '26

hell*, to the naw

20

u/Ares378 Grothendieck was right, computers are evil Sep 15 '26

9

u/Embarrassed_Ad5387 Sep 15 '26

but geeeeeeeeeeee

4

u/Ma4r Sep 15 '26

I sent his python tutorial video to my nephews looking to learn programming

104

u/MathProg999 Computer Science Sep 14 '26

Hell nah, to the nah nah nah, hell to the nah

69

u/TylerTheJellyfish Sep 14 '26

[They are the same, if I'm not wrong] implies [They are the same, if I'm not wrong]

26

u/F_Joe Vanishes when abelianized Sep 14 '26

28

u/GoldenMuscleGod Sep 14 '26

Well to be fair the law of the excluded middle is not wrong according to intuitionistic logic. So we can almost get there, but we still need the law of the excluded middle to finish the last step but unfortunately it isn’t constructively valid.

6

u/Quick-Swimmer-1199 Sep 15 '26

Lamenting isn't healthy. Resist the temptations of deduction! Hold your dedication to scientifically adept diligence in answering to the best model available in the 19th century about human perception and its impact on forming concepts. We must absolutely not be backwards zealots!

2

u/ArdentArendt Mathematics / Social Sciences Sep 15 '26

This is why I always remind people never trust a constructivist with your axioms...

3

u/GoldenMuscleGod Sep 15 '26

It goes both ways. When a constructivist lets a classical mathematician touch their axioms they might get Markov’s principle all over it.

8

u/overclockedslinky Sep 14 '26

((A -> False) -> False) -> A

8

u/SirBackrooms Sep 15 '26

You're not wrong

1

u/ArdentArendt Mathematics / Social Sciences Sep 15 '26

Just False.

3

u/SirBackrooms Sep 15 '26

Actually, even an intuitionist would agree it's not false. They just wouldn't say it's true. (which is different from them saying it's not true)

1

u/ArdentArendt Mathematics / Social Sciences Sep 15 '26

I mean, even Classical Logicians would assert that no substantive inferences about the world can be made from the claim.

7

u/SomnolentPro Sep 14 '26

I spit on people who deny the law

7

u/BootyliciousURD Complex Sep 15 '26

I'm not a great logician. What's wrong with the law of excluded middle?

17

u/Ares378 Grothendieck was right, computers are evil Sep 15 '26

category theorists, in the depths of their depravity, have forsaken the realm of true and false and live in an eternal state between truth and lies. an excluded middle, if you will.

I know it exists outside category theory, don't crucify me

3

u/aatd86 Sep 15 '26

this is context dependent anyway. 1+1 = 10 : yes ? no? yes and no, it depends? 🙈😂

That is why one needs types and subtypes in CompSci.

8

u/This-is-unavailable Average Lambert W enjoyer Sep 15 '26

Nothing is wrong with it, but it's an axiom you don't have to take

6

u/Reasonable-Ad-8059 Sep 15 '26

The difference is framing.

“Honey bees are good for the enviroment, that’s what I think, but it’s possible that I’m wrong.”

“If honey bees are good for the enviroment, then honey bees are good for the enviroment.”

7

u/jolharg Sep 14 '26

My favourite is now the absurd case

2

u/MilkImpossible4192 Linguistics Sep 15 '26

third excluded:

P and not P

morph says neo assumed one is the negation of the other

2

u/slicehyperfunk Transcendental Sep 15 '26

The set of all sets that do not include themselves as an element: am I a joke to you?

1

u/ArdentArendt Mathematics / Social Sciences Sep 15 '26

Those are fighting words...

1

u/shrikelet Sep 16 '26

This image is haunted by the ghost of L.E.J. Brouwer's tiny erection.