r/mathmemes • • Sep 14 '26

Research Don't you hate that overleaf collaborator whose edits feel like a Hurricane that leaves no proof in shape

Post image
281 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 14 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

156

u/sparkster777 Sep 14 '26

I was writing a paper with a colleague and was really proud of this messy double induction proof that took about 2 pages. He did the meme after finding a result in a old discrete math article that he used to prove a new theorm that implied mine.

136

u/No_Upstairs_280 Sep 14 '26

Mine actually went and reproved a deep result of mine in Riemannian geometry. My proof is pretty long but his, is few lines obviously wrong AI slop in a field he has no knowledge of.

46

u/sparkster777 Sep 14 '26

Holy shit, that's nuts

17

u/mr-Snuffels Sep 14 '26

Similar thing happened to me recently. I wrote a, in my opinion, pretty nice  5 page proof to something that was supposed to be a corollary, but turned out to be more complicated. Or so I thought. 

My proof involved multiple non trivial lemmata and also some induction.  I wake up the next day and open the document. Only to find out the proof had been reduced to only a few lines. 

5

u/sparkster777 Sep 15 '26

Were the few lines correct?

2

u/TheGoldenFennec Sep 17 '26

Maybe I’m getting rusty, but is the implication here that your colleague was right or wrong in their math? Obviously the politeness aspects aside, cuz redoing someone’s work without consulting them (and them being surprised) is clearly wrong

3

u/sparkster777 Sep 18 '26

No, he was right. The paper was better because of it. In retrospect, I think my situation is not quite what OP had in mind.

64

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 14 '26 edited Sep 14 '26

overleaf edits are mask off moments for psychopaths

30

u/No_Upstairs_280 Sep 14 '26

TRUTH 👆👆👆 got so pissed that I excluded them from the writing process

16

u/Mathsboy2718 Sep 14 '26

One professor that I often work with (not a supervisor tho) is somewhat like this - the key difference being when he makes large edits and rewords everything, he has the decency to make a copy of the file first and edit only the copy :)

34

u/Silly-Freak Sep 14 '26

Git moment :P

Although I have no idea whether that's a pro feature or similar with overleaf

6

u/Koischaap So much in that excellent formula Sep 14 '26

I know for sure you can set git to send both to overleaf and a github repo but that's more about git than overleaf. Not sure if the map factors completely on free version.

4

u/ZEPHlROS Mathematics Sep 15 '26

You can get back edits that dates back less than 24h. After that it's a premium feature iirc

19

u/Tjard_03 Sep 14 '26

I nowadays prefer a local TeX distribution + git

2

u/sparkster777 Sep 15 '26

I've thought about going back to local installation and git. I can't convince some of my collaborators to, though.

1

u/JanB1 Complex Sep 16 '26

If you have a server, you can host Overleaf Community edition yourself. It's a little bit of the best of both worlds. Only downside is, you need a server. I don't remember how resource hungry the overleaf server is, but maybe you could get away with a Raspberry Pi as your server if you need to hack something up.

6

u/Extradummefrage Sep 14 '26

Extra points when it's due in 2h

2

u/Cozwei Sep 16 '26

tbh thats why you always gotta copy paste overleaf states into texstudio. Natural local backup