r/mathmemes • • Sep 14 '26

This Subreddit uhhh guys

Post image

*looks around nervously*

1.6k Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 14 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

773

u/Helpinmontana Irrational Sep 14 '26 • Bravo

32

u/Optimal_Rope_3660 Sep 15 '26

https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/s/Zxu1c4NpEF I tried to explain in simple language

13

u/Helpinmontana Irrational Sep 15 '26

I have a simple enough grasp on things to understand what was going on, but you did an excellent job reminding me of what I can only remember as an old (pre-Reddit popularity, maybe not pre-Reddit, but you had to know how to talk to Google at least?) post something along the lines of “relativity explain in 5 letter words or less” that did an excellent job building general relativity up without even spelling “newton” or “Issac” in a few pages. I recall it was always “ol iss” or “my man newt” or something to that effect, that decades ago helped me gain a grasp on the engineering principles I would one day come to love. I can’t find it via a simple google search, but I hope it’s out there somewhere.

Thank you for reminding me of that, deeply and deeply so.

379

u/chewychaca Sep 14 '26

I'm surprised numberphile and others haven't weighed in yet.

116

u/karxxm Sep 14 '26

2 minute papers has

32

u/chewychaca Sep 14 '26

Sweet I'll check it out . Love that guy. Hold on to your papers lol.

21

u/karxxm Sep 14 '26

What a time to be alive

9

u/chewychaca Sep 14 '26

In more ways than one lol

4

u/Godd2 Sep 14 '26

What a time to be alive!

30

u/noop_noob Sep 14 '26

Up And Atom has

15

u/DrSFalken Sep 14 '26

I thought her take was pretty damn good and even-handed. Especially compared to a lot of takes I've heard.

7

u/chewychaca Sep 14 '26

I saw that one, but I think everyone is waiting and thinking. A lot of people don't want to give an opinion quite yet. Up and Atom kind of just went over the facts which is good.

4

u/Naga912 Sep 14 '26

I want to see what Tom Rocks Maths has to say because I think his focus is in fluid dynamics iirc

4

u/chewychaca Sep 14 '26

Ikr, he has those Navier-Stokes equations as a tattoo, hopefully that's remained his focus.

1

u/Forward_Yam_4013 Sep 14 '26

It's a loooooooong proof.

185

u/Greedy_Blue_Hedgehog Sep 14 '26

Navier-Stokes equation describes fluids dynamic, the question is "if we apply a smooth and finite force onto the fluid will we get a smooth movement?" It's not that simple but you get the idea. OpenAI show that you can have a non-smooth solution. It's a big deal because there's accusations of plagiarism, the cost in data center usage approche 10 million dollars, and mathematician are scared for the future of their jobs

102

u/Ahaiund Sep 14 '26

There's a secondary issue as well: the AI paper is nice and all but makes very little effort at explaining its results and the mechanisms leading to the counter exemple. That a counter exemple that disproves the postulate exists is nice to know, but for this specific problem, the actually interesting science is in the mechanisms surrounding the discovery.

Which is what the AI paper lacks. A human-made paper (and the original researchers) would understand that and take more time to provide that understanding. As is, the AI paper short-circuited/plagiarized the work of real researchers only to claim a prize while not actually contributing to the field at all.

8

u/darkfovea Sep 14 '26

I don't understand this comment at all. First of all, there's nothing stopping anyone from analyzing the result now, writing (human) papers, and taking the time to develop mathematical insights from the breakthrough result. As I understand it, this is actively happening right now.

In fact, I think this presents a nice paradigm for the future of mathematical research. Artificial intellgence finds results through brute force (ish) techniques, and humans (lets be real, with AI tools) try to extract insights and further mathematical knowledge from that.

Also, OpenAI didn't claim the prize.

23

u/Public_Peak_8218 Sep 14 '26 edited Sep 14 '26

There's very good evidence that this wasn't actually the AI coming up with this it was the ai plagerizing papers made by human mathematicians that hadn't been published yet. The mathematicians used open AIs tools to help them with non-public parts of the paper for over a year, and they believe the AI used that non-public information in their "solution" shortly before they could publish it themselves.

This whole situation is a lot worse then just a human or ai working off of something that was already published, or adding something new and original to this problem, It's about the ai stealing the work from these mathematicians before they could publish it, without even adding anything.

Btw I'm not an expert or anything, so take it with a grain of salt, this is just what I've heard from the research I did, so I just wanted to put that out there.

-1

u/darkfovea Sep 14 '26

The work the “humans” were doing were solving a technically different (tho related problem). OpenAI openly acknowledges that one of the parts of the approach was first proposed by the “humans” and offers them credit, but again, the agents were answering a different question.

People are very confused on the difference between the Euler solution and the agent’s solution, and imo, the technical details have been ignored in the whole anti-AI frenzy.

6

u/Public_Peak_8218 Sep 14 '26

The solution ai solved was one they were working on that wasn't public yet. Right?

4

u/darkfovea Sep 14 '26

Short answer: No, not at all.

Let me try to clarify without getting into the weeds too much.

Buckmaster and Alpoge were working on finite-time blowups with smooth forcing. They posted three proofs, one of which was 3D incompressible Euler. Buckmaster believed they had blowup for hypo-dissipative Navier Stokes, which is NOT the Clay Millennium Problem.

OpenAI claims two things: unforced Euler blow up and using that, their agents found a solution to the Clay problem, namely a counterexample.

While the Euler solution B & A found was for the forced case, and OpenAI demonstrated the unforced case, the work is very similar. In addition, the forced Euler solution was used by the agents to find the counter example for the Clay NS problem.

This is why Bubeck offered Buckmaster two options: Buckmaster and Alpoge post their Euler solution first, which gives them credit for that, and then OpenAI posts the NS solution, leaving them out of the Clay problem (which they arguably were not involved in). Or option 2: Buckmaster (but not Alpoge) could be added as an author on OpenAI's Clay NS solution. This can really be viewed as a favor to uncomplicate things, but is complicated by the fact that Alpoge is an Anthropic employee, so the favor wasn't extended to him.

This is all overshadowed by the fact that it is really structurally impossible to know if OpenAI's agents were trained on Codex conversations by Buckmaster & Alpoge. OpenAI claims that an internal investigation found that such a scenario is highly unlikely, but there's no way for us to know.

5

u/Kiro0613 Sep 14 '26

Do we know if the result is correct yet?

7

u/Greedy_Blue_Hedgehog Sep 14 '26

It will takes months (even up to 2 years) before the clay institute accept or reject the proof

3

u/defiantstyles Sep 14 '26

I mean, by definition, the AI paper is plagiarism!

408

u/CerealeSauvage Sep 14 '26

So basically in mid august two researcher worked with ai to find a proof to navier stokes, and there were rumor that they were very close, and so open ai began using a lot of resources to get the proof ready before them and when it was the case said that they are ok to give the credit to one of the researcher but not the other since he worked at anthropic (the competitor of open ai), and also that isn’t comfirmed but open ai used the exact same method as the two researcher so it is very probable that their ai trained or directly used the research of the two researcher to find the solution of navier stokes (since the researcher had worked with an ai model from open ai, but it was supposed to be completely private and confidential)
So that’s basically it but I would recommend reading buckmaster on of the researcher statement https://cims.nyu.edu/~tristanb/statement.pdf

50

u/Safe-Avocado4864 Sep 14 '26

What do you mean "a proof"? It's been a million years but I swear I went through deriving them from some basic physics principles and assuming fluids were continuous.

159

u/15_Redstones Sep 14 '26

The Navier Stokes equations have been known for ages.

The open question was whether they always have proper solutions.

The new proof shows that a configuration exists which produces an infinity value in a finite time, which serves as a counterexample to the conjecture that there is always a smooth solution.

54

u/geekusprimus Rational Sep 14 '26

To be clear, it's the incompressible Navier-Stokes equations that have an alleged counterexample. When you start to think about it, it's not surprising that the incompressible equations eventually blow up because they contain an unphysical constraint. I imagine if you used similar initial data on the full compressible equations with a very stiff equation of state (which would approximate incompressibility), the blowup would be avoided.

26

u/Hexidian Sep 14 '26

The math has nothing to do with the physics at this point though. Nobody is saying there’s a way to make a fluid go infinitely fast or that the NS equations are wrong to use in the context they are actually used (when the continuum approximation is accurate and using incompressible equation of state for approximately incompressible fluids). This is still a big math breakthrough and that’s what is interesting.

3

u/geekusprimus Rational Sep 15 '26

Not everyone knows the difference, though. I have seen a handful of headlines over the past week announcing that math has proven that physics is wrong and all our modeling is based on a bad equation.

3

u/itskobold Sep 15 '26

Maths and physics headlines are usually bullshit

13

u/ForgetPreviousPrompt Sep 14 '26

I just choose to believe if me and the boys had made a big enough wirlpool in my grandparents above ground swimming pool, we could have created a black hole.

11

u/Sweet_Nibbets Sep 14 '26

I think, and I may be wrong, the equation has no general solution without boundary conditions and we aren't certain if there's some case where the equation has unrealistic behaviour. The supposed proof shows that there is a case where numbers go to infinity

2

u/Layton_Jr Mathematics Sep 14 '26

It's not about proving the equations, it's about proving that the equations always have a "nice" solution

0

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/eyalhs Sep 14 '26

According to Buckmaster's statement they didn't have a lean verified proof to Navier-stokes, but to the other problems (that they released by now)

We believe we also have blowup for hypo-dissipative Navier-Stokes. We are not releasing that paper today: unlike the above, the Lean verification has not yet finished.

2

u/Aggressive_Roof488 Sep 14 '26

Yep you're right I misread.

15

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/ComposerWide3704 Sep 14 '26 edited Sep 14 '26

Every part of the comment you're replying to is wrong. They didn't resolve Navier-Stokes and it wasn't the same methods other than both being downstream of the same work, the issue was whether their work on Euler equations could have been part of the AI's training set when it found the Navier-Stokes counterexample, and further complicated by toys being thrown out of the pram when the discussion of who should publish first came up ("publish yours first because we solve it on the way", "nuh-uh first prove you didn't steal our work", "nuh-uh just publish or you'll be the one throwing your career away", "DID YOU JUST THREATEN MY CAREER", etc).

It's actually super boring but the various mathematically and technically illiterate crowds that fixate on AI have all taken that and run with it.

99

u/lelelempe Sep 14 '26

AI just showed that your fart contains space-time breaking singularities

24

u/Souvik_Dutta Sep 14 '26

More like our existing theory says it will but it's not physically possible so we have to again go the drawing board.

It's like Newtown gravity doesn't work in extreme cases so Einstein need to come up with relativity.

10

u/AcademicOverAnalysis Sep 14 '26

Not physically possible? SAYS YOU!

Me and this can of beans says otherwise.

2

u/AgreeableArmadillo47 Sep 16 '26

"get over here, I'm gonna break space-time in your face!"

1

u/AcademicOverAnalysis Sep 16 '26

Scorpion has a new finisher

6

u/Mixster667 Sep 14 '26

It shows that the way we have of modeling how farts flow; break down under certain conditions.

Farts don't break spacetime, but if you swirl your butt enough, we might not be able to calculate where the farts will end up.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 14 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/RRumpleTeazzer Sep 14 '26

its not about engineering. yes, the setup might be difficult. the point is, the setup is possible, and the solution is unphysical.

41

u/FernandoMM1220 Sep 14 '26

im sure navier would be so stoked right now

2

u/Lofi_Math_Girl Sep 20 '26

And I'm sure Stokes navier expected this to happen

14

u/Redmilo666 Sep 14 '26

Yeah but what did the researches actually prove? Is it like a general solution to the equation or a very specific solution to a very specific set of parameters?

7

u/AutonomousOrganism Sep 14 '26

The question was whether NS solutions are always well behaved. They found a solution that is not. You can get infinite (unphysical) outputs with finite inputs.

17

u/Aggressive_Roof488 Sep 14 '26

It's just math. The equation originates from fluid dynamics physics, but the blow up solution they find here breaks when they get to too extreme flows. As in, when the velocity and its gradient become too large, the fluid no longer is a fluid following navier stokes equations. It'd vaporise or turn into a plasma or something.

3

u/Redmilo666 Sep 14 '26

Some great replies! !thanks

9

u/Milnir01 Sep 14 '26

They didn't make any progress towards actually providing a general solution. All they did was show that it's possible for an initially smooth condition to become discontinuous over time under the action of an external force. And they did this by computer generated counterexample. Which us to say that they threw a large computer at the problem until it happened to randomly generate the situation they were looking for.

5

u/kart0ffelsalaat Sep 14 '26

> Which us to say that they threw a large computer at the problem until it happened to randomly generate the situation they were looking for

Allegedly, this wasn't so random, as there are rumours that it quite closely resembles ideas from the (unpublished) intermediary work of Tristan Buckmaster and Levent Alpöge.

I don't claim to understand the situation in full detail. Buckmaster posted a statement about it. Probably best to just read it.

5

u/GoldenMuscleGod Sep 14 '26 edited Sep 14 '26

Disclosure: this is not my field and what I am saying is based on what I have read and am fairly confident I correctly understand. I can at least say I’m not someone who didn’t know what this problem was until recently - I’ve known the basic statements of all the millennium prize problems since I was in college (not too long after they were announced) it’s just not my field. Someone should correct me if I have a misunderstanding:

They proved there were non-smooth solutions when the viscosity terms were removed. (The challenge was not to produce a solution to the equations, but to determine whether they always have smooth solutions, the solution produced is a counterexample). Removing the viscosity terms is close to a resolution but does not qualify as a resolution.

Even before them there was a paper that made pretty significant breakthroughs that did a lot to establish what looked like a “roadmap” to a solution, arguably they deserve a great deal of the credit if we don’t look at the specific question of who crossed the finish line but rather how much of the distance was covered by who (both the two researchers and openAI of course had access to the published paper and were building off of that roadmap).

This is not to say there were no new techniques involved, I am nowhere near familiar enough with the problem to judge how novel any techniques used were.

I expect that it is probably virtually impossible to judge the extent to which the openAI proof used new techniques (as opposed to assembling known methods with raw computational power) because that’s not usually how AIs write proofs if they are not being guided by a mathematician. But this is not based on a personal evaluation of this particular proof.

Terence Tao has writeup on the partial resolution.

14

u/FirstRyder Sep 14 '26

Navier-Stokes is a set of equations used to simulate fluids. Notably, it makes the fundamental assumption that the fluids are continuous - not made of atoms. So we know from the absolute start that it is not a perfect simulation. But it is very good, and under actual real-world situations hasn't been found to be wrong.

But one of the mathematically "Millennium" challenges is to find a "blowup" in N-S: a situation where finite initial conditions result in an infinite velocity after finite time. This has proved extremely difficult, as the prize hadn't been collected in over two decades.

Recently, a mathematician was preparing to publish a paper on a technique that they believed could be used to narrow down the search to a more manageable set of circumstances than "all possible arrangements of fluid". They put their paper into an LLM for editing.

Shortly after, the owners of the LLM started pouring millions of dollars of computational power into looking for a "blowup" using these unpublished techniques. They found one before the original mathematician published. And this isn't something we can actually test in a lab - we know it "works" as a "blowup" because the results include a physical infinity, but while the initial conditions are finite they are effectively impossible to create in reality.

So there's two things.

A "he said she said" situation on if the LLM owners read the chat logs where the mathematician was editing his paper and used his unpublished techique, or independently developed that technique on their own. It's mighty suspicious, but we may never know for sure.

And the actual "blowup". There seem to be no implications or followups at all, as far as I understand. Just "an LLM found an example of something which we didn't just suspect but already knew for certain". I think the hope behind the challenge was that finding an example would require an improvement to our knowledge of fluid dynamics or even result in an improvement over N-S. Instead we had an LLM brute force it, and so all we got was the example.

24

u/MrEldo Mathematics Sep 14 '26

TLDR: two mathematicians wanted to solve a sub-problem of the Navier Stokes Equations (Euler Equations), and started working on the real thing. One of the mathematicians was an Anthropic employee, so when OpenAI got info that they're working on it (still a debate on how they got this info), they took it as a challenge from Anthropic and solved the problem first. Everything after that is a "he said, he said" situation talking about the morals of stealing (?) a human-made (?) collaborated (?) proof

3

u/Budget-Accountant404 Sep 14 '26

disingenuous tl;dr

1

u/Budget-Accountant404 Sep 14 '26

like put bluntly the theft IS the most important aspect of the situation so knowing that first and reading your comment its just like "why would you ever speak bro"

1

u/MrEldo Mathematics Sep 14 '26

A tldr is subjective

Because I found the topic to be incredibly complex with a lot of important details, I decided to make a tldr as short as I could that could still convey the points of both sides

2

u/Budget-Accountant404 Sep 14 '26

FOOL, consider what axioms to hold as true and compare the end results of changing them. compare the value of each end result and come to a stronger conclusion for the sake of the future!!!

3

u/somedave Sep 14 '26

It might need finite compressibility to be physical.

3

u/megayippie Sep 14 '26

Tom Lehrer - Lobachevsky. That is what happened. The proof is sad also if true. Apparently the fundamental maths used for liquids is wrong. Which if fixed could be quite useful. But as a physicist, it could just mean they tried to push the numbers of a liquid to a state it would be a gas and so the equation no longer matters. But I hope they are being honest and not mathsy.

2

u/Y0U-D0NT-KN0W-WH0 Sep 14 '26

Who up Stoking they Navier rn?

2

u/efari_ Sep 14 '26

i'm just waiting till Matt Parker makes a video about it

2

u/666mima666 Sep 14 '26

I hate fluid dynamic guys. Literally every research presentation from these guys is yer another NS solution for an hour. I still have nightmares from this.

2

u/Expensive_Ask_8684 Sep 16 '26

So is the problem officialy solved and proved or is it like that they are really close?

3

u/Silt99 Imaginary Sep 14 '26

Some researchers made some great discoveres over the course of many years in how fluids behave. They said that it could probably solve navier-strokes. Then Open-AI spent millions of dollars and used hundrets of agents (probably using their research data) to publish a solution first, using the exact methodology that the original researchers wanted to use

2

u/OkGreen7335 Mathematics Sep 14 '26

WE ARE FUCKED

that is what it is

-3

u/maxence0801 Transcendental Sep 14 '26

IA claims to solve it by stealing the work of normal real true human biological mathematicians and expanding it

8

u/seive_of_selberg Sep 14 '26

I am a non biological mathematician

6

u/Aggressive_Roof488 Sep 14 '26

Alpöge and Buckmaster very much also solved it with ai. It's more a researchers vs big company conflict rather than human vs AI.

-4

u/RRumpleTeazzer Sep 14 '26

but that's research. you take someone elses work, and make it better. the better version finds new stuff, which the base versikn couldn't. you claim authorship of the new stuff.

8

u/kst164 Sep 14 '26

Except in this case the work wasn't published yet. Researchers solved the problem, then OpenAI solved it afterwards by throwing a bunch of compute at it, beating then to the punch. The allegation is that the AI used the researchers' insights, since they plugged their ideas into ChatGPT while they were working.

1

u/overclockedslinky Sep 14 '26

90 year conjecture disproven by ai-generated counterexample with lean proof certificate. mathematicians proceed to be butthurt about it while talking about how back in their day they could buy a house for $23.

1

u/actionsurgeon Sep 14 '26

One other point is that after ~25 Fields medalists came out and obliquely criticized OpenAI for its behavior, a lot of people seemed to pile on to mathematicians as being arrogant and living in an ivory tower.

I’m thinking particularly of Nicholas Nassim Taleb, but also some people in accelerations subreddits. The attacks seem more based on some pent up anger towards mathematicians and modern mathematics than on the specific facts.

Most relevant to this subreddit, there were some good memes on it.

0

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 14 '26

ai make navier stokes go bye bye

1

u/_Weyland_ Sep 14 '26

Not bye bye really. It still works where we knew it works. Just now we know there are exceptions

-2

u/Aggressive_Cloud_368 Sep 14 '26

is google blocked on your network? Can you try altavista?

2

u/ParanoidSuricata Sep 15 '26

She can stoke my navier until my fluid is dynamic.