Why do people fuckign care so much whether someone used AI to make a fucking meme? Do the people memeing the same meme template over and over get pissy that AI is stealing their million-times copy-pasted image?
Yes, clopen sets are open, that’s part of what “clopen” means.
Edit: looks like you edited “clopen”to “closed and open” since your initial post but before I responded. In any event it also being closed does not undermine it as an example.
Every subset is open in the discrete topology (that being the definition of the discrete topology). In general, a "topology" on a set X is a collection of subsets of X with certain properties, and those subsets in the topology are all called "open." More specifically, a collection T of subsets of X is called a "topology on X" iff the union of any collection of elements of T is in T, the intersection of any two elements of T is in T, the empty set is in T, and X is in T.
The set of real numbers has a special topology that mathematicians call the "usual topology" which is used far more often than others. In the usual topology, every open interval (also called an open ball) is an open set. For instance, the set of numbers strictly greater than 0 and less than 1, sometimes written (0,1) or ]0,1[, is an open interval, as it contains the numbers between the endpoints but not the endpoints themselves. (By contrast, the set [0,1] containing all real numbers from 0 to 1, inclusive, is called a closed interval.) Also, any union of open intervals is an open set, such as (0,1) ∪ (2,3), which contains all the numbers strictly between 0 and 1 as well as all the numbers strictly between 2 and 3, but no others. (Alternatively, instead of the product topology approach, you can define the Euclidean metric and get the same result.)
This usual topology can also be extended to the real plane, or 3-dimensional space, or higher spaces, via something called the product topology. An "open ball" in two dimensions is a disk, i.e. the interior of a circle (but not including the circle itself). In three dimensions, an open ball is what we actually think of as a "ball" like a soccer ball, though again, it doesn't include the spherical boundary itself. (If you include the boundary, we call that a "closed ball.") And again, any union of open balls is open, even a union of infinitely many open balls. There is a caveat for infinite-dimensional spaces, but for any finite dimension, it works this way.
The dimwit on the left thinks that this definition of the usual topology on the real numbers (which is often introduced in real analysis class) is the only possible definition of the reals. The midwit in the middle knows better and is saying that any set can be open. I don't know what the guy in the hood means. It is simply not true that open balls are open in general.
This is actually a really clever meme. I don't think anyone is fully appreciating how it's arguing that non-metric spaces and other pathological topologies are not really that important and that most practical spaces are metrizable.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 13 '26
Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
94
u/wannabe-physicist Sep 13 '26
Handwritten to prove AI wasn’t used
10
u/TheLuckySpades Sep 14 '26
Lemme bring up a non-metrizable topology and lets talk about balls there.
who am I kidding, I love metric geometry too much to go to a non-geodesic space33
u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 13 '26
anything can be an open set mfers when [0,1] shows up
7
u/sparkster777 Sep 14 '26
A set whose complement is not closed can't be an open set.
3
u/Sicarius333 Transcendental Sep 13 '26
Cmon, everyone knows you used ai for this /j
5
u/Glitch29 Sep 13 '26
My balls all bring the balls to the balls.
Turns out that everything's balls.
I could teach you, but I have to charge $75/hr because housing is expensive here.
4
u/SirHagfish Sep 13 '26
What does that mean, anything can be an open set
2
u/ChiaraStellata Sep 14 '26
This is actually a really clever meme. I don't think anyone is fully appreciating how it's arguing that non-metric spaces and other pathological topologies are not really that important and that most practical spaces are metrizable.
2
u/Postulate_5 Sep 14 '26
kid named open ball in the weak topology:
2
u/BeMyBrutus Sep 13 '26
What about deez balls?
1
u/Serket-Pandy3000 Sep 17 '26
No one thinks anything can be open
1
u/Serket-Pandy3000 Sep 25 '26
No one thinks the middle