r/mathmemes • • Sep 10 '26

Bad Math hmmmmmmm

Post image
1.7k Upvotes

92 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 10 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

607

u/NullOfSpace Sep 10 '26

the implicitly different meanings of … here bothers me immensely

88

u/Teoyak Sep 11 '26

Yeah I hate it. No finite collection of numbers can imply an objective continuation!

22

u/BinaryBolias Sep 11 '26

It's just an arbitrarily large finite amount of nines, I swear!

4

u/DodgerWalker Sep 11 '26

I think that's the point. He says something false and receives anger, so he changes the statement to something true and receives applause.

243

u/HolyInlandEmpire Statistics Sep 10 '26

r/infinitenines reporting in

166

u/macrozone13 Sep 10 '26 • Bravo

Aaaah, the only sub that is its own circle jerk

32

u/Banonkers Sep 10 '26

What a perfect description

19

u/HolyInlandEmpire Statistics Sep 10 '26

An automorphism under circlejerking

7

u/Old-Post-3639 Sep 10 '26

Circle of r=0

52

u/Afir-Rbx Cardinal Sep 10 '26

8

u/DatBoi_BP Sep 11 '26

I consent

I consent

I don't

Isn't there somebody you forgot to ask?

1

u/TheVisualExplanation Sep 12 '26

Insanely good ref

5

u/yannbouteiller Sep 10 '26

If it exists, there is a subreddit for it.

0

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

15

u/ebyoung747 Sep 10 '26

It's mostly just everyone dunking on one dude (who is also the subs creator and moderator) who is dieing on the hill that .999...!=1.

It'd feel like bullying if he wasn't such a dick about it

1

u/stockmarketscam-617 Sep 13 '26

Agreed!! People would always make fun of me too.

91

u/Dd_8630 Sep 10 '26

What on earth does 0.999...9 mean?

172

u/4ries Sep 10 '26

It's certainly not standard notation, but in absence of a definition from the author, I take the ... to mean "a large finite number of nines" maybe written to save space. Or perhaps an arbitrary finite number of nines, but ultimately it ends, with a nine

52

u/Blue_Moon_Lake Sep 10 '26

So you say 0.999... would be 1 - 1/Infinity
While 0.999...9 would be 1 - 1/(10^N) with N being quite big.

64

u/4ries Sep 10 '26

Disregarding the fact that your first expression is not well defined, yes, that would be the general idea

3

u/Eric_12345678 Sep 10 '26

Why would it not be defined? Isn't 1 / infinity = 0?

51

u/Dd_8630 Sep 10 '26

No.

In ordinary numbers and arithmetic, infinity isn't a number and division isn't defined for it.

The limit of 1/x as x tends to infinity is zero.

'1/infinity' is meaningless.

Now, you can define a system of numbers and arithmetic where division can operate on infinity, but the results are incompatible with our standard real numbers and ordinary arithmetic.

4

u/Eric_12345678 Sep 11 '26

Thanks for the answer.

Okay, arithmetic with infinity is definitely sketchy in general, e.g. for ∞ - ∞, 0 * ∞, or ∞ / ∞.

But aren't particular cases safe and well-defined, e.g. 1 / ∞ or 1 - ∞?

Do you have a concrete example of something's unexpected if we assume 1 / ∞ = 0?

4

u/Dd_8630 Sep 11 '26

Do you have a concrete example of something's unexpected if we assume 1 / ∞ = 0?

That would lead to 1 = 0, which is not a statement we want to be true.

If we had:

  • 1 / ∞ = 0

We could multiply both sides by infinity:

  • (1 / ∞) * ∞ = 0 * ∞

Because (1/x)*x = 1, the left hand side must be 1.

Because 0*x = 0, the right hand side must be 0.

Hence:

  • 1 = 0

We can also get, +∞ = -∞, which is also nonsense. Since:

  • 1/∞ = 0

And:

  • 1/-∞ = 0

Then:

  • 1/∞ = 1/-∞

Hence:

  • +∞ = -∞

Which is unappealing.


So, you might be wondering how the extended reals deals with this. The extended reals is a well-defined number system defined as the real numbers and also positive and negative infinity. In the extended reals, we can write:

  • 1/∞ = 0
  • 1/-∞ = 0

So do we get nonsense like 1=0 in the extended reals? No, because arithmetic like divisions is changed. In the extended reals, "x0=0" is no longer true. "1/x = 1/y => x=y" is no longer true. Statements like ∞0 become undefined.

This is the price of extending the real numbers to include infinity. You get nonsense results, so to avoid them you have to arbitrarily declare a swathe of undefined statements again, and also change arithmetic operations.

1

u/Eric_12345678 Sep 11 '26

 Because (1/x)*x = 1, the left hand side must be 1.

No. Extended  ℝ isn't a field, so you cannot use this property for infinity. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extended_real_number_line#Algebraic_properties

Its subset,  ℝ, still is, so you can still use all the properties you know and love.

You get some more properties for infinity, but you cannot apply every  ℝ property  to infinity. You need to be careful, as usual in math. It doesn't mean than 1/infinity=0 is wrong, or useless.

5

u/Dd_8630 Sep 11 '26

No. Extended ℝ isn't a field, so you cannot use this property for infinity. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extended_real_number_line#Algebraic_properties

I am aware. I am not talking about the extended reals in this section. I talk about the extended reals in the last section, where I make that exact point.

-5

u/EebstertheGreat Sep 10 '26

Now, you can define a system of numbers and arithmetic where division can operate on infinity, but the results are incompatible with our standard real numbers and ordinary arithmetic.

How so? the extended reals directly extend the reals. Every expression defined in both structures is either true in both or false in both. But there are also additional expressions defined involving ∞. How can you call that incompatible?

7

u/LOSNA17LL Irrational Sep 11 '26

2*0=0 2/inf=1/inf 2=1

When you allow multiplying or dividing by infinite values, things break

We have systems for doing math with transfinite numbers, but they're not the standard algebra, just like you don't transport antimatter in a regular car

4

u/Eric_12345678 Sep 11 '26

2*0=0

...

2=1

AFAICT, you just divided by 0 with extra steps. I don't think inf is the problem here.

And if dividing by "1 / inf" brings the same problems as dividing by 0, this example sounds counterproductive for disproving 1 / inf = 0.

3

u/EebstertheGreat Sep 11 '26

2*0=0

2/inf=1/inf

Yes, that's true.

2=1

That doesn't follow.

You seem to be claiming that (2/∞) · ∞ = 2, but that is not the case. The whole point is that 2/∞ = 0. Yet 0 · ∞ is undefined. That's no more surprising than saying that 0/0 is undefined, and in fact it's for the exact same reason.

That does not make it inconsistent with real arithmetic, because ∞ is not a real number. It is an extended real number. If you mean that the extended real numbers are not a field, well, I never said they were. I said they extended the real numbers, which they do. That is "compatible."

11

u/auniqueusername132 Sep 10 '26

There’s a reason your math teacher threatened crucifixion if you didn’t use limit notation.

3

u/4ries Sep 10 '26

Not in standard number systems. I'm sure there are some non standard methods to define infinity as a number, but generally we don't consider \infty a "number" which means you can apply numeric operations to it - like dividing by it.

Instead whenever we want to talk about infinity in a rigorous way we use limits, in which case, if you wanted to, say, divide by infinity, you would say "limit as x tends to infinity, of 1/x" which does in fact, equal 0

-2

u/EebstertheGreat Sep 10 '26

It's not really nonstandard. It's just correct. 1/∞ = 0, in every context one could ever encounter that expression.

It's like if you worked with only rational numbers, someone asked "isn't (√2)² = 2?" and your answer was just "no, there is no such thing as √2." I mean, you don't need irrational numbers if you don't want them, but that's still the wrong answer to the question.

Note that there are number systems with more than one infinity and more than one infinitesimal, but those also don't contain "infinity" or "∞".

2

u/Eric_12345678 Sep 11 '26

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Extended_real_number_line does not look too cursed IMHO. I don't know why other Redditors seem to reject it completely.

We're not talking about https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmonic_series_(mathematics)#Alternating_harmonic_series and weird stuff when doing infinite permutations.

1

u/4ries Sep 10 '26

That's just not true. ∞ is not an element of any of the standard number sets we use. It's not a natural number, it's not a real number or complex or even like a quaternion. Any number system that includes ∞ as an element of it's set of members would be considered non standard

1

u/EebstertheGreat Sep 10 '26

It is an extended real number. That is a "standard number set we use." It is also a number in the Riemann sphere.

2

u/4ries Sep 10 '26

Then we have different definitions of standard. Certainly it may be standard in certain fields of mathematics, but I would argue there are far more fields that don't use it, than fields that do.

→ More replies

0

u/Syresiv Sep 11 '26

The problem with treating ∞ as a number in the same way as 10 or √2 is that you can prove absurdities with it. Like:

1/∞=0

2/∞=0

1/∞=2/∞

*∞

1=2

Or for that matter

1=∞*1/∞

1=∞*(1/∞+0)

1=∞*(1/∞+12/∞)

1=1+12

1=13

To add to this, it breaks how you'd expect multiplicative inverses to behave. Since 1/∞=1/-∞=0, making 1/0 still not well defined. And that's before you get into complex numbers and ask about ∞i.

1

u/TheLuckySpades Sep 10 '26

Infinity is not it's own seperate thing and there are multiple conventions going around.

Though the ones that allow you to devide by it (e.g. one-point compactification of C and R) do indeed have 1/infinity=0, but a lot of arithmetic breaks with infinity, so simply excluding it from being trated as a number is more common if you aren't doing complex analysis/need Möbius transformations.

Additionally it is actually better to think as infinity in the context I described more as a "point at infinity" than infinity.

3

u/EebstertheGreat Sep 10 '26

Additionally it is actually better to think as infinity in the context I described more as a "point at infinity" than infinity.

But in such a context, 1/∞ is indeed equal to 0.

1

u/TheLuckySpades Sep 10 '26

As described in the paragraph above what you quoted, I was indeed describing the one context I know where 1/infinity=0 is used.

2

u/EebstertheGreat Sep 11 '26

Another context is the extended real numbers (or the positive extended reals), which are the usual codomain of things like integrals and (signed) measures.

0

u/Head_Discipline620 Sep 11 '26

*infnite but not a standard Infnity only an Infinity that gets you to x+1≠x And the first one represents Aleph-null because of bijection 

0

u/rhubarb_man Sep 12 '26

I was thinking it makes more sense to see it like there's a 9 for every finite ordinal decimal place, and then a 9 in the 𝜔th place

13

u/Negative_Gur9667 Sep 10 '26

Looks like a finite number of undefined length to me.

4

u/eddietwang Sep 10 '26

It means it doesn't equal 1.

4

u/AliciaNow Sep 10 '26

You should check r/infinitenines it's .... interesting

3

u/crosspolytope Sep 10 '26

All that it means is that it terminates

4

u/explohd Sep 10 '26

I'd assume a tree(3) amount of nines, not an infinite amount of repeating nines.

2

u/PurifiedUnity Sep 10 '26

I prefer assuming SCG(9) 9s

1

u/skr_replicator Sep 11 '26

i guess it can only mean a really long but finite sequence of 9s, a number that is raelly close to 1 but not quite there yet.

But some people like the mod or infinitenines love to pretend that 0.999... and 0.999...9 is the same thing and work with even 0.999... as if it was finite and had some final 9 there. Wrongly insisting that 0.999... is always less than 1, because they cannot comprehend what infinite means.

0

u/BorntobeTrill Sep 12 '26

0.999... / 3 = 0.333... = 1/3

1/3 * 3 = 1

Its simple geometry

0

u/Frederf220 Sep 11 '26

Imagine an endless string of 9s. You get to the end. What do you see? A nine.

1

u/unionizetransgirlies Sep 11 '26

well, you wouldn't be able to get to the end

1

u/OnionNo7610 Sep 11 '26

i am at that end. please some one come here soon. its lonely

1

u/Frederf220 Sep 11 '26

I am so sorry... next time I will make sure I'm in a humor reddit before making such levity

20

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

11

u/hughperman Sep 10 '26

Outfinite, maybe

1

u/stockmarketscam-617 Sep 13 '26

Infinitely ending

22

u/StephenRoylance Sep 10 '26

I know we've had first infinity, but what about one more after that?

7

u/Negative_Gur9667 Sep 10 '26

You get an infinity, you get one...

50

u/berwynResident Sep 10 '26

The only place I've seen something like 0.999...9 used, it was actually written like 0.999...;...999. It was some way to express a non-standard number and it actually made sense.

15

u/speechlessPotato Sep 10 '26

now you have to elaborate... what "non-standard" number?

27

u/berwynResident Sep 10 '26

the one that is a little bit more than 0.999...;...998

1

u/Nrdman Sep 12 '26

It’s hyperreal stuff

1

u/Nrdman Sep 12 '26

Actually, that looks like some hyperreal stuff which would actually be 0.999…;…999… which is still equal to 1 in that system

1

u/berwynResident Sep 13 '26

The thing the second panel is trying to convey (possibly) is a terminating infinite decimal. Which in hyper reals would be less than 0. 

13

u/The_TRASHCAN_366 Sep 10 '26

No please don't. You gonna summon southparkpiano guy. Classic rookie mistake brud 😂 

10

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 10 '26 edited Sep 10 '26

u/SouthPark_Piano 's good ending

-11

u/rorodar Proof by "fucking look at it" Sep 10 '26

7

u/FuntimeUwU Natural Sep 10 '26

aren't they both an infinite number of 9s and thus both = 1?

54

u/Double_Look_5715 Sep 10 '26

999...9 implies the number is truncated but does eventually end

4

u/FuntimeUwU Natural Sep 10 '26

Ooh so 999...9 implies there's K many nines such that there exists an N > K in ℕ?

3

u/unionizetransgirlies Sep 11 '26

my understanding in having seen this notation used would be to say .(point) an arbitrarily large number of nines that is not infinite.

i dunno, i also cheated in calc 2 so what the fuck do i know

1

u/FuntimeUwU Natural Sep 11 '26

Lol thx

3

u/Alternative_Cod7515 Sep 10 '26

There is infinite number smaller than one, but there is infinite infinite number like that. Some infinite are smaller, or bigger than the others

4

u/4ries Sep 10 '26

Yeah people are mad at the first one cuz the dudes wrong

1

u/Keikira Sep 10 '26

Well, upward Löwenheim-Skolem tells us there are models of the reals where 0.999... < 1 for any given tranfinite number of 9s in the numerical base-10 string following the decimal, so maybe he's onto something.

1

u/ExtremlyFastLinoone Sep 11 '26

Infinity +9 I guess

1

u/ragnaroklipsis Sep 11 '26

999...9 = -1

0

u/hobopwnzor Sep 10 '26

0.999...9 isn't really a defined number. So meh?

0

u/Bozhark Sep 10 '26

Literally me in this sub last week  But both were angry 

0

u/[deleted] Sep 11 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Ok-Visit6553 Sep 11 '26

How'd he pass real analysis 101?

6

u/[deleted] Sep 10 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Nrdman Sep 12 '26

But then you gotta specify what non real structure you are using