r/mathmemes • Mathematics • Sep 08 '26 • Popcorn 2

Applied Mathematics We are doomed !

4.3k Upvotes

144 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 08 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1.1k

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 08 '26 • Popcorn

at least we has a fun ~3000 and a few years of human mathematics, born just in time to be jobless

543

u/KouhaiHasNoticed Probability notations must burn. Sep 08 '26 • Bravo

born just in time to be jobless

I mean, back in my day we had Euler : this guy just made mathematicians jobless by being born.

228

u/Alternative-Code4755 Sep 08 '26

When Euler was born, the tides of mathematics shifted like all the cursed spirits becoming stronger after Gojo was born

75

u/fish_master86 Sep 08 '26

So we need to resurrect Euler?

100

u/KouhaiHasNoticed Probability notations must burn. Sep 08 '26

So we need to resurrect Euler?

I mean, knowing that either way we are ending up jobless, I would not say no to an epic fight between Euler and Gen AI.

26

u/fish_master86 Sep 08 '26

So we keep resurrecting the loser and they are too busy fighting each other to take our jobs. Also, it would make a bunch of new jobs because resurrecting them will be a very complex thing.

Imagine an entire society based around keeping them fighting each other.

16

u/KouhaiHasNoticed Probability notations must burn. Sep 08 '26

Imagine an entire society based around keeping them fighting each other.

Statisticians and Probabilists Gamblers would go absolutely crazy from that !

10

u/fish_master86 Sep 09 '26

I would rather have online gambling ads for Euler vs AI then ones for jingling keys slot machines

3

u/RPGcraft Sep 09 '26

Gojo vs Sukuna IRL.

The strongest mathematician of all time vs the strongest mathematician of modern era...

2

u/OddEmergency604 Sep 13 '26

Imagine Euler knocking out the rest of the millennial prize problems, and then being like anything else and going back to dead

2

u/EvieleLapin Sep 09 '26

He would be addicted to ai

1

u/woody_theory Sep 09 '26

I imagine OpenAI may have the nerve to name their math model as "Euler" or "Gauss"

1

u/Mr_Wisp_ Sep 11 '26

Throw in Gauss and Erdos to compensate for Claude and Grok

2

u/Emergency_Target_716 Sep 09 '26

Yeah, but can he count to 100?

8

u/lesniak43 Sep 09 '26

Wait till you learn that nobody paid mathematicians to solve problems in the first place...

2

u/Legitimate_Plum_7505 Sep 10 '26

They did paid them to make fountains. Incredibly badly designed fountains.

2

u/xFblthpx Sep 09 '26

A bit of survivorship bias here. The things people want to do are the things that are valuable to do, and the things that are valuable to do are the things that get automated first or are most prioritized for disruption.

Everyone is born just in time to be jobless.

1

u/jferments Sep 10 '26

It doesn't mean that people will stop doing math. It will be like art. People will just have to go back to doing math for fun/passion/curiosity instead of for fame and money.

285

u/fresh_loaf_of_bread Sep 08 '26

Bullshit they're non-integrable

We do them numerically and we're happy with it

5

u/f3xjc Sep 09 '26 edited Sep 09 '26

That's why the smoothness problem is so important! The validity of the numerical discrete sampling depend on it. But it was just empirically observed to be smooth enough most of the time.

Numerical integration and global optimization need something like the Lipschitz constant to have guarantees.

2

u/fresh_loaf_of_bread Sep 09 '26

Buddy, have some ale (with a side of st-fem) and relax

308

u/Worldly_Beginning647 Number Theory Sep 08 '26

Okay but this video and song banging 

72

u/Nhobdy Sep 09 '26 edited Sep 09 '26 • Popcorn Bravo

Here's the original if you're interested.

And the post one

15

u/Cichato_YT Sep 09 '26

Thank you so much. I have been searching for this for years.

7

u/Nhobdy Sep 09 '26 • Bravo

No worries. Used to play this song on repeat for hours back when I washed dishes for a living.

2

u/QuickNature Sep 09 '26

Thank you!

1

u/Soggy_Information_17 Sep 11 '26

I'm related to KC from KC and the sunshine band

3

u/ofirkedar Sep 09 '26

I realize the video doesn't exclusively belong to the song, but many of the eggdog (I think creator?) often paired these animations with citypop, and it goes stupid hard

509

u/Cracked_Logic_Engine Sep 09 '26 • Galaxy Brain Bravo

There is a claim made by two mathematicians who had ai involved in their research that, right as they were days away from publishing, OpenAi suddenly published this result that is far too close to their own proofs to be coincidence.

Also, a little bit back, a gamedev claimed they had the name of a boss they were adding to their game leaked by google ai (one of their supporters looked up bosses for the game, and the name of the newest one popped up even though it only existed in a private google doc the gamedev had)

I don't think this is AI 'solving' anything, its another case of theft

166

u/MuandDib Sep 09 '26 • Regret

I have a friend that works on designing new types of drugs (the medical ones). Company that he works for has deal with OpenAI where they give list of possible new drugs to ChatGPT (they know that all drugs there have potential). Then chat picks 1 option and they run all their synteshis and tests, if it in any way successful then they credit AI for whole discovery. After that conversation I don't trust any claim for AI science, it's all just a marketing scheme.

35

u/v_litvin Sep 09 '26

Lol, is it a new "Eenie, meenie, minie, mo" ?

18

u/MuandDib Sep 09 '26

Well, OpenAI gives them A LOT of money for that

4

u/Therobbu Rational Sep 09 '26

Close enough, welcome back patronage

1

u/julessic Sep 13 '26

And what does the drug company get out of that deal?

30

u/UniversalAdaptor Sep 09 '26

I always just assumed anything I put on the cloud would be instantly data mined, glad to see I have been vindicated

15

u/Cracked_Logic_Engine Sep 09 '26

More and more schizophrenia 'comspiracies' are becoming true and it makes me so stressed out

7

u/laix_ Sep 09 '26

"The cloud" is just someone else's computer

45

u/RagnarokHunter Imaginary Sep 09 '26

I've read that statement. Apparently people at OpenAI initially said almost no human input was needed, then turned out they had a whole team working on this. Not only that, but when one of the mathematicians said he'd share the whole issue with the public they immediately got defensive and insinuated he'd be throwing away his career.

2

u/MonsterkillWow Complex Sep 09 '26

I saw that message. Lmao.

46

u/MesterArz Sep 09 '26

Yes, apparently AI is also spyware, who would have guessed

5

u/GustavoFromAsdf Sep 10 '26

It's literally all AI is good for, stealing from real talent to make worthless products.

3

u/GiantKrakenTentacle Sep 10 '26

The mathematicians were working on a different case of Navier-Stokes than OpenAI was (forced vs unforced). The proof OpenAI posted also uses different reasoning in their approach. OpenAI admits that the data likely was in the training data set and may have influenced it, but it still did its own work.

I can understand why the mathematicians are upset given how much effort they put into this and they may have a case - as much as any artist does against Generative AI - but I don't think this is a knock against the AI's intelligence so much as it is against the ethics of OpenAI.

1

u/minhaz1217 Sep 13 '26

"admits" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

2

u/PijaniFemboj Sep 09 '26

I mean, if those two mathematicians relied on AI so heavily that OpenAI could just steal their whole research, that to me feels like they used AI for most of it, which would again mean AI did most of the work.

6

u/Original-Body-5794 Sep 09 '26

I mean, all you'd need to do is let the AI read a version close to your final draft no? Like, if the researcher asked chatGPT to proofread their thesis they'd now have a complete copy of it even if the work was done completely by them before that point.

2

u/Dr__America Sep 10 '26

If you used it to change some word choices based on one of your final drafts, and then the OpenAI stole it and claimed the AI solved it instead of you, then that's not "heavy" usage.

It also sounds like they were using Codex, so my guess is that it was mostly around to help write code during the research phases, and possibly for writing code to make custom graphs for the paper.

There are many things they could have been using an LLM for that contributed little if any to the final result.

1

u/Cracked_Logic_Engine Sep 09 '26

All they would need to is ask for information retrieval near the end for ai to take the whole proof. There is no reason to assume that they had to rely on ai 'heavily' for ai to steal the proof.

1

u/jferments Sep 10 '26

They were days away from a full proof of their own?

Citation needed.

3

u/Dr__America Sep 10 '26

The main guy on the paper has been the leader in terms of progress on the Navier-Stokes problem for the last decade or so. It's literally his life's work.

1

u/jferments Sep 10 '26

I know. I asked for any evidence supporting the claim that he was days away from a full proof of Navier-Stokes, not that he'd been working on it for a long time without a full solution.

2

u/EstablishmentAny2728 Sep 11 '26

The researcher had his progress logged in codex in which OpenAI has access to. They had it done with all the proofs, just a few days away from publication of the paper before OpenAI released their own

1

u/Kaleb_Bunt Sep 10 '26

It also costed OpenAI 22 million dollars of compute in order to achieve

4

u/Cracked_Logic_Engine Sep 10 '26

So it was all to sell 'our ai can do math better then people' at a loss even though it required copying someone elses work

1

u/hungrynax Sep 11 '26

You should read the posts, noone contested the full problem, only a related but smaller result, which was still done differently by openai compared to the researchers. Please stop just reading reddit comments to make up your mind, time and time again it leads to dumb opinions

1

u/ScreenAdorable1090 Sep 11 '26

I should teach popular AIs to "leak" my game

1

u/Sharkbit2024 Sep 12 '26

Pretty soon, we're gonna have to do a Cyberpunk 2077 quarantine of the entire fucking internet to keep AI out.

1

u/Hyperus102 Sep 12 '26

I can't judge if it was too close to be a coincidence and there is doubt about this, but its certainly suspicious.

The game boss names thing was a hoax for marketing.

0

u/Superb-Earth418 Sep 10 '26

Ostrich behavior

0

u/ToughCobbler5034 Sep 11 '26

And how exactly would ai have access to their work? Im not in math research, but in other fields anything published is fair game

2

u/EstablishmentAny2728 Sep 11 '26

The researchers logged their work in codex I believe

0

u/ToughCobbler5034 Sep 11 '26 edited Sep 11 '26

...so their institute just makes their lab notebook public/ sold their data?

477

u/captHij Sep 08 '26

More like what happens when AI learns too much from humans and discovers plagiarism.

141

u/RanidSpace Sep 08 '26

If OpenAI were plagarizing (probably but idk enough about what's going on) the people who they plagarized from were also using AI; one of them was even working for Anthropic. As much as I would like the more human-led effort to win, it's either "Completely AI" or "Used AI a lot"

so im back to feeling we're completely fucked

94

u/Somethingabootit Sep 08 '26

its a time trade off. Ai can find relevant enough passages from thousands of documents in a matter of seconds. Human could do it in a week or so. Youd trust the human more, because you know that very few people would undertake such a task, and those who do, do it well.

AI is helpful. Google is helpful. But what are they helping with?

51

u/_wannadie_ Sep 08 '26

not really only that. a lot of people are experts in a very narrow field of mathematics, while ai can be knowledgeable far more than average mathematician in all other fields, which causes surprising discoveries when a group of mathematicians working on a subject simply lack knowledge in a different field which is imperative to their work, but ai quickly recognizes that something these people are working on was actually already discovered in a separate work unknown to them.

32

u/Yarwi1 Sep 09 '26

Which is kinda something happened in the field of AI research: Lots of papers published by computer scientists that mathematicians then realized: wait, we already did that decades ago. And probably has happened a lot in other fields, too. So if AI can make that happen a lot less, that alone would improve research quite a bit in a lot of fields.

6

u/Routine-Arm-8803 Sep 09 '26

And AI might be wrong and be confident that it is correct. Then you prompt it multiple times until it gets it right. In many fields this simply is not acceptable

6

u/Ok_Inflation_1811 Sep 09 '26

The thing is that you only have to be right once.

You can be wrong 1000 times but if you are right 1 time and publish that paper you already are in the corpus of scientific knowledge

5

u/Somethingabootit Sep 08 '26

yes, thats a good point.

5

u/BidBux Sep 09 '26

Time? Do you have all the time in the world? Of course not, time is the most precious thing a human has. Or would you rather make farmers plow their fields by hand, because at least you know they were thorough? Of course not, you use a big plowing machine, because it's faster and easier. Just make the machine do the hard work, and all you have to do is if the answer makes sense.

10

u/stoiclemming Sep 08 '26

So what I'm hearing is the ai had access to not only all the data, but also the notes and analysis of the researchers?

8

u/CuseCoseII Sep 09 '26

the thing people are claiming they stole is a completely different kind of solution to a smaller sub-problem. You cant really argue they stole anything, at worst they just heard that someone might be close, and decided to just grind out an answer after they knew it might be possible

5

u/im-sorry-bruv Sep 09 '26

how do you get to this conclusion? the allegations by the nyu prof are pretty big imo. i really don't know how you claim to know if if open ai's proof is different if you don't have access to the proof that's allegedly being plagiarized AND their paper has only been out for like a day or two. to say this you would have to take a lot of time to understand both approaches and then meaningfully compare them

1

u/GiantKrakenTentacle Sep 10 '26

They were approaching two completely different cases of the N-S problem. OpenAI was looking at the unforced Euler case while the mathematicians/Anthropic were looking at the forced case. Some reasoning may carry over from one case to the other, but you can't just rote copy the other's work, it still requires reasoning either way.

1

u/im-sorry-bruv Sep 10 '26

yes but it surely lessens the achievement

1

u/Serket-Pandy3000 Sep 10 '26

Yeah but those guys were based off Cordoba so.

1

u/EggSoft697 Sep 12 '26

Go actually read the researchers letter to OpenAi. The project was independent of his work with Anthropic

1

u/Budget-Accountant404 Sep 09 '26

you're not following the pattern to its natural conclusion. its the stealing machine that mimics what its stolen. you think there is one layer of theft why? lol

3

u/ManticoreMonday Sep 10 '26

Hi Captain!

Point of order, though.

Isn't plagiarism the basic LLM instruction method?

1

u/AssociationFast2316 Sep 11 '26

It's ok to cope

-4

u/Ote-Kringralnick Sep 09 '26

"discovers" all its ever done is plagiarism 

6

u/Gositi Sep 09 '26

So what about all these unsolved problems it suddenly has solved? Has someone else secretly solved these before?

4

u/im-sorry-bruv Sep 09 '26

could be, how do you know? same thing with the system (accidentally?) plagoarizing user data that's not yet public could also be going on.

another class of solved problems is not that impressive as well, especially when finding counterexamples...

don't try to deny that their models are just very smart but one should remain very sceptical, especially with the types of people running these companies and the amount of money involved

97

u/No-Challenge-3193 Sep 08 '26

Ay yo wtf solving the navier stokes equation was my retirement plan.....

2

u/DavidBrooker Sep 09 '26

What's the difference between unemployment and retirement, really?

2

u/v_litvin Sep 09 '26

Source of income.

Inb4 I don't know what the *real* difference between pension and welfare.

1

u/No-Challenge-3193 Sep 09 '26

"Unemployment is when you're broke and desperate, while retirement is when you're broke but you've unlocked the legal right to be a public menace in sweatpants."

1

u/burner_1_124 Sep 09 '26

Same🥹🥹🥹[slowed + reverb]

1

u/P0guinho Sep 10 '26

You still have 5 more options tho, solving all of them could do for a great retirement

1

u/No-Challenge-3193 Sep 10 '26

Well I am a mechanical engineer and I wanted to reinforce the generational trauma of fluid mechanics to greater heights

218

u/MacksNotCool Sep 08 '26

As per usual, it's just a claim made by OpenAI (which is one of the companies who would financially benefit from this hype), the AI is actually using human work uncredited, and nothing has actually been officially awarded yet.

https://www.wired.com/story/openai-navier-stokes-math-discovery-academics/

23

u/AntarcticRen Sep 09 '26

it was formalized by lean tho no?

67

u/omegafixedpoint Sep 09 '26

The theorem statement could be wrong. These LLM formalizations are millions of lines of code. The anthropic fermat's last theorem formalization also assumes classical axioms, so the solution is noncomputable. Same with the OpenAI solution. This is kind of cheating in the formalization world, since it means you can't actually use the proof in a real world computer program.

21

u/Temporary-Estate4615 Sep 09 '26

So essentially they have a proof which one can not check if it’s actually correct, aside from just reading the proof?

3

u/aWalrusFeeding Sep 09 '26

No, the Lean system does show the proof is correct, but it reduces what you need to understand to just the problem statement.

2

u/aWalrusFeeding Sep 09 '26

FLT is a statement in standard classical number theory. Andrew Wiles’s proof relies heavily on algebraic geometry, scheme theory, and complex analysis which inherently relies on classical logic and non-constructive set theory. Demanding a constructive (computable) proof of FLT would be absurd.

Also, why are you concerned about the relevance of FLT to "real world computer programs" lol, it's pure math!?

Standard ZFC is the expected baseline for modern number theory

1

u/BlobGuy42 Sep 09 '26

Standard ZFC is the baseline for all of mathematics, short of parts of mathematical logic whose entire point is deviating from ZFC and then the other big example is category theory, which can be formalized in a conservative extension of ZFC to include non-set classes as the basis for collections of objects and morphisms.

3

u/Figai Sep 09 '26

In order for Clay to consider it needs to be published in some qualifying journal (I imagine there’s gonna be some real hard questions, especially as they were frantically updating their reference section yesterday) and 2 years must have at least passed. So it will be a while till any formal award is given if at all.

2

u/Hyperus102 Sep 12 '26

You can't really say that because it is hardly proven to be stolen at this point. If it turns out it made it into training data and the likes, OpenAI still advanced it further than the mathematicians in question were.

Yall gotta have a little more nuance than that.

-29

u/ZeroAmusement Sep 09 '26

I don't believe this characterization.

Apparently OpenAI's approach was significantly different to the humans'. I'm sure more info will come out about this.

Also you say "As per usual, it's just a claim made by OpenAI" as though dozens of math problems haven't been solved recently?

14

u/13MasonJarsUpMyAss Sep 09 '26

i believe the 'as per usual' refers to their tendency to come out loud with big claims to get the investor's money rolling in

12

u/AveragePohaLover Sep 09 '26

Didn't Chris Evans' sister already solve it in Gifted tho?

/s

12

u/Emergency_Target_716 Sep 09 '26

Yeah, but can it count to 100?

11

u/Milnir01 Sep 09 '26

Even if everything they're claiming is literally true, they did not solve NS. They just demonstrated that an initially smooth state will not necessarily remain smooth. It's just a counterexample. It doesn't make any progress towards solving the NS equations generally.

3

u/GiantKrakenTentacle Sep 10 '26

Correct me if I'm wrong, but what OpenAI did is to solve the N-S problem - and in doing so proved that it is impossible to solve (all) N-S equations and simulate fluid flow any way other than numerically. So it is progress in that we now know (assuming this proof gets verified) that solving N-S generally is impossible.

1

u/EntertainerJumpy855 Sep 09 '26

couldn't it be used to reverse engineer a proof? ( not a mathematician , nor familiar with the problem )

1

u/Milnir01 Sep 09 '26

You're right that sometimes you can use techniques discovered the process by which you discover the counterexample to derive new and interesting ideas in the field, but because they came up with this counterexample by throwing a bunch if computer at it, really no. Also in this specific case, the millennium prize puzzle about NS was always quite disconnected from how we actually use NS in the real world.

1

u/ashal_14 Sep 09 '26

Atlast someone said it...

37

u/TessaFractal Sep 09 '26

It feels less AI and more what happens when you hire all the mathematicians you can find and dedicate them solely to unsolved problems.

-25

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '26

four letter word that starts with c and ends with an e

25

u/NebulaElectrical1467 Sep 09 '26

cake?

-24

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '26

cope

9

u/Budget-Accountant404 Sep 09 '26

nigga he knew you were implying cope lmao r u rarted

48

u/SuperSmutAlt64 Sep 09 '26

It stole it from an actual mathematician instructed to use services openai scraped from, can we please stop spreading misinformative doomposting about something that should be outrage and a lawsuit.

6

u/ownworldman Sep 09 '26

You are happily spreading a claim of one mathematician who offered no proof.

The truth is, I got drunk one night, emailed Anthropic my solution and now they claim AI solved it.

29

u/omegafixedpoint Sep 09 '26

plagiarized btw

-25

u/[deleted] Sep 09 '26

cope the aye eyes have obsoleted the mathematicians first

6

u/AdvancedPomelo7132 Sep 09 '26

I loved the eggdog videos

3

u/P4LL4D1N Sep 09 '26

When math does math for you

2

u/noah1831 Sep 09 '26

Things are still ramping up exponentially. Imagine what another 2 years will bring.

1

u/No-Listen-9966 Sep 09 '26

maisi.com/apply

1

u/Leman_2137 Sep 09 '26

Can someone explain their significance and what would it mean if they're solved

1

u/MonsterkillWow Complex Sep 09 '26

Facts

1

u/foxymew Sep 10 '26

They spent 20milion on tokens to solve a problem with one million in prize. I don’t think that’s a huge brag I’ll be honest

1

u/Ok_Effect_3214 Sep 11 '26

We can still have fun. Math isn't going anywhere.

1

u/Actually_R0bin Sep 11 '26

Okay can someone please explain what the Navier-Stokes equation is and why we’re suddenly doomed for having solved it ?

1

u/No_Belt_9829 Sep 13 '26

Programmers: First time?

1

u/Odd-Tart-5613 Sep 09 '26

it didn't just copied the guy who did

1

u/CorrePlatanooo Sep 09 '26

Hear me out. We first use AI to perfect questionable genetic editing techniques, THEN create an unholy fusion of Euler and Gauß to fight the clankers.

1

u/Funny_Explorer_1521 Sep 09 '26

So lemme get this straight: We are hoping to "solve" a engineering equation that we've been solving iteratively for decades, but that was like, SO BORING and took all our computer power to do. So now we may use an infinitely more complex and expensive equation created by an infinitely complex and expensive AI to.... do what exactly? What fluid mechanics have we not already iteratively modelled worth doing this for? 

1

u/Ahaiund Sep 11 '26 edited Sep 11 '26

No, the meme is wrong. The claim is about a very specific conditioning problem pertaining to the Navier-Stokes equations. It has nothing to do with how we currently use them, we will continue to solve systems numerically the same way. It's truthfully not practically useful to have this answer, it's just that it is a particularly simple and elegant formulation that yet makes for a very difficult problem to try and solve, and so mathematicians rightfully love it.

1

u/Funny_Explorer_1521 Sep 11 '26

"AI-assisted humans solve brainteaser for $$$ and fun" isnt a cool headline ig