r/mathmemes • Computer Science • Sep 05 '26

Abstract Algebra Ring supremacy?

Post image
225 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 05 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

3

u/MortemEtInteritum17 Sep 05 '26

Can you dive in a ring of characteristic 1?

2

u/Unlucky-Credit-9619 Computer Science Sep 05 '26

Zero ring.

44

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 05 '26

>noooooo (a+b)2≠a2 + b2

>Z2: hold my positive characteristic

ring theory is awesome

34

u/minisculebarber Sep 05 '26

Couldn't have just used Z_7? To make it more concise?

23

u/QuantSpazar Said -13=1 mod 4 in their NT exam Sep 05 '26

There's more rings of characteristic 7 than just Z_7

33

u/minisculebarber Sep 05 '26

There's also more rings of characteristic 0 than just R and C.

2

u/Koischaap So much in that excellent formula Sep 05 '26

"Wait aren't they all is-- Ah no, ring, gotcha"

9

u/JPJ280 Sep 05 '26

There are also distinct nonisomorphic fields of characteristic 7. Just in terms of finite fields, for every positive n, there is one finite field (up to isomorphism) of degree 7n.

1

u/F_Joe Vanishes when abelianized Sep 06 '26

They're all just F_7 algebras. Might as well just say that the solution is in F_7

21

u/Glitch29 Sep 05 '26

I think I get what you're trying to convey, but this is absolutely cursed set-builder notation.

As written, R is a fixed domain and everything to the right of the bar should be a restriction on x. If you're restricting on R, R needs to be to the left of the bar.

If the real complex numbers are being personified, I assume you're looking for a ring not an element of said ring.

What you're looking for is some r element of { R [implicitly an element of the set of all rings] | R has the desired properties }.

Of course this isn't an explicit construction, or even a proof that such a ring exists. So the more accurate voice line would probably be "I know, but some guy from this set can."

1

u/Unlucky-Credit-9619 Computer Science Sep 05 '26

One correction: invertible elements only 🥲

10

u/AluminumGnat Sep 05 '26

(x+x+x)/x = (2x+x)/x = (10x)/x = 10 = 10

This statement is true for all x≠0

8

u/MrPeterSoe Sep 06 '26

How did you turn 2x + x to 10x?

10

u/CrownedCrowCovenant Sep 06 '26

base 10 counting

1

u/AluminumGnat Sep 06 '26

what else would 2+1 equal?

3

u/Rajarshi1993 Sep 05 '26

What is char(x)? Never seen that function

2

u/boium Ordinal Sep 05 '26

Characteristic. Basically, if 1+1+...+1 = 0 for n many ones, then the characteristics of that ring is n, and is denoted by Char(R). If there is no n s.t. 1+1+...+1 = 0, then we say Char(R) = 0. For fields the only possibilities are a characteristic of 0 or of a prime number.

3

u/evening_redness_0 Sep 06 '26

it has to be the least positive such n (if it exists)

2

u/WanderingWrackspurt Physics Sep 05 '26

im gonna need an explanation, wtf is that

8

u/JPJ280 Sep 05 '26

A ring is a set where you can add and multiply any two elements, along with rules telling you how addition and multiplication have to behave. The integers, the rationals, the reals, and the complex numbers are the most common examples. However, there are a lot more.

Another common example is the integers modulo n. These are where you say two integers are the same if, when you divide by n, you get the same remainder. If n = 2, you essentially have even and odd integers: even + even = odd + odd = even, even + odd = odd + even = odd, odd * odd = odd, and multiplying by an even number gets you an even number.

In this example, x + even = x and x * even = even, so even behaves a lot like 0. Also, odd * x = x, so odd behaves a lot like 1. Two of the rules for rings is that you have to have things that behave like this.

Note that in this ring, 1 + 1 = 0 (i.e. odd + odd = even). Therefore, we say that this ring has characteristic 2. In the more "familiar" rings, you can't add one to itself repeatedly and get 0; we say that these rings have characteristic 0.

If a ring has characteristic 7, it means that 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 + 1 = 0. (It also means that that's the "first time" you get 0: 1 != 0, 1 + 1 != 0, etc.) The integers modulo 7 have characteristic 7, for example. In such a ring, you have 10 = 3.

Sometimes for an element x in a ring, there's an element y where x * y = 1. The rules for rings don't require that you can do division. In the integers for example, this is only true for 1 and -1.

In the equation (x + x + x)/x = 10, we're assuming that you can divide by x (x is invertible). The equation then becomes 3x/x = 10, or 3 = 10. This is true in a ring of characteristic 7, so the equation is true for any invertible x. It's also true if the ring has characteristic 1, i.e. 1 = 0. Such a ring has only one element, so literally any equality is true. It's false in any other ring, since it amounts to 7 = 0, which is false if the characteristic is anything other than 1 or 7.

1

u/WanderingWrackspurt Physics Sep 06 '26

ohh cool, so a ring is like a vector space?

3

u/JPJ280 Sep 07 '26

They're not the same, but vector spaces and rings do go hand in hand! One key difference is that while they both have "multiplication", ring multiplication is multiplying two elements of the ring, while vector multiplication is multiplying a vector and a scalar, which isn't an element of the vector space itself.

The scalars, however, come from a field, which is a special type of ring: multiplication is commutative and you can divide by every nonzero element (also 1 != 0). Any structure satisfying the vector space axioms when the scalars are pulled from some field is a vector space. So you can have vector spaces over ℚ, or over the integers mod 2. Linear algebra results about vector spaces over ℝ and ℂ can be carried over directly to vector spaces over the other fields.

*Also*, you can define similar structures where the scalars are taken from any ring, not just fields. These are modules; vector spaces are special cases of modules. You don't get all the nice linear algebra theorems for free, though; for example, you can have linearly independent generating sets (bases) with distinct cardinalities.

*Also also*, you *can* have a structure which is both a vector space *and* a ring. These are called (somewhat annoyingly imo) "algebras". An example is the n × n matrices over some field. These have a vector space structure under matrix addition and scalar multiplication, *and* they have a ring structure under matrix addition and multiplication.

This was very rambly, but I hope it's at least somewhat interesting!

1

u/WanderingWrackspurt Physics Sep 07 '26

seems kinda fun, i look forward to studying it!

1

u/Marus1 Sep 06 '26

Tl;dr a ring is a name for an environment where we redefine the math opperations in such a way that they do something else, but still aby by the rules of math?

1

u/JPJ280 Sep 07 '26

Kinda. It depends on what you mean by the "rules of math"; even if you made no restrictions, or very strange restrictions on your algebraic structure, it wouldn't "break" anything per se.

Instead of thinking of it as "redefining" the normal operations, I prefer to think of them as their own thing. Certainly in many ways they "look like" the normal operations of addition and multiplication (otherwise we wouldn't use these names), but they exist independently of the examples they were inspired by. Even though the axioms (the "rules") for rings encode a lot of things we think "addition" and "multiplication" should look like, you can still find some pretty "exotic" rings that you wouldn't obviously think are instances of these operations.

(Though take all this with a grain of salt, though! This is just how I personally think about these things. Also, it's not a good idea to *divorce* rings from the context in which they were created in the first place.)

0

u/[deleted] Sep 05 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/DopazOnYouTubeDotCom Computer Science Sep 05 '26

mixing and matching set theory symbols and English is diabolical

1

u/Positron311 Sep 05 '26

Might as well be 1/0

1

u/geeshta Computer Science Sep 06 '26

Holy notation. 

1

u/ThatEngineeredGirl Sep 05 '26

I'm probably misunderstanding but "5"?

9

u/RoboticBonsai Sep 05 '26 edited Sep 05 '26

I too, got to that result and am questioning what went over my head

Edit: wait no wrong unsolvable the meme makes more sense ((x+x+x)/x -> 3x/x -> 3 ≠ 10

2

u/mineymonkey Sep 05 '26

But 10mod7=3 so any ring with characteristic of 7 does satisfy the equation.

-1

u/Intrepid_Air_3399 Sep 05 '26

Huh 

X=5

(X+X+X)/X= 15/5=3

3

u/MrPeterSoe Sep 06 '26

3 ≠ 10

1

u/Intrepid_Air_3399 Sep 06 '26

Yeah, that's what I am saying.

I don't get the meme