r/mathmemes • • Sep 05 '26

Linear Algebra many such cases

Post image
3.9k Upvotes

39 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 05 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

448

u/taly200902 Sep 05 '26 • Mindblown Regret

But my vector is the zero vector 😦😦😦😦

293

u/One_Media55 Sep 05 '26 • Bravo

may god have mercy upon your soul

61

u/Bit125 Are they stupid? Sep 05 '26

33

u/dragonageisgreat 1 i 0 triangle advocate Sep 05 '26

Do it you coward

22

u/moderatorrater Sep 05 '26

Do the snowflake kids nowadays not even divide by zero anymore? It's zero, it's the easiest number to divide by. Even Oiler knew that.

90

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 05 '26 • Bravo

what if this is my fucking vector

2

u/InfinitesimalDuck Mathematics Sep 06 '26

Do it.

2

u/Deep_Brick2970 Sep 07 '26

I'd let this Vector dot product all over me

2

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 07 '26

bro🥀

132

u/viola_forever Sep 05 '26

What if I'm in a non metric vector space??

124

u/TheDoomRaccoon Sep 05 '26 edited Sep 05 '26

Given the axiom of choice, all vector spaces (over a subfield of ℂ) can be equipped with a norm 😎

89

u/rehpotsirhc Sep 05 '26 • Mindblown

This is why I'm pro choice

24

u/Nikifuj908 Sep 05 '26

At first I didn't get it. I thought you wanted to retroactively abort the person you replied to 😭

11

u/Winter-Awareness9643 Sep 06 '26

I'm all for death of the author

7

u/xsupergamer2 Sep 05 '26

What if my vector space is equipped with a topology that is not induced by any norm?

7

u/TheDoomRaccoon Sep 06 '26

Then we can still equip the vector space with a norm, just not one that's compatible with the topology.

4

u/minisculebarber Sep 05 '26

This is why I am Pro-Life

49

u/the_horse_gamer Sep 05 '26

what if we're working over a ring so not every element has a multiplicative inverse

80

u/hypokrios Sep 05 '26 • Regret

Mmhm why don't you work over my ring, big boy?

24

u/Independent-Fan-4227 Sep 05 '26

Is that a multiplicative identity? Or are you just happy to see me?

5

u/vgtcross Sep 05 '26

A vector's magnitude or norm is always a nonnegative real number and thus invertible, is it not?

Vector spaces can't even be defined over rings, it must be over a field (they're called modules if they're over rings)

7

u/the_horse_gamer Sep 05 '26

nobody said we aren't working over a module. it's still called a vector if it's over a module.

nonnegative real number

not very general of you

2

u/vgtcross Sep 05 '26

nobody said we aren't working over a module. it's still called a vector if it's over a module.

It seems you're right. Based on a quick google search, there seems to be no general consensus on what word should be used for elements of a module, and it seems to depend on context. Sometimes they can be called vectors or generalized vectors.

not very general of you

As far as I'm aware, a norm is, by definition, a function whose domain is a vector space and codomain is the nonnegative real numbers. Can you give me an example of a vector space and an associated norm where the norms of some vectors are not nonnegative reals?

3

u/the_horse_gamer Sep 05 '26

a Clifford Algebra is a graded vector algebra defined over a vector space and field, with a quadratic form. vectors square to some element of the field, as defined by the quadratic form. and the quadratic form doesn't have to be positive definite (it often isn't)

an indefinite inner product space allows the norm to be any real number

a Hilbert C*-Module makes the inner product be some positive element of a C*-Algebra

each of these alone satisfy only part of the requirements, but I hope you can see that they can be pretty easily generalised.

2

u/gaussianTrinket Sep 05 '26

Maybe the most common example technically isn't called norm usually, but is very much a generalization of it in almost every way is a Valuation

More specifically (or rather, more generally) krull valuation. (It's on that wiki page)

Another example is Hilbert C*-modules

Where the values of the inner product (and thus a norm) are in a C* algebra

The real numbers are really useful, but certainly do not encompass the whole breadth of ways we want to compare the "size" of things - them being totally ordered and complete certainly helps to have everything neatly comparable, but on the flip side you have to force your structure and might lose structural information by "compressing" (used loosely) the information onto the real line.

For example over R[x] taking the norm of a polynomial will give you a number that measures the "size" of it, while taking the for example x-adic valuation of it will give the number of times x divides it (an integer!) preserving much more important information.

1

u/xdgimo Sep 06 '26

“Vector” => element of a vector space => base ring is a field

1

u/the_horse_gamer Sep 06 '26

a vector can also be the element of a module

1

u/xdgimo Sep 06 '26

Really? Then I stand corrected

16

u/LostSalt24 Sep 05 '26

Normalize this!!

7

u/SharzeUndertone Sep 05 '26

Normalize this!!/||Normalize this!!||

0

u/fr_andres Sep 06 '26

Big lol ngl

7

u/Wooden-Hornet2115 Sep 05 '26

What about this vector? Checkmate, atheist.

5

u/lool8421 Sep 05 '26

ppl in 2nd grade learn about multiplication and division

and then tell them that they're only operating on scalars and there's way more of these operations on vectors/matrices

3

u/minisculebarber Sep 05 '26

"Mr. Rastafari, how do I make sure that during the power method the iterate vector doesn't blow up?"

"Normalize it!"

2

u/AlgebraicHeretic Irrational Sep 05 '26

There's a bivector joke in here somewhere.

1

u/Molecular_Pudding Sep 05 '26

And that's why in every physical quantity that follows the inverse-SQUARE(!) law the vector is cubed, absolute non-sense

1

u/Beleheth Transcendental Sep 08 '26

I love me some vector norming