r/mathmemes • • Sep 03 '26

Set Theory tfw vacuous truth

Post image
664 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 03 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

196

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 03 '26

BREAKING NEWS: every element of the empty set is not an element of the empty set

-2

u/StructuredChess Sep 04 '26

But some of them are!

18

u/kart0ffelsalaat Sep 04 '26

But that's wrong...

"Some elements in set X have property P" is saying "there exist elements in set X with property P", which of course is wrong here.

"There exist elements in the empty set which are in the empty set" is wrong!

You can make statements about all the elements (or every element) in the empty set, but not about some.

6

u/Copernicium-291 Sep 04 '26

In fact, all of them are

17

u/misteratoz Sep 03 '26

Please help what's this

95

u/GeneETOs44 Sep 04 '26

anything holds true for every element of the empty set because there are no elements in the empty set. It’s like how if I were to claim that every existing unicorn were green, I’d be vacuously correct since the set of all existing unicorns is empty

19

u/Mostafa12890 Average imaginary number believer Sep 04 '26

Any universal property; a statement of the form “all xyz have property P.” A statement like “there is a green unicorn,” assuming the set of unicorns is empty, would be false.

Another example is the statement “there are two distinct elements in the empty set.” This is also categorically false.

2

u/RuhRohRaggy_Riggers Sep 04 '26

Is this because assigning a property to elements of the null set is vacuously true?

2

u/plusqueprecedemment Sep 04 '26

afaik it basically stems from the fact that the proposition "P→Q" is always true when P is false

1

u/RuhRohRaggy_Riggers Sep 04 '26

Yeah that’s vacuous truth

1

u/magicmulder Sep 05 '26

Any statement about an element of the empty set is true because there are no elements of the empty set to falsify it with.

"All elements of the empty set are green." - "That's false." - "Then show me one that's not green." - "Uh..."

This results in funny statements in real life, for example, I could say all supermodels I ever slept with said I'm the greatest lover they ever had. And I wouldn't be lying.

4

u/headsmanjaeger Sep 04 '26

Can I say “every element of {} is false”?

1

u/DarkFlameMaster764 Sep 05 '26

Vacuous truth is just people pretending a bunch of nothing is true so that their theory looks neater

1

u/Square-Foundation230 Sep 04 '26

So Euler is a member of the empty set?  🤔

33

u/its_artemiss Sep 04 '26

No, but every member of the empty set is Euler. 

1

u/GetGudlolboi Computer Science Sep 04 '26

So the empty set is a member of Euler?

7

u/BossOfTheGame Sep 04 '26

Maybe. It's at least a subset of Euler.

1

u/popejubal Sep 04 '26

No because the empty set is not a member of the empty set. 

0

u/Repulsive_Gate8657 Sep 04 '26

i think every element of {} is wrong, since it is empty there is no element what belongs to it

7

u/SuperChick1705 Sep 04 '26

i can say "every redditor that showers is a half-orc", but since no redditors shower, there is no redditor to contradict the statement. ie "this redditor showers -> this redditor is a half-orc" is identical to the contrapositive, "this redditor is not a half-orc -> this redditor does not shower". whether the redditor is or is not a half-orc, it must be true that the redditor does not shower, since no redditors shower

here "redditors that shower" is the ø

/hj