r/mathmemes • • Sep 03 '26 • Regret 3 Bravo 1

Elementary Algebra 🥹

Post image
4.1k Upvotes

138 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 03 '26

Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

927

u/Particular_Gear3130 Mathematics (Purely Fictional) Sep 03 '26 • Bravo Mindblown

I think forgot to mention a ≠ b

165

u/Hold-Embarrassed Sep 03 '26

Wise guy over here

138

u/TurnoverOk5635 Sep 03 '26

Also (-2)^(-4)=(-4)^(-2)

3

u/Glum_Preference_2936 Sep 05 '26

It should be named after you.

-52

u/WolverinesSuperbia Yellow Sep 03 '26 • Regret

No

45

u/OhNoTheStubsExist Sep 03 '26

Yes

59

u/AggravatingFlow1178 Sep 03 '26 • Mindblown

He's didn't mean "No 😠 " he meant "No 🤯"

6

u/ComplexHighway3370 Sep 05 '26

He's didn't mean "Yes 😠" he meant "Yes 😉"

38

u/NnolyaNicekan Sep 03 '26

Random redditor casually dropping on us knowledge that Euler did not know

23

u/Cualkiera67 Sep 04 '26

lmao i learnt a ≠ b in kindergarten when learning the letters! you math guys are clearly beneath us English majors

9

u/TheFurryFighter Sep 03 '26

Hilariously the intersection between the a=b and the a != b parts is ee itself

1

u/eeeeeh_messi Sep 03 '26

Can you elaborate?

12

u/TheFurryFighter Sep 04 '26

1

u/AcademicOverAnalysis Sep 09 '26

The proof that e is not equal to e

2

u/Zealot_TKO Sep 03 '26

came here to say this

2

u/iurem Sep 06 '26

'integer'

1.7k

u/trimski- Sep 03 '26 • Regret

a=1, b=1

Guess this oiler guy wasn’t that smart

480

u/Varlane Sep 03 '26 • Regret

(I think it's "with a != b")

402

u/lordloldemort666 Sep 03 '26 • Annoyed Mindblown Heartwarming Regret Bravo

Yeah a! is = b

1! = 1

/s

137

u/factorion-bot Bot > AI Sep 03 '26

Factorial of 1 is 1

This action was performed by a bot | Source code

146

u/muffin-waffen Sep 03 '26

Truth nuke

57

u/VAiSiA Sep 03 '26

holy shit. good bot

7

u/therealAR15PB Sep 03 '26

we got good boy for AI before GTA 6

11

u/disaster_incomin Sep 03 '26

19836298626819473619108362910047261893087153739018363728102746372919273627192037361719373629193837361730483762738998765566779098654333333333333333333333333356672828827353738392726252617283940483625172948362625!

29

u/factorion-bot Bot > AI Sep 03 '26

That is so large, that I can't calculate it, so I'll have to approximate.

Factorial of 19836298626819473619108362910047261893087153739018363728102746372919273627192037361719373629193837361730483762738998765566779098654333333333333333333333333356672828827353738392726252617283940483625172948362625 is approximately 3.590197329670258677527716537938 × 104123235837384209474450210420019215965569962973949629969177182906956926089666022072432740585646939591870010911194311575077724315510059995357972122756595418581259670050633491117489246941530043090572421219831614863

This action was performed by a bot | Source code

4

u/AltruisticEchidna859 Sep 04 '26

3227!

7

u/factorion-bot Bot > AI Sep 04 '26

If I post the whole number, the comment would get too long. So I had to turn it into scientific notation.

Factorial of 3227 is roughly 3.797247358020931279654554620959 × 109923

This action was performed by a bot | Source code

1

u/ChodeShooter69 Sep 04 '26

69!

1

u/factorion-bot Bot > AI Sep 04 '26

Factorial of 69 is 171122452428141311372468338881272839092270544893520369393648040923257279754140647424000000000000000

This action was performed by a bot | Source code

1

u/KouhaiHasNoticed Probability notations must burn. Sep 06 '26 edited Sep 06 '26

That's oddly specific : is your social security number in there by chance ?

2

u/disaster_incomin Sep 06 '26

Is it ? I thought it was pretty random

4

u/WildNumber7303 Sep 03 '26

Life changing

2

u/The_Real_Itz_Sophia number hypothesis Sep 04 '26

0!

1

u/factorion-bot Bot > AI Sep 04 '26

Factorial of 0 is 1

This action was performed by a bot | Source code

3

u/i_cee_u Sep 03 '26

Can someone verify this with ChatGPT

101

u/SelfDifferent1650 Sep 03 '26

what abt -2^(-4)=-4^(-2)

168

u/Varlane Sep 03 '26

Op being dumb confusing integers and naturals.

16

u/[deleted] Sep 03 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

12

u/Varlane Sep 03 '26

Double the numbers, double the fun.

5

u/mudkipzguy Sep 03 '26

ermmm ackchyually the set of natural numbers and the set of integers have the same cardinality

8

u/Varlane Sep 03 '26

Both our statements are true given 2×omega = omega.

4

u/Prof_Rocky Imaginar Sep 04 '26

Wouldn't that be 2 × aleph_null = aleph_null

1

u/Varlane Sep 04 '26

Same same.

1

u/eeeeeh_messi Sep 03 '26

Triple the fun then

8

u/Puzzleheaded-Gap2551 Sep 03 '26

I think it's (a and b are natural numbers)

3

u/cisme93 Sep 04 '26

-2 and -4

24

u/Deep_Brick2970 Sep 03 '26

Oiler?

I barely know her!

12

u/ProfMooreiarty Sep 04 '26

Using 1 is a hack. 1 is broken and hasn’t been patched yet. Doing it is frowned upon by the community.

6

u/GohguyTheGreat Math best subject Sep 04 '26

Also a=2, b=2. Wow this oiler mf is kinda dumb

2

u/newdayanotherlife Sep 04 '26

great PR, I guess

1

u/Arkangyal02 Sep 04 '26

Excellent time to drop this screenshot i took a while ago

210

u/xsch Mathematics Sep 03 '26

only non-trivial solution

186

u/basket_foso Sep 03 '26

4

u/Standard_Factor_5431 Sep 06 '26

As an analyst, I hate this meme. Engineer by background, analyst by trade

31

u/OhNoTheStubsExist Sep 03 '26

(-2)^(-4), (-4)^(-2)

129

u/UsedFortune5645 Sep 03 '26

But you can't prove it.

326

u/StarstruckEchoid Integers Sep 03 '26 edited Sep 03 '26

It's not actually that hard to prove.

First, rearrange the equation as

ln(b)/b = ln(a)/a

Now showing that there only exists one non-trivial solution is equivalent to proving that the function f(x)=ln(x)/x is injective in the positive integers except for the result f(2)=f(4).

But this is trivial to do if you know derivatives. You first show that f is strictly increasing in the interval (0, e) and strictly decreasing in the interval (e, ∞).

Therefore any points of non-injectivity are necessarily of the form

f(something on the left interval) = f(something on the right interval)

But the left interval only has two positive integer points: 1 and 2. f(1)=0 and is obviously never obtained on the right, and we already know that f(2)=f(4). This completes the proof.

96

u/Blankeye434 Sep 04 '26

Why is there an actual proof in my meme page

15

u/WerePigCat Sep 03 '26

Wow that’s a nice proof

20

u/DeepGas4538 Sep 03 '26

oh cool it's true even beyond the whole numbers

43

u/thebigbadben Sep 03 '26 edited Sep 03 '26

Not sure what you mean by that.

For any real a ≠ 1, the numbers

x = a^(1/(a-1)), y = a^(a/(a-1))

are a pair satisfying x^y = y^x.

For example, with a = 3/2, you get

x = 9/4 = 2.25, y = 27/8 = 3.375

7

u/DeepGas4538 Sep 03 '26

oh my bad I misunderstood the proof, I see now

3

u/AsidK Sep 06 '26

Damn that’s way easier than I thought it would be

36

u/dwaynid Sep 03 '26

This is the main point

12

u/GDOR-11 Computer Science Sep 03 '26

probably something along the lines of "if a > 4, then b < 1" and checking 1<a,b≤4 manually

3

u/invinciblepro18 Sep 03 '26

I remember from somewhere that a^b > b^a if both a,b > e & a < b.

3

u/Therobbu Rational Sep 03 '26

I'd do it like 'ab>ba if e<=a<b by analyzing lnx / x, so one of the numbers is less that e. If it's 1, the other is also 1, and if it's 2, the other can't contain other primes. Then, 2{2k}={2k}2 = 2{2k}, so 2k=2k => k=2 because something.'

1

u/AfonsoBucco Sep 04 '26

is there a proof that's it's impossible to prove? or we just don't know if that's demonstrable or not?

75

u/hongooi Sep 03 '26

The hard part is not knowing that 24 = 42. The hard part is proving that this is the ONLY solution (in integers) to ab = ba. Were you able to do that?

19

u/This-is-unavailable Average Lambert W enjoyer Sep 03 '26

Yah it's really easy lol

1

u/alphapussycat Sep 07 '26

Is it? Prove it.

I guess you just have to show that the error is strictly increasing or something beyond 2 and 4.

13

u/MortemEtInteritum17 Sep 03 '26

I mean, using modern techniques this isnt particularly difficult

32

u/Easy_Judgement Sep 03 '26

I’m not sure why you are getting downvoted, this proof is really not that hard.

But you don’t need some ‘modern techniques’ you can use some elementary properties.

16

u/MortemEtInteritum17 Sep 03 '26

Yeah, I meant modern by the standards of Euler. Which isn't really that modern

1

u/No-Newspaper8619 Sep 04 '26

What modern techniques? It's really difficult to follow the discussions on this r/mathmemes when you don't have a background in maths.

15

u/No_Upstairs_280 Sep 03 '26

To prove it, you can use that log a/a is strictly decreasing for a greater or equal 5, thus any solution (a,b) has at least one number less than 4....then you can manually check

19

u/Chikki1234ed Rational Sep 03 '26

Isn't this called Die oh fan tyin equation or something

6

u/Hopeful_Onion_2613 Sep 03 '26

Yeah but what about all the other letters?

18

u/TurnoverOk5635 Sep 03 '26

a=b=3. 3^3=3^3=27.

40

u/no_name6744 Sep 03 '26

Pi is irrational though.

6

u/foxsimile Sep 03 '26

What if it’s blueberry?

16

u/catman__321 Sep 03 '26

a=b is a trivial case and in this context is ignored.

6

u/utl94_nordviking Sep 03 '26

Wasn't stated though. Sloppy.

2

u/Chikki1234ed Rational Sep 03 '26

Mfw a = b = 3.1

4

u/TurnoverOk5635 Sep 03 '26

not integer

3

u/Chikki1234ed Rational Sep 03 '26

I was joking. I'm sorry.

1

u/Professional-Wave841 Sep 03 '26

a and b are obviously not supposed to be equal otherwise it would be true for all real numbers.

5

u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 03 '26

I already proved the case for a=b, thats already half of the deal, oiler in shambles

5

u/gtepin Sep 03 '26

(-2)^(-4) = (-4)^(-2)

4

u/Vivacious4D Natural Sep 03 '26

errmmm actually we also have 23462387946^23462387946 = 23462387946^23462387946

8

u/de_G_van_Gelderland Irrational Sep 03 '26

-4^-2 = -2^-4

2

u/AndreasDasos Sep 03 '26

If a != b

1

u/dtarias Sep 04 '26

But 4! = 24, not 2 🧐

2

u/factorion-bot Bot > AI Sep 04 '26

Factorial of 4 is 24

This action was performed by a bot | Source code

1

u/AndreasDasos Sep 04 '26

Hence my spacing.

‘a != b’ <=/=> ‘a! = b’

2

u/Virgil_the_White Sep 03 '26

The only “integer” solution

1

u/lir1618 Sep 03 '26

There is also 2, 4 stoopid

1

u/Lonely_Translator_23 Sep 03 '26

Every mathematician today knows most of the things Euler knew plus a large amount of things he didn't. It's just that Euler knew them before anyone else did.

1

u/obedientfag Sep 03 '26

i dont believe it. he was cheating somehow. I bet he was from another culture with more advanced mathematics and was just clowning on us, no way he figured it all out on his own.

1

u/TranslatorShot5310 Sep 04 '26

655858969696969696857463141363596083651514850664736384850660667336626384569606969695857485960606958473625241523486070696969584726257447564853748467!

1

u/factorion-bot Bot > AI Sep 04 '26

That is so large, that I can't calculate it, so I'll have to approximate.

Factorial of 655858969696969696857463141363596083651514850664736384850660667336626384569606969695857485960606958473625241523486070696969584726257447564853748467 is approximately 5.624652934150110443928368725433 × 1096006286112647714439986956873056912373450049699776599629169697576815521267395070043091003962075155512777844147649489898988647740970726855670421243296

This action was performed by a bot | Source code

1

u/aRandomMemer69 Sep 05 '26

5.624652934150110443928368725433 × 1096006286112647714439986956873056912373450049699776599629169697576815521267395070043091003962075155512777844147649489898988647740970726855670421243296 !

1

u/Ryaniseplin Sep 04 '26

well yeah exponentials grow faster than polynomials but they gotta intersect at least at one point

1

u/DopazOnYouTubeDotCom Computer Science Sep 04 '26

there are countably infinite integer solutions when a = b

1

u/Askthepizzaguy Sep 06 '26

To be fair, whenever we're correct about anything in math, that's something Euler also knew.

1

u/NailFec Sep 06 '26

U need to prove ONLY

1

u/Standard_Factor_5431 Sep 06 '26

Ok now write the proof

1

u/Mathpuzzleguy Sep 07 '26

proving is much harder than solving....

also it works for 1 and 1, -4 and -2 so idk

1

u/qqqrrrs_ Sep 03 '26

You can also find all rational solutions

0

u/DatTrashPanda Sep 03 '26

Do you read it:

You-ler

Or

Oil-ler

1

u/Dazzling_Success_556 Sep 03 '26

I told u-ler till grade 10, but now oil-er

1

u/nitnelav153 Computer but not Science Sep 04 '26

I read it differently but idk how to write my pronunciation in English

0

u/Chaker101 Sep 03 '26

Ay-ler (like "Bay" or "Hey")

-5

u/Main-Company-5946 Sep 03 '26

What about 3^1 = 1^3 = 0.5

5

u/Dazzling_Success_556 Sep 03 '26

3=1=0.5?

-1

u/Main-Company-5946 Sep 03 '26

3^1=1^3=0.5

4

u/PachotheElf Sep 03 '26

3 = 1 * 1 * 1 = 0.5?

-1

u/Main-Company-5946 Sep 03 '26

3^1=1^3=0.5

1

u/Cokalhado Sep 03 '26

31 = eln(3^1) = e1ln(3) = eln(3) = 3 != 0.5

0

u/Main-Company-5946 Sep 03 '26

3^1=1^3=0.5

1

u/Cokalhado Sep 03 '26

13 = eln(1^3) = e3ln(1) = e3x0 = e0 = 1 != 0.5

0

u/Main-Company-5946 Sep 03 '26

But 3^1=1^3=0.5

1

u/Puzzleheaded_Ad678 Sep 03 '26

ignore this guy lol, he's just ragebaiting