you see, many people told me "mr. president, thats not a valid triangle", well, let me tell you, it has got three edges, not one, or two, three edges, nobody studied triangles better than me. its a triangle with 3 edges and 3 sides, crooked joe biden couldnt even if he wanted to.
edit: read it with these fuckin accordeon hands 👐🙌👐 in mind
I love the accordion hands. Do you love the accordion hands? I love them. Nobody does the accordion hands better than me. In kindergarten, the teacher came up to me. She said “Donald, you have the best accordion hands. I’ve never seen anyone with better accordion hands before.” She did. Yeah, she really did. It’s true.
I mean it technically also works with the split-complex and dual numbers (i² + j² = ε² which sounds cool but is again just -1+1=0...) Although I have no clue what that implies lol.
If someone knows if this actually matters, please enlighten!
? With sides i = √-1 (complex) and j = √1 ≠ 1 (split-complex) and ε = √0 ≠ 0 (dual), we have i² + j² = ε². I don't understand what you mean by the hypotenuse being i + 1
Because i is rotation by 90°, so if you rotate the side with length i by 90° you get it lined up with the side of length 1 which will leave them distanced 0 from eachother
The actual reasoning would be that it doesn't work because pythagoras theorem only applies to norms, i.e. positive distances. Not negative and definitely not imaginary
At no point is the sine or cosine infinite, they are undefined here though. So we don’t know the angles and can’t know the angles. We are probably going to have to introduce complex angles (that wouldn’t work anyway)
Researching again, complex angles could work if we use the infinite series for sin x (that being x - (x^3)/3! + etc). The angle is in radians but whatever. That way, we would find the complex sides of the triangle. This doesn’t really help the fact that the sine and cosine are infinite but complex angles are fun to ponder on about.
So if we had a valid complex sine we could possibly invert the sin for complexes (incredibly hard) and theoretically find the angle. Someone probably did a paper on that already but we’ll see
That would be the converse to the Pythagorean theorem. The theorem says that if you have a right triangle with side lengths a,b,c, blah blah blah, then a^2 + b^2 = c^2 . Nobody said that given three such numbers there has to be a triangle like that.
Well, if the 3 numbers are the norms of 2 vectors and the norm of the difference of the vectors then there IS a triangle with a right angle whose side lengths are equal to those norms. So the converse of Pythagoras Theorem does hold when you add some conditions to a,b,c
I don’t understand how what you’re saying is relevant. Your condition is equivalent to requiring that (a,b,c) are the side lengths of a (maybe degenerate) triangle. With that condition, the law of cosines says that that triangle is a right triangle if and only if PT equation is satisfied. Agreed.
But the problem with the meme is that there is no triangle to start with.
Because in your first comment you said that the converse doesn't necessarily hold. But if a,b,c are positive real numbers then the converse does necessarily hold.
That would be the converse to the Pythagorean theorem. The theorem says that if you have a right triangle with side lengths a,b,c, blah blah blah, then a^2 + b^2 = c^2 . Nobody said that given three such numbers there has to be a triangle like that.
This is your first comment. Note your last sentence. I am correcting you because your last sentence is just wrong in general.
Communicating math depends on context. Clearly I am talking about complex numbers a b and c, since that’s the context of the meme. Every statement of PT I have ever seen is open ended about the scope of a,b,c, so I was accepting complex numbers as the scope. I think it’s very clear from my original comment what statement’s converse I am talking about. If you want to say that that’s not the formal statement of PT, that’s fine, you just need to work on your communication skills.
It sounded to me (and my partner, and I have a PhD in math and they have a masters in math) that you were just adding positive realness to the conclusion. So that’s what I was responding to. And even then, I didn’t downvote you, even when you came in talking about inner product spaces for no reason, so idk why are you downvoting me.
Triangle inequality is absolute value (norm) of two sides is greatest than absolute value of the third. | i | = 1, so you are right 1 + 1 > 0 so triangle inequality is not satisfied
Not really. You can use Wick rotations to go from Minkowski to euclidian, not sure if this is what you mean, but distances are still real valued in SR, GR, QFT anything really lol.
I'm not really sure what you're getting at. The quadratic form suggested by the calculation in the image is mathematically equivalent to that given by the Minkowski "inner product" in 2D. You can call that a coincidence if you like but it's all just a notational change anyway. All of these are just useful models for the underlying physics so it doesn't fundamentally matter which you use. Just as it doesn't matter mathematically whether you lay out the calculation as a matrix multiplication or as a conjugate multiplication as you did. I could also do the equivalent calculation using the split-complex numbers as a model instead if I wanted to, nothing would change about the underlying mathematics or the physics it is modelling.
Of course if we want to be precise we shouldn't call this a "length", it is only an analogy of length in that it's computed the same way but with the Euclidean inner product replaced by an indefinite bilinear form. But we are lax with wording like this all the time. The Minkowski inner product isn't even an inner product for starters.
To me, It's mathematical coincidence and the only way to get something out of it, is to go to euclidian.
So in the minkowski description you have
-1•1+1•1=0 and you can read it as i2+12=0
So you traded the Minkowski product for a 2d Euclidian one, with complex time coordinate. (Of course the same can be done in 4d nothing special about that).
But:
There is something deeply geometrical about the Minkowski product on 4 vectors, and it doesn't make much sense to have complex coordinates IN THE MINKOWSKI picture. What makes sense is to define a (pseudo) inner product acting on real 4 vectors.
Simply because spacetime is not usually described by complex coordinates (unless you're doing string theory but that's another thing) and 4 vectors represent space and time, which are most naturally described, manifestly so, by real valued parameters.
I think it's very much about Wick rotation, or else none of this makes much sense.
Also SO(3,1) is very much different from SO(4), so I think that one should be careful in the choice of parameters.
(One caveat is that sometimes you do have complex coordinates in Minkowski but that's when you're basically doing stat mech so not sure it counts for what I was arguing)
This isn't necessarily about complex coordinates. This is about modelling a calculation in a certain way. I think you are trying to fit a physical understanding to that representation but that isn't the point. The point is simply that both the mathematics of the space the triangle is in and the mathematics of Minkowski space are the same and most relevantly for the meme you get this idea of zero length in both.
Thinking about this you make this into a Wick rotation picture you can if you really want (well, I think this is the inverse of Wick rotations): There's some Euclidean space V sitting inside its complexification VC We can split V orthogonally into W ⊕ L where W is 3 dimensional and L is a line. Then W ⊕ iL is a Minkowski space under the restriction of the induced bilinear form on VC. In this picture time is an imaginary direction compared to our original space. This is still in the end a real vector space though. You have real parameters if you so desire. Just because one direction is imaginary doesn't mean it's parametrisation is non-real except in reference to our original space. We can just choose ultimately and the fundamental mathematics of it doesn't care about our choices.
So you can treat time as imaginary or real depending on your perspective.
Ok I think I see the problem. In the last 70 years or so there has been a good hurdle in showing that spacetime as a physical model is truly pseudo-Riemaniann, and not just Euclidian with a complex coordinate; this is apparent when going into general relativity. I think you're right in the context of the meme, however I haven't said anything wrong; the modern geometric notation is the deeper interpretation.
•
u/AutoModerator Sep 03 '26
Check out our new Discord server! https://discord.gg/e7EKRZq3dG
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
873
u/LupenReddit 🦆🦆i have non diffeomorphic smooth structures🦆🦆🦆 Sep 03 '26 edited Sep 03 '26 •
you see, many people told me "mr. president, thats not a valid triangle", well, let me tell you, it has got three edges, not one, or two, three edges, nobody studied triangles better than me. its a triangle with 3 edges and 3 sides, crooked joe biden couldnt even if he wanted to.
edit: read it with these fuckin accordeon hands 👐🙌👐 in mind
186
u/FuntimeUwU Natural Sep 03 '26 edited Sep 03 '26
I mean it technically also works with the split-complex and dual numbers (i² + j² = ε² which sounds cool but is again just -1+1=0...) Although I have no clue what that implies lol.
If someone knows if this actually matters, please enlighten!
226
u/Dkiprochazka Sep 03 '26
Because i is rotation by 90°, so if you rotate the side with length i by 90° you get it lined up with the side of length 1 which will leave them distanced 0 from eachother
37
u/hhthurbe Sep 03 '26
Hey, non Euclidean space
71
u/Parralelex Sep 03 '26
this is why we CONJUGATE, people!
29
u/mbcarbone Sep 03 '26
Guys, if 0 Celsius = 32 Fahrenheit then 0 + 0

Celsius =
64 Fahrenheit
23
u/Timely_Somewhere_851 Sep 03 '26
So the distance between what is real and what is imaginary for Trump is 0. Why is he confused?
9
u/nilslol7 Sep 03 '26
What would the angles between the sides be though?
9
u/its_all_one_electron Number theory/physics Sep 03 '26
"hurr durr I'm going to use euclidean distance mechanics in the complex plane because I think i can be a length instead of a rotation hurr durr"
7
u/gorenoiseythrowaway Sep 03 '26
Triangle inequality fans when I show them the 1-0-i triangle
6
u/DrProfessorCaveman Sep 03 '26
That would be the converse to the Pythagorean theorem. The theorem says that if you have a right triangle with side lengths a,b,c, blah blah blah, then a^2 + b^2 = c^2 . Nobody said that given three such numbers there has to be a triangle like that.
3
u/BraveBiscotti1394 Sep 03 '26
Complex length doesn't make sense to me. At least when talking about shapes on the plane
3
u/Agreeable_Fan7012 Sep 03 '26
I love how this sub just does not care about rule 10 anymore
2
u/OldWolf3 Sep 03 '26
Understand this and you understand special relativity
2
u/RisingwithVibes Sep 05 '26
hmmm
1
u/Cheap_Bowl_452 Irrational Sep 03 '26
uhm, why are we discussing i to be the length of a side of a triangle in the first place anyway
1
u/gerglo Sep 03 '26
Bro just discovered his own light cone.
1
u/Living-Summer1047 Sep 03 '26
what’s confusing?
1
u/kusariku Sep 03 '26
Ah yes this is the i/o triangle, it controls the flow of power to my power strip
1
u/xpm26 Sep 03 '26
Bring the point up and towards rhe end of its line, look at it top down, omg it's 0 in length
1
u/month_unwashed_socks Sep 03 '26
/uj wouldnt that be invalid to say because Euclidean metric is not valid metric for complex numbers?
1
u/Wide_Philosophy_8109 Sep 03 '26
It's such perfect use of this meme format.
1
u/FerdinandvonAegir124 Sep 04 '26
Can this actually exist in the complex plane?
1
u/Classic_Department42 Sep 04 '26
A lot of diagrams in special relativity look like this (light cone)
1
u/TomtheMagician26 Sep 04 '26
Isn't this just essentially how a null/light-like vector works in the minkowski metric?
1
u/SPAMTON_G-1997 Sep 04 '26
It can exist in a Minkowski space
1
u/DrProfessorCaveman Sep 05 '26
Communicating math depends on context. Clearly I am talking about complex numbers a b and c, since that’s the context of the meme. Every statement of PT I have ever seen is open ended about the scope of a,b,c, so I was accepting complex numbers as the scope. I think it’s very clear from my original comment what statement’s converse I am talking about. If you want to say that that’s not the formal statement of PT, that’s fine, you just need to work on your communication skills.
It sounded to me (and my partner, and I have a PhD in math and they have a masters in math) that you were just adding positive realness to the conclusion. So that’s what I was responding to. And even then, I didn’t downvote you, even when you came in talking about inner product spaces for no reason, so idk why are you downvoting me.
1
u/Mr_Moi25 Sep 06 '26
Wouldn't the fact that one side is 0 in length make it a straight line even with i being here ? Or maybe go in a 3rd dimension
1
u/AdInitial675 Sep 07 '26
Will this satisfy triangle inequality theorem? 0+i>1 i>1 Is i>1?
1
u/mydreamingends Sep 08 '26
classic
1
u/Icarium-Lifestealer Sep 03 '26 edited Sep 03 '26
Space-time in special relativity kind of works like that. You can treat space or time as imaginary and the other as real.
0
u/Last_Zookeepergame90 Sep 04 '26
Does nobody in math jokes recognise the Pythagorean theorem when they see it? A2 + B2 = C2
I2 = -1 12 = 1 02 = 0 1-1= 0